and that, children, is how you know you've lost your soul.
For all you know like the OP is trying to say, they might have done the hard math and decided that this is the way they want to say.
I'm not saying it is the best but rather they might be fully aware of what they are doing
Esquire has a great print experience, but their web one, mobile especially, is awful.
I'm sure their lead print designer gets final say for what goes to press. If their web designer is caving in to every ridiculous demand of management, that's the fault of the designer, not management.
So either the lead "webmaster" has no idea what they're doing, in which case they should get a new job, or they know exactly what they're doing but are hamstrung by management, in which case they should get a new job.
These are established companies with existing management structures. The owners / management controlling the brands will have briefed in a designer to implement all of these elements.
There priority will be leverage the audience of esquire, to allow them maximise the sales they can do via media buyers.
Audience development for sites like these, is often only minimally effected by design. Especially considering these are established brands. They already get the numbers, they dont need to earn them.
Web designers are just the people paid to put the designs together options together for management to choose from.
There's ads in the print magazine, but they're in a format that doesn't run into absolute conflict with the content.
Never mind "understanding the series of decisions that led us to such an experience". Look at the outcome, for crying out loud.
Nothing else matters.
Lots of other things matter, such as revenue.
Revenue in this case is tied to good user experience, specifically things like how long people stay on your site and whether they click the various links on it.
But you already know that. You're just arguing for the sake of arguing.
Russell: Well, why am I watching it?
George: Because it's on TV.
Russell: (pause) Not yet.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ofOSlsNz5I8Or it implies they have motivations perhaps not understood, which was the OP's point.
Hanlon's Razor doesn't say that if something isn't caused by stupidity or incompetence then it must be malice.
There are only two choices here. Either they want people to read their articles and are doing a bad job of it (incompetence) or they are luring people under false pretenses and preventing them from doing what they want (evil). There is no third way.
"Motivations perhaps not understood" is just a way of saying that we may not know why they're being evil.
Where does the false pretense come in? The popover crap?
Some anecdata: I just viewed that same article on my phone, an Android G2. Zero trouble. No font-size issues (though I could have upped the font size without zooming in the whole page; I'm amazed at sites that manage to prevent that).
No popover stuff. There was a smallish banner ad at the very top. I apparently got a page designed for a mobile device, because there was no sidebar stuff either.
Could this be an iPad issue?
They manipulate and abuse us, we manipulate and abuse them. If we are supposed to be understanding of the self-interested reasons they manipulate and abuse us, can't we expect the same courtesy in return?
So jwz's use case is that he's an inbound link from a social media site, right? So Esquire is optimizing two things here: conversion rate to the downloaded app and amount of time spent on site. The first one is obvious -- people who have the app downloaded are going to spend much more time overall and are going to be more valuable; the second one is a bit trickier, since you play a balancing act between getting users to dive deeper into the publication while making sure they don't leave altogether. In this sort of case, it's pretty reasonable to assume that someone has either the data or intuition to say "Hey, if they're visiting our site from Facebook, they have a pretty big investment in trying to read the article than someone who Googled something vaguely related to the article."
(The same goes true from mobile, where audiences tend to be slower and more captive.)
So, if we understand the series of decisions that led us to such an experience, we then have to ask why were those decisions made? Clearly there's a backlash against this kind of thing -- nobody says "wow, what a great banner ad!" -- but its hard to argue against the financial straits of such a publication. Esquire doesn't have the circulation they used to, and its not a non-profit; they need to make money somehow.
Either way, its hardly fair to pin this on Esquire's web designer. Esquire's management, maybe -- or maybe the legions of people addicted to AdBlock, the legions of people who put a low -- and getting even lower -- value on content.
Now, everything is hinging on that assumption that people are vaguely competent over at Esquire. While it's entirely possible that such an assumption is invalid, I find its a more comforting one than the opposite assumption.