News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by socrates1998 on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:44AM (#6547518)
You are falling into the curve fitting trap that is epidemic in economics.

This is typically what economic "scientists" do, they find a formula that fits a lot of past data, then they publish it as science.

If they actually used it to make money, then it would be better, but that is almost never the case.

People who make money in the financial markets don't publish their winning formulas.

Why? For two reasons.

1) It probably isn't a hard rule or formula. It is probably a combination of factors that go into a decision that ultimately becomes a "gut feeling". Then, the best traders, usually get out if the trade doesn't work right away. This is because something unknown is acting on the trade, and since they have no idea what it is, they get out.

2) They want to use the formula to continue to make money, and since financial markets are very dynamic, they formula might not work if a bunch of people start using it.

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by crntaylor on Monday October 14, 2013 @11:07AM (#6547644)
Believe me, I am more than aware of the perils of overfitting!

The purpose of my comment isn't to say that using Shiller's P/E ratio is a good way to make money. In fact, I'm essentially saying the opposite - that while I think the research is good, it would be an inappropriate tool for most individual investors, because of the length of the required time horizon, and the length and magnitude of the drawdowns you'd have to endure.

As an aside, I believe that your criticisms of economics are misplaced. Certainly there is plenty of poor research and curve-fitting that gets published in journals of economics. But there are also extremely capable economists whose understanding of data-mining bias and overfitting is far in advance of yours or mine, and who are extremely careful when evaluating models using historical data.

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by Misterburns on Monday October 14, 2013 @11:37AM (#6547836)
Your statements about scientists are an overfit.

Randomized controlled trials: http://m.newyorker.com/reporting/2010/05/17/100517fa_fact_pa...

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by zmk_ on Monday October 14, 2013 @11:50AM (#6547922)
Insiders publish a sizable chunk of research. Not the currently winning formulas but something that stopped working or is too general a theory to be easily applied. E.g. for hedge funds this is one of the very few ways they can advertise to investors.