Re:AbsurdJS – JavaScript based CSS preprocessor
by lux on Friday October 11, 2013 @08:36PM
(#6536712)
This is a really powerful idea and makes a lot of sense.
It's as flexible and readable as any CSS preprocessor I've seen, possibly more so because it's in a syntax I won't forget because I program in it all day.
And it's trivial to integrate into any JavaScript setup because it's just JavaScript. Brilliant!
Re:AbsurdJS – JavaScript based CSS preprocessor
by jcampbell1 on Friday October 11, 2013 @09:21PM
(#6536851)
I completely agree.
When I get a chance, I am going to attempt thing that are impossible with SASS and LESS. There are things that are impossible such as using multiply and screen to create a button of an arbitrary gradient and color that looks good.
This is the first preprocessor that is capable of doing something other than just saving keystrokes.
Re:AbsurdJS – JavaScript based CSS preprocessor
by SkyMarshal on Saturday October 12, 2013 @02:02AM
(#6537484)
Absolutely, and it takes CSS (preprocessors at least) closer to the LISP ideal of code is data and data is code.
Now that I've seen it, in hindsight I'm struck with several thoughts: 1) in hindsight it seems so obvious, 2) why didn't I think of this, and 3) LESS/SASS/Stylus/etc are obsolete.
Re:AbsurdJS – JavaScript based CSS preprocessor
by jonnyscholes on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:11PM
(#6550797)
Yeah totally agree. Can also lead to very unreadable sass files to if your not very careful. Whilst teaching new devs where I work we ask them not to use @extend until we suggest it one a few reviews have been done.
I guess it's trying to be a more flexible version of LESS/SASS by leveraging the full power of JavaScript. I've never felt that LESS was really lacking in power... I'm curious what others think. But interesting idea.
Re:AbsurdJS – JavaScript based CSS preprocessor
by jeremiep on Friday October 11, 2013 @08:54PM
(#6536772)
One use case would be to create server-side 'widgets' just like Yesod does.
The basic idea is that they combine the document, style and scripting in a single reusable component. Pages are then built by composing these widgets together and can finally be used as templates when responding to requests.
Re:AbsurdJS – JavaScript based CSS preprocessor
by paulannesley on Friday October 11, 2013 @07:36PM
(#6536495)
I think it makes a lot of sense to build the features of Less/Sass etc on top of a well-known parser/interpreter (JS), rather than inventing a new one from scratch.
I already feel like I understand how AbsurdJS works better than I understand Less/Sass, for that reason.
Re:AbsurdJS – JavaScript based CSS preprocessor
by tomjakubowski on Saturday October 12, 2013 @06:55AM
(#6538285)
Off the top of my head, order in CSS is only important when a property is defined multiple times for a given selector, either within the same block or in separate ones. Like these examples:
Re:AbsurdJS – JavaScript based CSS preprocessor
by krasimirtsonev on Saturday October 12, 2013 @08:19AM
(#6538459)
Actually you care about the ordering if you have same properties applied for same selector. However, AbsurdJS hides this and automatically calculate the latest defined value. And that's what it goes in the compiled file. I need to spend some time using the library to be sure that such problem is actually solved. So, shortly: I can't 100% guarantee that you will not have problems with that.
the only difference is using JSON and JS input vs. a CSS string, but he could have easily written that in less than 100 lines vs an entirely separate framework.
Re:AbsurdJS – JavaScript based CSS preprocessor
by nilved on Friday October 11, 2013 @06:58PM
(#6536364)
I like the idea. People should note that this doesn't mean mixing your CSS into your JavaScript necessarily - you can precompile CSS just like you would with S*SS.
Re:AbsurdJS – JavaScript based CSS preprocessor
by mrfancypants on Saturday October 12, 2013 @01:30AM
(#6537423)
It doesn't seem to handle vendor-specific prefixes (-webkit, -moz, etc). I suppose you could write your own mixins (plugins) to handle that, but still, a shame.
Re:AbsurdJS – JavaScript based CSS preprocessor
by krasimirtsonev on Saturday October 12, 2013 @03:14AM
(#6537644)
Hello guys. Thanks for the comments. The next things which I'm going to do is to start packing components. One of the big problems which I have for a long time, is the fact that I have to deliver html, css and javascript. Usually they are placed in different places and I have to take care to put them in the browser. With AbsurdJS I could send the javascript logic and the css together.
Re:AbsurdJS – JavaScript based CSS preprocessor
by PLejeck on Saturday October 12, 2013 @01:02AM
(#6537389)
This seems like it would be good for filling a similar role to LLVM, providing a framework to take an object and turn it into CSS. I'm not so sure it makes sense as a language to directly use: JSON is nice as a data serialization format, but it's not very fun to author complex things in it.
It's as flexible and readable as any CSS preprocessor I've seen, possibly more so because it's in a syntax I won't forget because I program in it all day.
And it's trivial to integrate into any JavaScript setup because it's just JavaScript. Brilliant!
When I get a chance, I am going to attempt thing that are impossible with SASS and LESS. There are things that are impossible such as using multiply and screen to create a button of an arbitrary gradient and color that looks good.
This is the first preprocessor that is capable of doing something other than just saving keystrokes.
Now that I've seen it, in hindsight I'm struck with several thoughts: 1) in hindsight it seems so obvious, 2) why didn't I think of this, and 3) LESS/SASS/Stylus/etc are obsolete.
...or is there some use case for CSS-in-your-JS that I can't quite manage to imagine? I'm straining my brain to think of one...
Edit: more info at http://davidwalsh.name/write-css-javascript
I guess it's trying to be a more flexible version of LESS/SASS by leveraging the full power of JavaScript. I've never felt that LESS was really lacking in power... I'm curious what others think. But interesting idea.
The basic idea is that they combine the document, style and scripting in a single reusable component. Pages are then built by composing these widgets together and can finally be used as templates when responding to requests.
Also, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JavaScript_Style_Sheets anybody? ;-)
I already feel like I understand how AbsurdJS works better than I understand Less/Sass, for that reason.
the only difference is using JSON and JS input vs. a CSS string, but he could have easily written that in less than 100 lines vs an entirely separate framework.
EDIT: Krasimir Tsonev's article not David Walsh
I guess I wouldn't bee too upset with CSS being replaced by json in the future. It makes sense in a way of using fewer languages.
On the other hand Javascript should probably be replaced by something better too.