Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F...
by davidwoof1 on Sunday October 13, 2013 @12:46PM
(#6543163)
Umm, I seriously doubt that "almost everyone" in the state of Georgia in 1832 was eligble to participate in this lottery.
Families who won the lottery reverted to the mean in a generation or two
A small event known in the US as the Civil War, which completely decimated the economy of Georgia, just might have had something to do with this.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F...
by brownbat on Monday October 14, 2013 @05:31PM
(#6549781)
> Umm, I seriously doubt that "almost everyone" in the state of Georgia in 1832
Touche. My point was that participation was extensive and varied. It remains to be seen whether or not this effect holds for women or minorities, but even if it didn't, that would only support my main point: context matters.
> A small event known in the US as the Civil War... just might have had something to do with this.
The authors address the Civil War in the piece. It would indeed have been a weird oversight for economic historians studying the pre-war South if they hadn't, if that just never occurred to them as relevant.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F...
by mertd on Sunday October 13, 2013 @11:47PM
(#6545294)
Almost everyone was indeed eligible. Freakonomics did an episode on it, and there is a study on this affair since it was pretty well documented.
Families who won the lottery reverted to the mean in a generation or two: http://home.uchicago.edu/~bleakley/Bleakley_Ferrie_Intergen....
(To be fair, educational attainment and lifetime earnings of offspring are a different measure of success though, so that probably accounts for some of the discrepancy in the results as well.)