News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by BWStearns on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:35AM (#6531556)
>> "stated under oath when examined by the defense counsel that there was no harm whatsoever"

First, I don't actually believe that the Wikileaks releases (Manning's) really caused that much damage, in fact we came out smelling like roses in most cases, our allies however frequently looked like asses (think Saudis wanting to tag gitmo inmates with bird trackers).

The thing here to consider is 1) by the Wikileaks statement above it would seem that the purpose was never to counter US interests [calling bullshit here, support or oppose Assange/WL != pro US gov], so it is disingenuous at best to us the lack of damaging information to suggest that WL was not an anti-USG group.

Is the Disney film less than fully accurate? I'd bet so, it's a commercial endeavor.

I'm more disappointed that Wikileaks chose to focus on the USG and GB than all of the upstanding states around the world like Syria, Russia, North Korea, and China. Sure, when the US fucks up, call us out on it, that's part of an informed democracy.

WL/Assange pretended to be the vanguard of transparency (and when they first announced such ambitions I actually was rooting for them). Instead of focusing on the most opaque and oppressive governments, they focused on finding the warts on governments that by and large are respective of human rights. Russia? Fuck it you get a pass because Assange doesn't have ricin-proof pants yet. NK? Do you know how hard it is to get documents from there?

</rant>

Seriously though, I am disappointed. When they stood up I thought they were going to actually go after folks who actively opposed free speech and human rights. Instead they went after the targets that were easiest to create media stories out of. I would like for Wikileaks to get the memos on the election rigging in Azerbaijan, I would like for them to get the UN memos between RF and Syria. To borrow the line from Rick, I don't mind a whistle blower, I just mind a cut rate one.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by CatMtKing on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:06AM (#6531806)
I haven't browsed through much of Wikileaks, butt I was under the impression that they do leak documents from many governments, not solely the US or GB. However, is it a surprise that the documents that get the most press are US-related? And, after all, the bigger the government, the bigger the paper trail / surface area for leaks.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by BWStearns on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:18AM (#6531954)
There are pathetically few documents on WL from governments with truly atrocious human rights records. There are more documents from fucking fraternities than oppressive governments. Governments are pretty reliable, there are documents even in the most dysfunctional governments.

Wikileaks is less interested in publishing these than anything that is embarrassing to the US/UK. I know I'm throwing HN Karma down the toilet here, but really, while the behavior of the USG is far far from ideal, the behavior of Wikileaks is also so, and in a more insidious manner since its silence on more oppressive governments gives them validation.

Also for those downvoting, please see my other posts. I am not blindly pro-USG or anti-whistleblower. I have more complicated feelings regarding Snowden but wrt Wikileaks I have been disappointed in their focus. I feel this is a valid concern as the obsession with taking the US down a peg also gives validation to those oppressing their own people. Taking the US down a peg and denouncing real atrocities should not be incompatible. I feel that Wikileaks has sacrificed the more valuable duty of the latter in favor of the former.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by phaemon on Friday October 11, 2013 @07:31AM (#6532430)
> There are pathetically few documents on WL from governments with truly atrocious human rights records.

So what? I seriously don't understand your position. I don't really care that there's nothing about North Korea on Wikileaks simply because:

1. Everyone knows North Korea has an appalling government. "North Korean Government Official Caught Accepting Bribes" would quite possibly be the stupidest news story ever.

2. I don't live in North Korea. I care about what the UK government is doing, because that's where I live!

I take it you're from the USA. Wikileaks are telling you what your government is doing, and instead of thanking them, you're annoyed that you can't ignore what's going on? You're more concerned about some weird "embarrassment"? Seriously, WTF?

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by rtpg on Friday October 11, 2013 @09:50AM (#6533044)
Everyone knows that the NSA spies, but having all the physical proof of exactly what happens helps the cause doesn't it?

NK might not be useful, but in countries with some amount of information exchange with the rest of the world like Russia, imagine if there were more solid cases of corruption against specific people in power?

We say that WL helped trigger the Arab Spring, so why not the same in Russia?

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by belorn on Friday October 11, 2013 @10:49AM (#6533446)
> Everyone knows that the NSA spies, but having all the physical proof of exactly what happens helps the cause doesn't it?

I guess that is why anyone who mention said knowledge was labeled as conspiracy nut and tinfoil hat. /sarcasm

Please lets not rewrite history. People did not know that US diplomats was used as spies, or that NSA planted bugs in EU buildings, or had secret deals with mail and social networks that gave them privileged information under secret terms. People did not know about secret assassination lists.

Surely a lot of people suspected things, but knowing is an other cup of tea here.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by varjag on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:37AM (#6532199)
Here, have an upvote. I am a citizen of Belarus, and disgusted by Assange.

http://www.tabletmag.com/jewish-news-and-politics/79749/wiki...

He clearly has an agenda, which can be summarized as anti-American and pro-not-giving-a-fuck-about-anyone.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by belorn on Friday October 11, 2013 @10:37AM (#6533360)
Manning leaked documents to Wikileaks, and Wikileaks gave the documents to a journalist, seeking help in selecting what information could be safely given out to the public. The journalist then gave out the password in a book, making all documents available to the public, which then caused problems for people named in the leaked documents.

Please point out which people in those steps of events you are disgusted by, and what you would have done instead in their shoes.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by varjag on Friday October 11, 2013 @10:47AM (#6533430)
Where does it come from? His anger at any attempts of editing out parts of the cables is well documented by different people he cooperated with:

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/30/magazine/30Wikileaks-t.htm...

"He was angry that we declined to link our online coverage of the War Logs to the WikiLeaks Web site, a decision we made because we feared — rightly, as it turned out — that its trove would contain the names of low-level informants and make them Taliban targets. "

Also, I would go as far as to say that his deputy's trip to KGB HQ in Minsk was totally unnecessary.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by foobarqux on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:22PM (#6535311)
The redactions Assange objected to were those that implicated corporations and political figures. The Guardian claimed that they made the redactions from fear of libel lawsuits.

Only after Leigh published the password for the cables, effectively making them public, did Wikileaks post them to its website.

If you have evidence that Assange systematically published cables of informant names before the password was published by Leigh please share it.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by mpyne on Friday October 11, 2013 @12:25PM (#6534118)
Why is it that the documents provided for the journalist's use were still publically accessible months after the journalist had confirmed receipt? That's a good question for starters, as it's possible the journalist could have later been hacked and lost control the password, had his laptop stolen in an apartment burglary, or any number of other legit accidents.

Proper INFOSEC involves not leaving information where it doesn't need to be for any longer than it needs to be there, encrypted or not.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by varjag on Saturday October 12, 2013 @06:34AM (#6538225)
Because he put them on torrents later, encrypted, but reused the same damn password. It's playing God while lacking skills.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by vidarh on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:43AM (#6532022)
You are jumping to a lot of conclusions regarding WL's agenda, when it is quite possible the reason most of the documents are from the US/UK simply because they are reasonably easy to get leaks from compared to more brutal regimes.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by BWStearns on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:49AM (#6532047)
This is no doubt true (it's easier in the US than NK), but as I commented below, they posted that they had some stuff on Russia, and then shut the hell up about it. What is the takeaway?
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by algorias on Friday October 11, 2013 @06:12AM (#6532267)
Sometimes, painful compromises need to be made? Pick your battles, fight one bad guy at a time. Would you rather have Snowden in jail?

Also, as a non-US citizen, I think it's justified targeting the US specifically, because they have an inordinate amount of influence on global policies (basically, they force their laws on everybody else through so-called trade agreements)

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by mpyne on Friday October 11, 2013 @12:27PM (#6534131)
The change in WikiLeaks's tune regarding Russia far predates Snowden.

Assange was using Russian state media (RT) as a mouthpiece for a television show of his before Snowden as well. I believe one of his first interviews was with the leader of Hezbollah, of all people.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by algorias on Saturday October 12, 2013 @11:01AM (#6538939)
I stand corrected. My general point still holds, though.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by speeder on Friday October 11, 2013 @07:55AM (#6532523)
I think.being anti-US is fine, since it is the most evil.country ever, that including disappeared people here. Sometimes I think.US will stop.being assholes and would return the friends of my writing teacher for example, but I know this is impossible, they were thrown out of a helicopter.over the Atlantic sea... I wonder when our government will bother digging those corpses up and counting them.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by mpyne on Friday October 11, 2013 @12:23PM (#6534098)
They used to leak documents from many governments, back when WikiLeaks was still a real wiki.

After their redesign in winter 2008 (2009?) the focus of the site shifted entirely, to direct attention to the flaws of the USA and UK instead.

The goal seems to now be to improve the world by disrupting the state (the largest Western ones being those of the US and UK), as opposed to the goal of a "world without secrets". This fits neatly with Assange's worldview (he has said in August 2013 that of the American politicians he is most fond of the libertarians of the right-wing Republican Party).

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by vacri on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:58AM (#6531617)
This is the same argument as "you cops should be out catching the real criminals!"
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by BWStearns on Friday October 11, 2013 @02:06AM (#6531634)
Really. You are suggesting that the US government is on the same level of opacity or human rights abuse as any of those that I mentioned? Are you literally fucking stoned?[1]

[1] No judgement, I've had a decent amount of scotch and to each their own, but really?

[edit: legalize it, and then tax it, and give me a tax break :) ]

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by IanCal on Friday October 11, 2013 @02:19AM (#6531675)
(Not the same person)

No, that's rather the point. "They should be catching real criminals" is the argument used to complain about the police arresting people who have committed a crime because there are more serious crimes.

The argument here is that just because the US isn't the worst, doesn't mean you shouldn't do anything.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by cmdkeen on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:12AM (#6532124)
Except cops are out catching real criminals as well, there are lots of cops. If the entire police department are out catching speeding drivers and dealing with no other crime then "they should be catching more serious criminals" is a valid point.

How much capital (financial, political, human, technical) does Wikileaks spend focusing on each country around the world? How would that list correlate with the worst human rights abusers, the most opaque governments.

This of course in a week when the Azerbaijan presidential elections have just seen the results accidentally released before voting even opened...

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by IanCal on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:53AM (#6532234)
How much do they actually focus on anywhere? Are you suggesting the receive but are ignoring significant reports from elsewhere?
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by vacri on Friday October 11, 2013 @09:17AM (#6532857)
Wikileaks is far from the only organisation watching or investigating 'bad guys'.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by mpyne on Friday October 11, 2013 @12:15PM (#6534041)
So when information literally falls into their hands and they still refuse to publish because it happens to be embarrassing to Ecuador, what then? Do we finally get to point out that WikiLeaks is biased in their own investigations, and has been since their major redesign?
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by wooter on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:10PM (#6534420)
Who put them in that position? The US. You can't blame them for wanting to stay alive. If I chase you into a bear den, I can't blame you for staying quiet.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by BWStearns on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:51AM (#6531907)
I appreciate the fact that that was the argument being made.

>> The argument here is that just because the US isn't the worst, doesn't mean you shouldn't do anything.

I did not say that you should give the US a pass (I in fact explicitly stated the opposite). I did state that if you claim to oppose some common ill of humanity that you should probably focus on where it is most ill.

If I decide to fight malaria, I should probably look at Africa as a good place to do my work.

If I decide to fight corrupt, oppressive, and deceitful governments I should probably look at states with the most distasteful human rights records.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by polymatter on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:30AM (#6532185)
If you decide to learn to swim, do you jump straight into shark infested waters?

If you anger the US government they will (generally) initiate legal proceedings to see you in court. Even if you think the legal proceedings against you are a sham, you (generally) get your day in court which are (mostly) fair. If you anger China or NK they (generally) don't bother with even that much pretense and you may be tried, convicted and executed before anyone even realizes you're missing.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by avn2109 on Friday October 11, 2013 @12:25PM (#6534117)
Because of the structural arrangement and pay-to-play financial details of the American legal system, "mostly fair" is an extraordinarily generous characterization of how you will be treated.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by Legogris on Friday October 11, 2013 @07:19AM (#6532402)
So with that mindset, why are you arguing against WikiLeaks on Hacker News? There are FAR worse example of breaking your set of rules where you should probably focus.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by insuffi on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:22AM (#6531853)
Read this very internal memo and decide for yourself. Surely, you could argue for China and Russia breaking human rights, but they don't portray themselves as the moral authority in the world.

The document says this: kill squads, assassination, execution, immunity for the soldiers doing the assassinations. What the documents don't say - destabilize the region, overthrowing foreign governments for political benefit(you could argue they're just playing the geopolitics game with Russia), political exiles, breaching their own constitution in whatever way they can, hacking and cracking(surely an individual hacker would've gotten 50 or so life sentences for the things they've done).

You tell me this is a big stretch.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by mpyne on Friday October 11, 2013 @12:19PM (#6534069)
> Read this very internal memo and decide for yourself. Surely, you could argue for China and Russia breaking human rights, but they don't portray themselves as the moral authority in the world.

Russia does, do they not? Were you not paying attention for Snowden or Syria? If Russia is not a moral authority that is at least compatible with WikiLeaks's moral goals then why would Assange host a television show on the state-sponsored Russia Today channel?

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by SkyMarshal on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:28PM (#6535350)
>then why would Assange host a television show on the state-sponsored Russia Today channel?

Plenty of possible reasons for that. One would be b/c there's no way Assange could get a TV show in the US, but RT has a decent Youtube following here.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by Daishiman on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:58PM (#6534740)
You should read about the secret wars the US has led in Cambodia, their interventions of democratically elected governments in all of Latin America. I'm sure you must have heard of Iran-Contra, the funding of repressing Middle East dictactors.

I think you should really, really read up on some history.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by bandushrew on Friday October 11, 2013 @02:32AM (#6531715)
I am not clear how they were supposed to 'target' Russia, exactly? How could they control what information is leaked to them?
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by BWStearns on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:37AM (#6532005)
Fun things never published:

http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Europe/2010/1026/WikiLeaks-re...

The closest thing that WL has on their website that is even embarrassing to Russia is a Wikipedia rip of Anna Politkovskaya's summary. Everything else is either coincidental or "anti-Syria" voices saying mean things about Russia. Really, the US is the only country with people in government who disagree with their government?

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by preab on Friday October 11, 2013 @09:10AM (#6532825)
Or was it published?

"Wikileaks: Russia branded 'mafia state' in cables"

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-11893886

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by BWStearns on Friday October 11, 2013 @06:31PM (#6536269)
Nope. That is unrelated and is an incidental mention within the cables.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by bandushrew on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:42AM (#6532021)
I dont know? surely a combination is needed? someone who disagrees, has the courage to act, knows about wikileaks and has access to information in a medium that is amenable to upload. Im perfectly willing to believe that the combination is a lot more rare in Russia or China than it is in America.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by BWStearns on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:48AM (#6532041)
They publicly announced that they had some pretty mind blowing shit on Russia... which they never released. This leads me to believe a) they never had it to begin with, or b) they bitched out on the execution and decided fucking with a government who might actually hurt them was a bad idea. In either case, I lose respect.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by asgard1024 on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:43AM (#6532208)
> In either case, I lose respect.

Really? So if a dissident decides to stop dissenting due to increased government pressure, we should lose respect to all the work he did previously? Just because he was not courageous enough to continue, someone, who didn't have the courage in the first place, will lose respect to him? Moral hypocrisy 101.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by makomk on Friday October 11, 2013 @06:09AM (#6532265)
Or (c) one of their trusted members sabotaged them and deleted their unreleased information before it could be made public. I'd go with (c) because we know a guy called Daniel Domscheit-Berg actually did this. Coincidentally, he's also one of the sources this film is based on.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by bandushrew on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:46AM (#6532213)
They did the same thing with the bank info.

who knows what happened for those stories. <shrug>

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by jcbrand on Friday October 11, 2013 @10:47AM (#6533426)
Daniel Domscheit-Berg (the same guy who wrote the hit-piece book on Assange and worked on "The Fifth Estate" movie) destroyed those leaks in an apparent attempt to sabotage Wikileaks.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Domscheit-Berg http://www.smh.com.au/technology/technology-news/wiki-war-35...

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by dobbsbob on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:20PM (#6534482)
Their biggest source was Manning, who only had access to US intel. Hence a disproportionate amount of US leaks. If you go through their archives from before the Manning leaks theres plenty of Russia, Canada, Aus, UK and other countries intel being dumped
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by BWStearns on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:44PM (#6534645)
Searched their website yesterday. Literally the only thing that mentions Russia in a non-incidental way is the Politkovskaya mini-biography.

Agreed that Canada/Aus/UK are well represented, but if we have Canada/UK/US/Aus/Russia, which one of those things is not like the other?