My reaction to that was "oh boo hoo".
When people my age were kids (get off my lawn) we used to type pages of raw hexadecimal from the back of magazines into a machine prompt. We didn't cry about it, we were just careful.
I can't find a hexadecimal example at the moment, but look at some of these TRS-80 programs (pp. 110-111, 143) which have multiple pages of data/digits to transcribe:
http://archive.org/stream/80-programs-for-the-trs-80-1979jim...
Btw, the originals were often bad photocopies. So maybe not 4 point font, but certainly ambiguity in some bits.
If young, interested kids can do it, I'd hope that a nation state could figure it out.
Link: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/a/a5/ComputesGazett...
Yeah, in the grand scheme of things it's easier to get a few people to type that in (it's parallelizable, after all) than to wait for another court order. Though I'd still have brought it to the judge's attention as this is like the dictionary definition of "contempt of court". If someone tried to be GPL-compliant in this fashion they'd be laughed off the mailing list.
[1] Great stuff at the time; precursor to Zork.
Voilà, information is transported reliably over a noisey medium! error correcting codes in practice 101
EDIT: voilà typo fixed :p
(Well, not "only", but I guess you can see my point.)
They would probably have to OCR the thing.
Obviously it would be possible to apply OCR, but it would take a few days/weeks to train the algorithm. An out of the box solution would not work.
Or are they "non-essential" employees ?
There should be a standard virus-laden ISO image specifically designed for "compliance" with court orders.
If you gave them a rar, tar.gz, zip or anything, the Man can hold you for contempt if he really wants to.
Has the FBI never heard of OCR, or were these printed as CAPTCHAs?
OCR only works decent in combination with a dictionary.
Moreover, each of the five encryption keys contains 512 individual characters - or a total of 2560 characters. To make use of these keys, the FBI would have to manually input all 2560 characters, and one incorrect keystroke in this laborious process would render the FBI collection system incapable of collecting decrypted data."