News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What I've been up to for the past year by guynamedloren on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @02:00AM (#6519652)
When I was reading this, I was asking myself the same questions. Unbelievable that a musician can't just upload a song to iTunes. I thought that was one of the huge driving factors of digital music distribution, breaking down the old barriers? I don't use iTunes, but apparently I missed something - sounds like the music industry hasn't changed much after going digital.
Re:What I've been up to for the past year by jonknee on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @02:06AM (#6519665)
I think Apple was/is scared of "unprofessional" music. Apple doesn't want to be the YouTube of music. Not allowing shitty (or pirated!) music is a hard problem to solve. A bunch of suits and contracts does a decent job because not many people are going to take the time if they just want to troll.
Re:What I've been up to for the past year by guynamedloren on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @02:15AM (#6519684)
So, how does Distrokid factor in to this? After reading, I had the impression that anybody with $20 could upload their music via Distrokid... is the idea that the annual fee is supposed to be a filter to prevent shitty music? Pirated music is one thing, but 'shitty music' seems a bit tougher to police.
Re:What I've been up to for the past year by pionar on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @10:07AM (#6521289)
pud said in an earlier post that there's a propietary spam filtering system in there that he's understandably reluctant to share details on.
Re:What I've been up to for the past year by Kronopath on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @10:52AM (#6521570)
A spam filter is different than an "amateur" or "unprofessional" filter though. I don't see how it could protect against that.
Re:What I've been up to for the past year by vargalas on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @03:31AM (#6519867)
Who decides what shitty is? Well, just listen to Gagnam style and compare it with others. Everybody is different. And the tastes are different, too.
Re:What I've been up to for the past year by GotAnyMegadeth on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @06:38AM (#6520425)
Agreed. Good music is 100% subjective, good apps are at least partially objective.
Re:What I've been up to for the past year by Amadou on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @06:55AM (#6520468)
Not allowing shitty (or pirated!) music is a hard problem to solve.

As others have said, shitty is entirely subjective.

But pirated is a really easy problem to solve. Just run it through an identifier like Echoprint.

http://echoprint.me/

Re:What I've been up to for the past year by gabemart on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @07:26AM (#6520576)
> As others have said, shitty is entirely subjective.

I strongly disagree that shitty is entirely subjective. Contextually, "shitty" could mean music recorded on a cell phone, or tracks that were 2 seconds long, or tracks that have been transcoded 7 times and sound like they're being played from a walkie-talkie at the bottom of a well.

I can understand why a music platform might want to enforce some standards of professionalism or technical competency, even if they didn't want to do so for matters of taste.

Re:What I've been up to for the past year by crucialfelix on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @08:47AM (#6520896)
or tracks that are actually completely stolen. this is a HUGE problem on BeatPort. DJs take 90s house records and just change the speed do a small edit and then release it as their own production. and BeatPort releases it. I have many friends who are furious because their music has been blatantly stolen.
Re:What I've been up to for the past year by hayksaakian on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @02:14AM (#6519681)
They literally do the same thing with apps. Pay a yearly fee and you're good.
Re:What I've been up to for the past year by guynamedloren on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @02:16AM (#6519689)
A yearly fee AND every single app has to go through an approval process.
Re:What I've been up to for the past year by gcb0 on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @03:00AM (#6519793)
Which just weed out competition with what they have/will have. Fart apps pass just fine.
Re:What I've been up to for the past year by crucialfelix on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @08:44AM (#6520875)
initially it was very difficult to get on iTunes unless your label was big enough for Apple to deal with. or if your indie label could work with their own indie distributor (Caroline etc.) to do a deal with Apple.

then came TuneCore which became the middle man to make it easy for both sides. this was great and empowering. but they have a big yearly fee.

it is possible to deal directly with Apple but its actually a significant value add to go through a middleman and reduce the labor and billing complications.