News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by davidgerard on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:50PM (#6523778)
The charity sector looks forward to a Bono-led recovery

RICH PARADISE, Bahamas, Monday (UNN) — The (RED) anti-AIDS marketing initiative has announced its first annual results.

The initiative, fronted by Bono, seeks to promote a "co-philanthropy" model, wherein companies can do good works by selling products they were going to sell anyway, but with a little red bit on to show how much they care. Really. They care.

"We've worked hard on the model," said Bobby Shriver, (RED) CEO. "It's been a brand launch designed to get people used to the idea of an entirely new fund raising model. Because (RED) is explicitly NOT a charity, we encourage our partners to go about their business including their marketing. Gap, Apple, Sprint and other sales people are meeting Americans and explaining that 5,500 Africans dying daily of AIDS is preventable."

"The publicity has been fantastically effective," said Bono from his Caribbean island. "Steven Spielberg smiling down from billboards in San Francisco, Christy Turlington striking a yoga pose in a New Yorker ad, me cruising Chicago's Michigan Avenue with Oprah Winfrey, eagerly snapping up Red products, Chris Rock appearing in Motorola TV spots saying 'Use Red, nobody's dead', and the Red room at the Grammy Awards. This is something to be really proud of."

Zombie Steve Jobs also voiced his support. "I don't see how else you can assuage your OVERWHELMING GUILT at your comfortable life and income without a Red U2 iPod on your belt. Imagine the SHAME if people saw you with a plain white or black one. The SHAME."

The stunning return to AIDS charities for 2006 was $18,000 on over $100 million in marketing and consumer spend. "The only way is up!" said Shriver. "Onward and upward!"

"Buy more stuff!" said Jobs.

Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by sgustard on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:28PM (#6523613)
"Aluminium case with tens of thousands of individual perforations" sounds so much fancier than "metal screen".
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by trafficlight on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:57PM (#6523820)
I would've also accepted the term 'mesh'.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by gilgoomesh on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:28PM (#6523996)
Metal screens are just stamped or rolled sheet metal, while these perforations are made by a CNC mill from the same piece of aluminium as the rest of the body.

Might not mean anything to a layperson but watching a CNC mill make thousands of precision perforations would be quite a sight.

Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by hop on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:40PM (#6524058)
Those perforations are lasered out, like they do the MBP speaker grill/holes.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by jacquesm on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:41PM (#6524068)
Those do not look milled to me.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by jeanjq on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:09PM (#6523518)
I'm always uneasy with the idea of (RED) charity: the message is "save the world by buying stuff". It's just consumerism with a bit of karma, no?
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by k-mcgrady on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:38PM (#6523687)
I think it's more "you're going to buy this product anyway, so why not go with the model that will help a charity?".
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by ddfu on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:08PM (#6523882)
Sure, Product(RED) is designed to help you feel better about buying stuff you don't really need, but the high marketing spend is hardly much different than other charities. It's a "why not?" but don't assume you're done helping others for the year since you bought a (RED) iPad!

If you want to donate efficiently, may I suggest typing :help uganda into vim?

Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by vor_ on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:31PM (#6523629)
I don't understand why you're uneasy about it.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by randomafrican on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:45PM (#6523738)
No
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by vparikh on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @06:12PM (#6524231)
This to me does not really strike me as some Mr. Ives would have had a large amount of time in, and quite frankly am shocked that he put his name on this.

The Leica M has had pretty much the same dimensions and design for since the 50s (save to major departures the Leica CL and the Leica M5). Note that I am referring to the analog film version and not the modern digital M8 and later incarnations design, along with the Fender Stratocaster are the closest thing to perfection anyone has come up with.

The Stratocaster is a discussion for another time. In the case of the Leica, it is the best design because it distills the essence of the photographic expression and builds the product around that. The controls are simple. You have a shutter speed dial, a film crank, a shots taken indicator. Aperture control is on the lens barrel. Any photographer can pick up a Leica M and know how it works intuitively. The controls fall right where they should. Its been 50 years, and no one really has come up with a better interface to take a picture.

This design throughs all of that out the window. From the looks of the picture, it doesn't look very comfortable to hold. It seems to rounded, and the "cheese greater" design is just asking for dust/environmental problems. A well used Leica looks even more desirable with age, this would just look hideous. This design just lost all of the elegance that 50 years of incremental design bestowed on the Leica M and turned it into something that looks like a Braun product.

Then lets move to the usability -- whats with the recessed dials??? the whole point of the dial placement ABOVE the top plate is so that the photographer can operate all the controls via his thumb without taking his mind away from the act of taking a picture. This completely violates that principle. Not to mention all the ergonomic evolution the engineers at Leica spent so much time agonizing over.

Don't get me wrong, yes I do love the Leica M. I am not a zealot by any chance. I don't claim they do everything but what they do -- they have perfected the design. And here they just through all of that out the window.

If the goal was to make an advancement on the design, I would say take a close look at the Fuji X100s. It has taken the Leica ethic and bridged it beautifully with the modern digital age. In fact I will say the Fuji X100s is the first classic of the digital age.

Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by axman6 on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @07:21PM (#6524620)
It's also a one of a kind and may never actually be used, but instead displayed in someone's private collection. Who cares if it's not particularly usable, it was not designed to be used from what I can tell.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by vparikh on Thursday October 10, 2013 @12:04AM (#6525590)
That is my point exactly! As you stated, it is not designed to be used. I have huge respect for Jonathan Ives. Steve Jobs is quoted as saying "Design is not just what it looks like and feels like. Design is how it works." I think Mr. Ives forgot about that when he was working on the Leica. And that is why I am surprised he let his name go on such a poor design
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by corin_ on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:23PM (#6523577)
> The camera took 85 days and more than 735 hours to manufacture. During that time more than 550 models and 1,000 prototype parts were made and tested; 55 engineers worked on the process.

And

> It is expected to fetch between $500,000 (£312,000) and $750,000.

If they took the cost of that time and work and donated it directly to the charity how much would it have been?

Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by ebiester on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:35PM (#6523669)
Ah, but it's not a direct equivalent. Do you think Jony Ive's contract with Apple allows moonlighting?
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by corin_ on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:46PM (#6523745)
I didn't mean he should have sold his time to another company..
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by aray on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:29PM (#6524001)
It's possible he can't (via a contract) but can donate it. No idea though, just guessing.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by vor_ on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:46PM (#6523747)
Obviously, not as much as they expect it to make in sales, or they wouldn't have done it.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by buro9 on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:49PM (#6523766)
Looking at that, without reading the text, I thought immediately that it looked like Marc Newson's work rather than Jony Ive's.

Then I read the text:

> Apple's feted design chief teamed up with industrial designer Marc Newson

I would say that Marc did most of this, and Jony either just created the collaboration and put his name to it, or his touch was reasonably light.

The only part that really looks like Ive's stamp is the perforated aluminium. Every other curve, the buttons and balance of the design, scream Newson.

Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by 9999 on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:33PM (#6524021)
The shutter speed dial really looks like Ive's work to me. Although it's hard to say. This Leica bears absolutely no resemblance to Newson's Pentax K-01, but perhaps that's just because the K-01 was a camera that was actually intended to be used rather than stuffed away in a billionaire Leica fanatic's collection.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by huxley on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:23PM (#6523966)
Really? Maybe I'm missing something, but I don't see it, there is a Dieter Rams influence to it that says Jony Ive more than Marc Newson to me.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by aray on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:28PM (#6523999)
It really screamed Rams to me as well (much more than Ive), even more than Newson as well.

It doesn't look to me like a Rams/Braun product though, but a product that's trying to be one.

Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by veemjeem on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:30PM (#6524008)
It looks more like an Ive design than a Newson. Newson designed a Pentax camera last year, and it doesn't seem like any of those design elements made it into this Leica camera design.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by fein on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:24PM (#6523581)
> 85 days and more than 735 hours

> more than 550 models and 1,000 prototype parts were made and tested... 55 engineers worked on the process.

Uhh... I think they spent more developing this than what it will fetch. Wouldn't it have been better to just donate the money?

A 500k donation at the expense of that many resources...

Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by abat on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:51PM (#6523783)
It's called marketing. Ive "designing" a limited edition Leica is like Murakami being involved with Louis Vuitton.

Lecia needs people to believe that their cameras are worth a lot of money and involve a much greater amount of design work and craftsmanship than a standard Canon.

Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by Osmium on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:16PM (#6523931)
For the curious, Murakami = Takashi Murakami.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Takashi_Murakami

Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by vor_ on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:49PM (#6523767)
Do you really think they didn't consider this when making the device? Obviously, they gauged interest and determined that they'll make more money for charity by selling it.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by anigbrowl on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:40PM (#6524062)
Not necessarily. They also get good publicity out of it, so the cost is weighed against (value of charitable donation) + (value of equivalent advertsing/marketing campaign).
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by Osmium on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:36PM (#6523676)
You assume they aren't getting anything else from that. Presumably it also counts as R&D for future products.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by sp332 on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:13PM (#6523920)
Reciprocally, Project (RED) also gets Ive's name to draw attention.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by sarreph on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @04:52PM (#6523788)
I think they just wanted to make a bloody awesome camera, that also happens to generate money for charity.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by slinlee on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:14PM (#6523925)
Like so many apple products, it probably feels great to touch, but bad to hold.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by DigitalJack on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:27PM (#6523984)
I suppose people that buy these will just put them on a shelf, but if not, those perforations are going to fill with garbage.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by eCa on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @06:36PM (#6524368)
There will be only one.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by DigitalJack on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @08:21PM (#6524869)
Oh, I see now. I misread the part about 550 models thinking it meant they produced and were selling 550 of these.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by exo_duz on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @06:28PM (#6524322)
Ive doing what he does best. Industrial and hardware design.

I still think there are some question marks about his software design skills as some of the things in iOS7 is very badly thought out such as the new date pickers.

Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by zokier on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:34PM (#6524026)
How the hell it that top selection wheel supposed to be operated? Overall, it looks pretty similar to the normal Leica M, but with Apple-style all-aluminium coloring and more rounded corners.
Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by 001sky on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @05:57PM (#6524158)
A leica fan and his money are easily seperated

-- source: leica owner

Re:Jonathan Ive designs Leica camera for Red charity by snarkAttack on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @06:14PM (#6524244)

  It is expected to fetch between $500,000 (£312,000) 
  and $750,000.

  The special edition Leica M camera features an anodised 
  aluminium case with tens of thousands of individual 
  perforations.

  The camera took 85 days and more than 735 hours 
  to manufacture.

  During that time more than 550 models and 1,000 
  prototype parts were made and tested; 55 engineers 
  worked on the process.
The best part about writing for the BBC without a byline is that no one can criticize you as an individual, when you start spewing hyperbole and completely unrelated statistics in an illogical fashion, for the purpose of making retarded embellishments that go over like a lead zeppelin.

But hey, it's for charity, so the Madison Avenue bullshit artistry is (almost) excusable.