News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by asperous on Saturday October 12, 2013 @09:08PM (#6541047)
I think the context is super important here. "gave cash to groups of young people so they could learn a trade and start their own businesses." In Uganda.

These people were pretty much starving before. “These were mostly farmers who had work 10 to 20 hours a week and earned about $1 a day,"

With different people, culture, attitudes, environment the effect might be completely different in America, for example.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by breischl on Saturday October 12, 2013 @09:34PM (#6541117)
In addition...

<blockquote>To get the cash, applicants had to form a group with others in their village and submit a proposal showing how they planned to use the money</blockquote>

It's not clear how selective they were, but it does sound more involved than just "fill out this form and get your cash." So it's a group of people that were selected, or at least self-selected, for some minimum amount of initiative and ambition.

The title of the article invites comparisons to social safety net programs in the developed world, but this sounds more like a combination of the educational and small business grant programs. It also seems like it would not be broadly applicable - you couldn't just carpet an area with $400 grants and expect the same kind of success rate.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by ma2rten on Saturday October 12, 2013 @09:50PM (#6541145)
In addition...

The simple fact that someone came after those people to check what they did with their money, for the purpose of the research, probably influenced the result (at least if they knew or suspected that beforehand). If they said they would use the money for business, but then instead spend it alcohol and gambling, that would be very embarrassing.

If on the other hand, a program like exists this for a long time and everyone knows nobody will check what you do with the money, abuse would become very likely, imo.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by notahacker on Sunday October 13, 2013 @06:33AM (#6542126)
Absolutely. The problem with these kind of studies is how difficult it is to generalise from them. One of the cited examples concludes making people accountable for the money was less efficient even though accountable people spent the money better because it cost "up to $1800" per $150 loan for followup studies. That hires a well-educated person for a year in a developing country, which strongly suggests that you'd reach a wholly different conclusion if the programme was designed and administered 100% locally. Of course, there's also the issue that if a particular group doesn't have any followup studies associated with the research, then observations of how they spent the money are inevitably less accurate.

Then there's the simple observation that repayable grants can be passed on to others (less admin costs) and are sustainable on a larger scale in an economy. Teach a man to fish and his interest repayments can teach his neighbours to fish, provided those neighbours also reasonably expect to get a positive return on the rod they invest in. That latter bit is important in assuming the net effect doesn't involve very expensive fishing rods and depleted fish stocks...

Whilst loan based aid is not unproblematic (there's some hideously expensive administration and profiteering in some microfinance problems, and poor people many people do use them as expensive consumer loans) the same technology that earns Kenyan grants such rave reviews for their effectiveness can also be applied to strings-attached microfinance: M-PESA can potentially cut the cost of receiving microloan repayments even more effectively than it cuts corruption in doling out the aid. Just because the desperately poor don't spend all their grant money on prostitutes and alcohol (which isn't that surprising if you've ever visited a developing country) doesn't necessarily mean they can't be efficiency helped in other ways

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by waps on Saturday October 12, 2013 @10:48PM (#6541295)
I think you've just hit the nail on the head. Gifts in this program have the same function as loans would traditionally have : they are supposed to be invested in improving one's life. They were obviously not free, the money was traded for promises that carry a social cost if one doesn't deliver.

A basic income would have no such effect. If it's enough to live on, why would everyone invest it in becoming a better and more capable individual ? (note the question is not "anyone", but "everyone". The aggregate effect of free money is what will determine the outcome. Not what exceptional individuals might achieve with it, but what a lazy drunkard would achieve with it matters)

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by klenwell on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:25PM (#6541376)
Ah yes, the undeserving poor. Alfred P. Doolittle gave a pretty good accounting of what they might do with it in Shaw's Pygmalion:

I ask you, what am I? I'm one of the undeserving poor: that's what I am. Think of what that means to a man. It means that he's up agen middle class morality all the time. If there's anything going, and I put in for a bit of it, it's always the same story: "You're undeserving; so you can't have it." But my needs is as great as the most deserving widow's that ever got money out of six different charities in one week for the death of the same husband. I don't need less than a deserving man: I need more. I don't eat less hearty than him; and I drink a lot more. I want a bit of amusement, cause I'm a thinking man. I want cheerfulness and a song and a band when I feel low. Well, they charge me just the same for everything as they charge the deserving. What is middle class morality? Just an excuse for never giving me anything... Don't you be afraid that I'll save it and spare it and live idle on it. There won't be a penny of it left by Monday: I'll have to go to work same as if I'd never had it. It won't pauperize me, you bet. Just one good spree for myself and the missus, giving pleasure to ourselves and employment to others, and satisfaction to you to think it's not been throwed away. You couldn't spend it better.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by karlmdavis on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:50PM (#6541436)
Don't this:

> The aggregate effect of free money is what will determine the outcome.

And this:

> Not what exceptional individuals might achieve with it, but what a lazy drunkard would achieve with it matters)

Contradict each other? The "aggregate effect" = "lazy drunkards" + the effect of "exceptional individuals" + the effect of everyone else. So it really isn't the lazy drunkards that matter; it's the overall effect that does. If, on average, it improves society then isn't that a win?

Very often, when talking about basic incomes and similar programs, people seem to say things like "twice as many people will take advantage of the system and be lazy." To me, that's not a sufficient criticism: it all depends on the percentages. If a program increases the percentage of bottom feeders from 1% to 2%, say, but also doubles the quality of life of everyone else, that would be a huge win to me. Obviously, the numbers I chose in my example are probably unrealistic, which just further illustrates how important it is to actually determine what the numbers are/will be.

[deleted]
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by icebraining on Sunday October 13, 2013 @03:50AM (#6541837)
That's the measure of effectiveness from a bourgeois perspective, who considers themselves superior because their families are more endowed.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by waps on Sunday October 13, 2013 @12:09AM (#6541470)
You're right. That was wrong. I obviously meant it's the effect of A plus B.

It would depend on the amount of "bottom feeders". That's a bad way to define it though, "non-productives" might be better, since it would include pensioners, children, students (including people who go back to studying if this program is introduced, but are older than 0-24 years), really ill people, ... mostly not people I'd define as bottom feeders.

I would say that it's a lot larger than 1-2%. Let's assume that a lower bound on the non-productive people would be 30% of the total (which would mean tax levels need to be, at bare minimum . I would say that various factors are going to make that close to 50% over a period of time that's not very long.

Suppose you'd have the same tax level for these things as you currently have for social programs + medical programs (~50% of total taxes), then here's how much it could be (ignoring administration costs, which would take another bite):

Non-active population => basic income possible using 50% of govt. budget

30% => 11,249

40% => 9,642

50% => 8,035

60% => 6,428

70% => 4,821

(the current labor force participation rate is 65%. Since that is likely to drop, prudence would suggest you take the 50% or 60% figure as realistic. Increases in the govt. budget dedicated to this cannot make these numbers rise by a significant amount. So I would think the 30% figure is the maximum attainable even if the military were to be defunded)

Since even the largest of these numbers is only barely sufficient to live + insurance + ... is this really worth it ? This amount is not of the level that it's going to do what this program needs to do to improve our economic situation : give the poor disposable income.

The basic problem we have is of a different nature. We do not have any economic reason for 70% of the world population to be alive, and that number is growing fast. In the US that number is currently amazingly low, but it's bound to rise as well.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by karlmdavis on Monday October 14, 2013 @12:53PM (#6548318)
> It would depend on the amount of "bottom feeders". That's a bad way to define it though, "non-productives" might be better, since it would include pensioners, children, students (including people who go back to studying if this program is introduced, but are older than 0-24 years), really ill people, ... mostly not people I'd define as bottom feeders.

You're absolutely right, thanks for the correction.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by Freeboots on Sunday October 13, 2013 @05:43AM (#6542017)
The selection process is usually along the lines of 'the poorest of the poor'. Organizations such as this identify an area or ethnic group, then a village, then a family. The recipients are selected, then approached, in such a way that minimizes self selection. The idea is to bring a poor family up to the standard of their slightly less poor neighbours. Then the village up to the standard of other villages. then the province. etc.

I personally dont see the invited comparison, at least not directly in the title, given the context of a 'Global Impact' article. This could be simply my lens, and yours. I work in development field (mostly cambodia), so i automatically apply it to what i see here. You seem more involved with the situation in US(?) an rightly say that it would not apply in the same way.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by brownbat on Sunday October 13, 2013 @11:53AM (#6542974)
Context is definitely relevant. In 1832, Georgia held a lottery to allocate all of its unclaimed land. Almost everyone in the state participated. The value of each parcel of land was immense, life-changing for most of the people in the lottery.

Families who won the lottery reverted to the mean in a generation or two: http://home.uchicago.edu/~bleakley/Bleakley_Ferrie_Intergen....

(To be fair, educational attainment and lifetime earnings of offspring are a different measure of success though, so that probably accounts for some of the discrepancy in the results as well.)

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by davidwoof1 on Sunday October 13, 2013 @12:46PM (#6543163)
Umm, I seriously doubt that "almost everyone" in the state of Georgia in 1832 was eligble to participate in this lottery.

Families who won the lottery reverted to the mean in a generation or two

A small event known in the US as the Civil War, which completely decimated the economy of Georgia, just might have had something to do with this.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by brownbat on Monday October 14, 2013 @05:31PM (#6549781)
> Umm, I seriously doubt that "almost everyone" in the state of Georgia in 1832

Touche. My point was that participation was extensive and varied. It remains to be seen whether or not this effect holds for women or minorities, but even if it didn't, that would only support my main point: context matters.

> A small event known in the US as the Civil War... just might have had something to do with this.

The authors address the Civil War in the piece. It would indeed have been a weird oversight for economic historians studying the pre-war South if they hadn't, if that just never occurred to them as relevant.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by mertd on Sunday October 13, 2013 @11:47PM (#6545294)
Almost everyone was indeed eligible. Freakonomics did an episode on it, and there is a study on this affair since it was pretty well documented.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by repiret on Monday October 14, 2013 @11:43AM (#6547877)
From the abstract of the article:

"...which had nearly universal participation among adult white males."

White males is a lot less than almost everyone. Its not even most people.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by thrownaway2424 on Saturday October 12, 2013 @10:17PM (#6541215)
I don't think it's that different from the situation we have here in America. A lot of people are working low-wage dead-end jobs because they their kids or siblings need to eat. With only a little bit of extra money those people could stop working their jobs, learn new skills, and get better jobs.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by jbooth on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:21PM (#6541362)
Of course it's incredibly different. I won't trivialize how shitty life in the ghetto is if you don't trivialize how shitty life as a subsistence farmer surrounded by simmering ethnic conflicts.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by ekianjo on Saturday October 12, 2013 @10:22PM (#6541219)
People are not starving in America.Please visit poor countries before drawing parrallels.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by up_and_up on Saturday October 12, 2013 @10:44PM (#6541279)
Sorry, but people are starving in America: http://abcnews.go.com/Health/US/hunger-children-america-slow...

Are you aware that many kids in America grow up without access to even a basic grocery store and decent nutrition? Starvation can be slow and steady.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by cjbprime on Saturday October 12, 2013 @10:59PM (#6541314)
Yes, but the starving child in Boston in your article went to a nearby world-class hospital where he was given free food.

Poverty exists in the US; extreme poverty (living under the purchasing power equivalent of USD $1.25 per day) is extremely rare (<0.5%) in the US, whereas it describes 50% of people in subsaharan Africa.

http://www.un.org/esa/socdev/rwss/docs/2010/chapter2.pdf

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by Freeboots on Sunday October 13, 2013 @05:52AM (#6542030)
Im not sure if you're taking purchasing power into account, but if not, be aware that US$1 a day is doable in many countries, but very much not in america. Poverty is relative, just saying.

And for what its worth, i live in cambodia and have lived on such a budget, albeit only for 3 months.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by up_and_up on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:12PM (#6541348)
Extremely rare? 313900000 * 0.005 = 1,569,500 people living on $1.25/day in the USA?
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by jlgreco on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:20PM (#6541361)
That seems like a reasonable definition of "extremely rare". Platinum is extremely rare, several hundred tons of it are mined every year. (A number that sounds incredibly heavy, but pales in comparison to the numbers of common metals.)

Half a percentage is "extremely rare" compared to numbers like 50%. Most people in America have absolutely no experience with the sort of poverty that is nearly inescapable in many underdeveloped counties.

If you can't get over the "~1.5 million” thing, just consider that this is comparable to the poplulation of The Bronx.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by aspensmonster on Sunday October 13, 2013 @12:22AM (#6541503)
Well, I can see it didn't take long at all for the Oppression Olympics to get underway.

Edit: -1? Impress me.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by tsotha on Sunday October 13, 2013 @01:41AM (#6541626)
Predictable as the sunrise in these kinds of posts.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by prostoalex on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:28PM (#6541386)
How can that number be true if food stamp benefits net roughly $200, and earned income tax credit is $487 for a single person? Both numbers go up significantly if children are involved.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by iambateman on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:49PM (#6541431)
Very easily...if people don't have access to those services.

Illegal immigrants, homeless with no ID.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by yummyfajitas on Sunday October 13, 2013 @03:34AM (#6541814)
Hunger among children is a bigger problem for wealthier families (earning >400% of the poverty line) than for the poor.

http://mchb.hrsa.gov/chusa11/hstat/hsa/pages/221oo.html

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by ekianjo on Sunday October 13, 2013 @03:57AM (#6541851)
Sorry, your first world starvationhas nothing to do with the thurd world poverty you have probably never seen in your life. Stop spreading myths or half truths and get out and see for yourself what i amtalking about.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by up_and_up on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @10:32AM (#6553399)
I have spent time in India, Ecuador, Bolivia, Peru and Mexico. I have definitely seen poverty.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by ekianjo on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @10:38AM (#6553440)
Then you should know enough to see the difference between the poverty these and back in the US. In some of the countries you mentioned some people die because they are poor. In the US, you usually don't die of that poverty. You don't live very well, you struggle to make a living and to eat well, but you don't just disappear and die like that.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by JulianMorrison on Sunday October 13, 2013 @05:29PM (#6544220)
At what point does it count as starving? When they don't eat for a week at the end of the month so they can make rent? When they have chronic malnourishment? When they manage to live by visiting food banks or soup kitchens? When they dumpster-dive for discarded food? All this happens in America.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by slurry on Sunday October 13, 2013 @10:44AM (#6542735)
People aren't really starving in Kenya, either.

It's not a rich country, but people eat.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by Freeboots on Sunday October 13, 2013 @06:02AM (#6542055)
ikr, people in this thread seem to be reading this into the context of the 'living wage' idea floating around. But its nothing like that. These are one off grants to people living in completely different circumstances. In developing countries whose governments are not able to provide basics most developed countries take for granted.

The living wage is an income, not a one off. And its being talked about in terms of developed countries whose government would distribute said income.

The difference is easy to see when you consider what you would do in each situation.

Situation A) You are given 6 months pay to increase your standard of living. Many/most people would invest such a windfall. They would pay debts, buy land, stocks. Many would treat themselves to a nice car or something, but i dont think people who NEED that money would do so.

Situation B) You are told that from now on you will get $1000/m. Forever. Welp. Im going to cut my hours and go for a drink. Again, many people would treat this as a windfall to be saved. But some (more than situation A) would spend it, knowing they will get more next month.

Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by hannibal5 on Sunday October 13, 2013 @09:58AM (#6542592)
In America, increasing the minimum wage would help the majority of poor who are working poor.
Re:Research Finds Outright Grants of Cash are an Effective F... by swasheck on Sunday October 13, 2013 @10:42AM (#6542728)
Not necessarily. The accompanying effects (things like the impact on the standard of living, cumulative expenses for the employer) may actually make their situation worse. If their employer must have the role fulfilled, then their costs increase which means decisions such as raising the price of the good/service, reducing operational costs (lower quality, or fewer workers), outsourcing, etc.

I'm all for people being paid a fair wage, but just think that a solution that focuses on one symptom may only make things worse. I think that the real problem is that, for the most part, the economy is so sick that decision-makers are either too afraid or too incapable of doing a proper RCA and triage of the problem. It feels like we've been treating symptoms and not the problem(s).