"On August 8th, rather than turning over the master key, Levison shut down Lavabit." seems to imply that they never got the information necessary to decrypt the data.
Re:How Lavabit Melted Down
by anologwintermut on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @09:42PM
(#6518987)
I did actually miss that part. I figured he gave them an electronic copy when he shut down.
Minimally, he gave them an "illegible copy." in 4 point font.Assuming its the actual key, I'm sure the FBI or NSA can OCR that. Even if parts of it are screwed up, SSL private keys actually have a fair amount of structure in them(at least enough to recover from someone writer "FUCK A DUCK" over and over again over part of one [0]) and even if say half the bits of the key give are illegible totally, the rest give you more than enough to factor it.
[0]http://crypto.2012.rump.cr.yp.to/87d4905b6d2fbc6ad2389debb73...
See my response above. https://news.ycombinator.com/edit?id=6517845