News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by gojomo on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:21PM (#6486108)
The US is 5-10x larger in population than the other single-payer-ish systems usually cited. (And, more culturally/politically/geographically varied.)

Also, we in the US tend to have bigger problems running giant federal bureaucracies, compared to these other smaller, more-unified nations. (How many government shutdowns have they had in the past 40 years?) Our existing single-payer-ish health bureacracies, like Medicare, suffer more fraud and cost-problems, and have a harder time enforcing steely-eyed rationing (aka "death panels") than elsewhere.

These smaller systems also benefit as free-riders from positive externalities thrown off by the United States' eccentric overexpenditures - like drug and new-treatment beta-testing. (If we become more like them, their own medical indicators could get worse.)

So the argument can't just be, "make it work like over there", when nothing here works quite like there, and our challenges of scale, culture, and politics are larger.

Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:46PM (#6486219)
> The US is 5-10x larger in population than the other single-payer-ish systems usually cited.

Which doesn't explain the vastly higher per capita (and even per GDP) costs.

> Also, we in the US tend to have bigger problems running giant federal bureaucracies

That doesn't explain why the US costs (again, per capita or per GDP) are still higher than the total costs in many countries providing universal coverage even if you exclude the slightly-less-than-half of US spending that is public spending.

> Our existing single-payer-ish health bureacracies, like Medicare

Medicare isn't single-payer-ish, as for decades there has been policy to move from traditional single-payer-ish "Original Medicare" to (usually partially, with a personal premium as well) publicly subsidized private insurance "Medicare Advantage" plans.

> These smaller systems also benefit as free-riders from positive externalities thrown off by the United States' eccentric overexpenditures - like drug and new-treatment beta-testing.

Er, a lot of drugs and new treatments are tested and accepted overseas before they are in the US.

Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by gojomo on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:56PM (#6486261)
You're right: our costs are off-the-charts. There's something about our culture and politics that's making that happen, even in a system with centralized price-setting like Medicare.

If you can't answer why Medicare seems to do worse than your favorite "single-payer-ish" models, you haven't explained how making the entire system into a single-payer system, a bureaucracy of unprecedented size, will improve things over a smaller bureaucracy that's failing at controlling costs.

Some drugs and new treatments start elsewhere. A disproportionate number start in the US. Fancy new (and often unnecessary) treatments are one of the things driving our costs up.

Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by timr on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @08:10PM (#6486317)
"There's something about our culture and politics that's making that happen, even in a system with centralized price-setting like Medicare"

It's not a difficult puzzle: nobody in our system is incentivized to care about costs. The insured consumer never sees the cost, the physician is incentivized to be cost-blind when choosing treatment options, and the insurance companies pass the costs back to employers, who don't get any say in treatment. The only other people who know what health care costs are unemployed and/or poor, and well...screw them, right?

You couldn't possibly choose a worse economic model for allocating health care. Medicare is much cheaper and more efficient than employer-based healthcare, but it can't overcome the structural expenses created by a system dominated by people who are almost totally cost-insensitive when it comes to their health.

Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by pbreit on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @08:57PM (#6486448)
I don't see why employers and insurance companies wouldn't worry about costs. And also patients who pay a percentage of their bills.
Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by larrywright on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @10:54PM (#6486829)
And yet they don't. Do you know that the cost of prescriptions can vary greatly between pharmacies? Of course, you only pay your co-pay, but your insurance company pays the difference.

When's the last time you comparison-shopped your prescriptions or other medical services?

Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by pbreit on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @11:39PM (#6487011)
Drugs aren't the best example since they are inexpensive (at least the ones I've purchased). But if I had a more expensive surgery where I was on the hook for 20-40%, I might be incented to negotiate or shop around. And you'd certainly think the insurance company would be highly incented to negotiate.
Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by timr on Thursday October 03, 2013 @03:11AM (#6487562)
"Drugs aren't the best example since they are inexpensive (at least the ones I've purchased)."

There are some very expensive drugs, and they're not uncommon. For example, valcyclovir is a very common anti-viral drug, and costs something like $300-400 per course. The similar drug acyclovir is $20 as a generic, but is more annoying to dose. As a result, doctors will nearly always prescribe valcyclovir over acyclovir. For patients with a chronic infection, that's a mundane decision with an impact of tens of thousands of dollars per year. But unless you're a doctor or a pharmacist, you'd probably never know about the choice.

Insurance companies pass these costs on to the risk pool first, then onto employers. By the time the cost increases hit you (through employers cutting or reducing your health benefits), the implications are so far removed from the initial expenses that there's no way to close the cycle.

Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by jbooth on Thursday October 03, 2013 @01:30AM (#6487365)
Medicare is only for 65yo+.

Of course it's going to be more expensive, with worse health outcomes, than a general population pool. That's how aging works.

Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by gojomo on Thursday October 03, 2013 @03:34AM (#6487626)
It's worse at cost control than other countries, even for comparable cohorts.
Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by jbooth on Thursday October 03, 2013 @10:05AM (#6488940)
But better at cost control than private insurance in America, with much better cohorts. They're in America, medicare can't get you british-cost healthcare.
Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:32PM (#6486157)
> The US is 5-10x larger in population than the other single-payer-ish systems usually cited. (And, more culturally/politically/geographically varied.)

I see this argument all the time, and never an elaboration.

I understand going from 1,000 to 1,000,000 people incurring growing pains, but I have a hard time understanding why people seem to think a system that works for 80,000,000 people in Germany wouldn't be scalable to 300,000,000.

Re:SimplyInsured (YC W13) raises $750K to simplify health in... by gojomo on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @07:38PM (#6486189)
Germany…

…isn't quite single-payer, more like a "public option".

…has far more labor-business-government cooperation than the US.

…has the oldest tradition of social insurance, but still their current system was the result of gradual expansions over many years.

…runs lots of government services better than the US.

…is only half the area of Texas, but that area is as population-dense as Maryland (our 5th densest state).

Why can't any 300 million people in Africa just adopt US-levels of public services by willpower and legal fiat? Why can't the US make our 50-million-member Medicare as efficient as the German system? These structural, historical, cultural, and political path-dependencies matter.

"Make it work because I don't understand how it couldn't" isn't a good basis for the largest nationalization experiment ever.