News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Graphical Programming: I Really Hope This Is the Future by vidarh on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @07:18AM (#6552591)
People have tried this. Over and over and over. I love the idea, and I too have tried (and scrapped my effort), but it is an immensely difficult problem to tackle for a number of reasons:

- The moment you force a user to pick up the mouse, you have lost.

- It seems very compelling to augment the display with more information, but a lot of it is simply distracting, or reduce the density of relevant information that will fit on the page. There's a reason that even in most IDE's very little additional information beyond syntax highlighting have "stuck".

- Some weirdos (like me) won't touch tools that won't let me work over a dumb ssh connection and terminal when I need to, which is one of many reasons why...

- ... everything needs to have a sane textual format. Another reason is that it is essential to communicating about the code.

If you want to think about this, at least thoroughly review the long history of visual languages, as there are plenty of mistakes to repeat.

Re:Graphical Programming: I Really Hope This Is the Future by splawn on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @09:23AM (#6553051)
I think visual programming works well if its geared towards a specific problem set. In the past I used Talend ETL to generate small java programs and it worked well. However I couldn't imagine trying to do something big with a general visual language.
Re:Graphical Programming: I Really Hope This Is the Future by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @08:52AM (#6552907)
>There's a reason that even in most IDE's very little additional information beyond syntax highlighting have "stuck".

We are working on it; e.g. http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/people/smcdirm/liveprogr...

Re:Graphical Programming: I Really Hope This Is the Future by pcmonk on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @01:26PM (#6554756)
Oh, man, I wish I hadn't have posted this just before I went to bed.

At any rate, I understand your criticism. Regarding the mouse, I think you're almost right. In particular, you don't ever need to pick up the mouse to use my program -- there are no menus and no buttons. However, I do, on occasion, use the mouse to move around inside the tree structure. It's not necessary, but sometimes it can be the most natural way to interact. It's never a part of normal coding, but when I'm searching for a bug or surveying the structure of my code, it can be useful.

Regarding ssh, yeah, I know what you mean. I just hope that the benefits outweigh that unavoidable disadvantage.

Re:Graphical Programming: I Really Hope This Is the Future by ArbitraryLimits on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @09:27AM (#6553074)
> People have tried this. Over and over and over.

Seriously, it's the future and it has been for fifty years.

Re:Graphical Programming: I Really Hope This Is the Future by CmonDev on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @12:36PM (#6554349)
So it will probably be a part of final HTML5 specification. Worst case HTML5.1.