News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by rayiner on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:09AM (#6546995)
The term "economic sciences" is about as appropriate as the term "sanitation engineers." No controlled experiments = not a science. Relevant: https://www.lhup.edu/~dsimanek/cargocul.htm.
Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by davidw on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:23AM (#6547061)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observational_science

"An observational science is a science where it is not possible to construct controlled experiments in the area under study. For example, in astronomy, it is not possible to create or manipulate stars or galaxies in order to observe what happens. Other examples of necessarily observational sciences include geology, paleontology, epidemiology, and much of the social sciences."

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by tedunangst on Monday October 14, 2013 @02:24PM (#6548768)
I think there's a substantial difference in the extent of the observations. One sometimes gets the impression that a social scientist forms a theory, a culture with X will also have Y. Then they go around inspecting cultures until they find one with X. If it also has Y, boom, theory proved. If it doesn't, you say it's an outlier and move on to the next.

Astronomy and geology, on the hand, have theories that explain a larger set of observable behavior. Maybe you still have unknowns, like wtf is a quasar, but you can mostly point to any star or planet and have astronomy tell you how it works. If I pick a random human society and provide a brief description of it to a social scientist, my confidence that they will then accurately predict other facets of that society is pretty damn low.

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by yummyfajitas on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:50AM (#6547210)
I wonder how many people making this claim are willing to apply it to geology, oceanography, climate science, astronomy and epidemiology?
Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by r3m6 on Monday October 14, 2013 @11:00AM (#6547609)
Last time I check all the fields you mentioned do controlled experiments.

Example climate science: Have two models, and see which one predicts the next decades better.

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by yummyfajitas on Monday October 14, 2013 @11:20AM (#6547717)
How is that a controlled experiment, or any different from what economists do?

A controlled experiment in climate science/geophysics/etc would involve building two earths (or stars, in the case of astronomy), subjecting one to a treatment and using the other as a control.

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by jljljl on Monday October 14, 2013 @11:14AM (#6547685)
Don't good economists do the same?

Economists also attempt to test micro-economic principles through controlled, randomized experiments, similar to how psychology experiments are conducted.

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by tedunangst on Monday October 14, 2013 @02:15PM (#6548718)
Do you have a link to an example of somebody doing that? All the headlines regarding climate science seem to be about fitting a curve to previous decades' data.
Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by onebaddude on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:22AM (#6547050)
>No controlled experiments = not a science.

According to whom?

Wikipedia: Science (from Latin scientia, meaning "knowledge) is a systematic enterprise that builds and organizes knowledge in the form of testable explanations and predictions about the universe.

More importantly: who cares?

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by Misterburns on Monday October 14, 2013 @11:25AM (#6547749)
Randomized controlled trials to study poverty: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/books/authorinterviews/86...

Game. Set. Match.

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by widdershins on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:40AM (#6547158)
> in the form of testable explanations

i.e. controlled experiments.

> More importantly: who cares?

Anyone who's interested in the truth.

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by lotharbot on Monday October 14, 2013 @11:09AM (#6547657)
> "testable explanations ... i.e. controlled experiments"

Explanations can be tested through careful observation of uncontrolled environments.

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by jk4930 on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:35AM (#6547123)
Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by vdaniuk on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:09AM (#6547326)
If economic sciences produce economic models that are have better prediction power than models in previous iteration they are by definition useful. Your own disregard for this type of science is irrelevant.
Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by gutnor on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:47AM (#6547192)
Not sure what the status is, but at some point Valve (yes the video game company) wanted to use their games to test economic theories: http://blogs.valvesoftware.com/economics/it-all-began-with-a...

Obviously not the real thing, but interesting to note.

Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by dagw on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:18AM (#6547027)
Like it or not, the term social science is widely used, understood and accepted in the English language. Everybody knows what it means and understand that it's not the same as physical science.
Re:Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences 2013: Trendspotting in a... by zmk_ on Monday October 14, 2013 @12:07PM (#6548018)
There is a whole field of economics doing controlled experiments (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Experimental_economics). Most of the behavioural economics is derived from evidence from these.

Otherwise, a lot of care is taken to identify causal relationships in economics (e.g. thorugh instrumenting explanatory variables).