If you think of your entire company as providing a "customer experience," then you only have one threshold, and everything is held to that standard.
The companies I am angry at are the ones sacrificing product quality and value for sales and marketing. (And also companies that just ignorantly release crappy products and ignore their customers/employees.)
customer experience != maximizing value to shareholders
I wish it were. I really do. But it isn't.
That is a clear case of people wanting crap... in fact demanding it instead of the better quality product.
Note: Sorry for being vague about the brand but he is still there and might not want the full story public.
If people were satisfied with the product, changing the ingredients is definitely going to add risk. I worked for a food manufacturer, once upon a time, and we did extensive triangle testing even when sourcing ingredients from a new vendor.
People want quality. That doesn't mean their taste is the same as yours...
On your points, I agree mostly but in this case people didn't want better quality. They liked the taste of the lower quality product.
It may use ingredients that score better on certain metrics (low sodium, etc.) but these don't mean"better quality" in the sense that these consumers are interested in (the taste that they've come to like.)
Basically, it is blindly tasting three samples, and trying to tell which one of the three is different. (The other two are the same.) So, if you are testing a new supplier, you can give the subjects two samples from the old supplier and one from the new supplier, and see if they can pick out the odd one with any kind of statistical significance.
The key factor is that it is not attempting to measure "which tastes better", but rather, "which tastes noticeably different".
How did they brand the change?
Did they reposition the food items in the store?
Did they redesign the packaging?
Did they market the better food in the same way as the crappy old food?
How long did they give it the stuff to see if it would sell?
If you've been previously selling to misers with no taste, and you want to expand (misers with no taste are not loyal but they are loud), you have to not just change the product but the ecosystem.
Of course people bitch. People will bitch your ear off for any change. Every good manager knows this.
The question is: does it sell? And if it doesn't, are you doing all you can do to help it sell?
Just adding more is a local optimization. If you want to change the bigger picture, in a situation like that, you have to upgrade your customers... to people who will pay more. Which means your existing customers are likely, yes, to bitch. But, as you said, the brand was already dying so maybe its current customers aren't the right ones.
You can't switch Alpo with Finest Steak and expect to charge dog owners more money. Doesn't work.
A product / service can create value in all of those areas.. some are either mutually exclusive or at least practically so.
To even use Apple as an example.. Great Operating system - unless you want a netbook. Or want to play games. Or create blu-ray disks.
Put it this way - I'm sure you can make a better hamburger than mcdonalds. But I'm sure Ray Croc made a whole lot more money than most of the people on HN ever will.
Some store brand products are premium equivs while some aren't. (Some stores even have two brands so they can compete with the premium with the same quality at a slightly lower price and at lesser quality at a significantly lower price.)
There was a big Harvard Biz Review article about store brand strategies several years ago.
McDonalds hamburgers.
They have arguably the worst tasting hamburger of any restaurant chain and yet they sell more than anyone else.
try asking someone at a walmart in a metro area where you can find car tarps or universal remotes...
That's a load of crap. What is true for a small start-up is not necessarily true for a huge behemoth.
There are many other components to the mechanisms for making money (which is what businesses are - human machines to make money), and although product development and customer services are very important in the early stages of a company, the focus shifts, later, to other areas (like sales or value chain optimisation). Those can make a much larger difference to the company's profits, once it is at scale, and so they deservedly get more attention at those scales.
This article represents a very narrow-minded, naive view of business. Perhaps you should work in a wider variety of companies before making such grand statements. Maybe read a book or two about corporations. I recommend "Management" by Peter Drucker as a (heavy, but excellent) starter.