News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Women Are Dying Younger Than Their Mothers, and No O... by hacknat on Monday October 07, 2013 @12:19PM (#6509248)
Because they're more obese.
Re:U.S. Women Are Dying Younger Than Their Mothers, and No O... by elwell on Monday October 07, 2013 @01:37PM (#6509825)
Re:U.S. Women Are Dying Younger Than Their Mothers, and No O... by Mikeb85 on Monday October 07, 2013 @01:41PM (#6509858)
It's troubling that the color scale starts at 13.7%...
Re:U.S. Women Are Dying Younger Than Their Mothers, and No O... by colanderman on Monday October 07, 2013 @01:44PM (#6509877)
The correlation seems to break down in Appalachia -- low obesity; high mortality rate.

(Aside -- the stark contrast in obesity between Colorado and Kansas is surprising.)

Re:U.S. Women Are Dying Younger Than Their Mothers, and No O... by Patrick_Devine on Monday October 07, 2013 @01:50PM (#6509915)
I'd love to have access to the raw data to feed it into R. I'm fairly positive even with Appalachia included there is still going to be a strong positive correlation.
Re:U.S. Women Are Dying Younger Than Their Mothers, and No O... by gohrt on Monday October 07, 2013 @02:10PM (#6510047)
That's not really how averages work, though. You can't just smash two modes of a bimodal distribution together and treat it like a unimodal distribution. I mean, you can, but it generates garbage results.
Re:U.S. Women Are Dying Younger Than Their Mothers, and No O... by Patrick_Devine on Monday October 07, 2013 @04:41PM (#6511099)
It's hard to draw that conclusion without knowing what's in either data set. I'm fairly certain that the obesity data would have gender as one of its attributes, and it's also probable that any death statistics would include other vital stats such as height and weight at time of death.

But you're right, it's certainly possible that all of the women in those states are of normal weight and it's only the men who are obese. I'm being a little glib though, it's hard to know without seeing the data.

Re:U.S. Women Are Dying Younger Than Their Mothers, and No O... by 3pt14159 on Monday October 07, 2013 @01:55PM (#6509951)
That doesn't prove anything. We are looking at the delta here. It could very easily be that the correlation breaks down in Appalachia because Appalachia has doubled its very low obesity rate to just a low obesity rate.
Re:U.S. Women Are Dying Younger Than Their Mothers, and No O... by VLM on Monday October 07, 2013 @02:46PM (#6510319)
Something involving certain forms of resource extraction.

I was working on a theory of grain related herbicides pesticides but I know for a fact coal mining via mtn top removal makes quite an ecological mess.

Another not entirely far fetched idea I'm working on is livestock contamination of drinking water resulting in high constant antibiotic levels leading to more resistant infections in general. Looking at where I know there are poultry plants and dairy farms its not looking good.

Its entirely possible coal tailing contamination of water kills em in Appalachia, factory livestock contamination of drinking water gets em in some rural areas, and pesticide / herbicide contamination of drinking water gets em in some areas. In that case we should in theory be able to track increased death rate by river water flow directions. For whatever reason "some contaminants" are apparently not in the Colorado river basin, but the Mississippi isn't looking good.