Re:Blogs Falling in an Empty Forest
by madair on Tuesday June 09, 2009 @01:09AM
(#648567)
They completely miss a couple huge segments of bloggers, those who write because they want to write regardless of audience, and those who write for a small social network such as family or friends.
I believe they also make an unspoken presumption of posting regularity as a metric for everyone, when in fact many bloggers are far more casual about posting.
Then there are statements like, "So why do blogs have a higher failure rate than restaurants?" This makes little sense unless the activity of blogging is simply for commercial success. I really don't think that's a well-meaning attempt at understanding the wide community of blogging and the nature of on-again off-again bloggers who make up a large percentage.
This includes myself. I've had several blogs, and currently I don't blog. None of my blogs was a "failure". At each new juncture I had found a new voice in my writing and my previous work was no longer of interest to me to have out there. This is not the experience of all bloggers, it's just my experience.
I expect to blog again soon. But with new social networking mediums, such as Facebook, MySpace, Twitter, each with quite a different flavor and audience, I find that some things that previously would have made a blog entry make more sense as a twitter, or are more appropriate on Facebook, and so on. The article almost, but not completely, misses this complexity to social networking.
It is also my completely non-scientific impression that the New York Times more frequently contains a negative take on blogging in general. It would be interesting to analyze that and see if it's actually true or not, it just seems to be the case as far as I can tell.
Re:Blogs Falling in an Empty Forest
by Achorny on Tuesday June 09, 2009 @12:13AM
(#648516)
That's true but how many blogs are even started with either generating lots of traffic, or lasting forever, as goals? The article implies that all or most do, but some percentage must be started just as experiments or hobbies, and I would hardly call those "failures", not in any useful sense of the word.
Re:Blogs Falling in an Empty Forest
by TomOfTTB on Monday June 08, 2009 @11:38PM
(#648485)
It could be but I don't think it is. If anything it disproves the most common anti-blog slur, namely that blogs are full of amateurs with no talent. In truth blogs are like any other form of media. Those who are good rise to the top, those who aren't fall to the bottom and give up.
Re:Blogs Falling in an Empty Forest
by CalmQuiet on Tuesday June 09, 2009 @06:36AM
(#648845)
I don't know where that article appeared in the newsprint version of NYTimes. But the url (nytimes.com/2009/06/07/fashion/07blogs.html) suggests the "Fashion" section. Hence: a lightweight piece that does not go deeply into either the Business or Media aspects of blogging.
Note also, since the discussion tends to slide to blog-vs-newspaper: This reader is not pleased that following the link to the NYT article takes me through a jeweler's ad page. "All the news that's fit..." ...and a lot of UNfit attempts to sustain profitability.
I believe they also make an unspoken presumption of posting regularity as a metric for everyone, when in fact many bloggers are far more casual about posting.
Then there are statements like, "So why do blogs have a higher failure rate than restaurants?" This makes little sense unless the activity of blogging is simply for commercial success. I really don't think that's a well-meaning attempt at understanding the wide community of blogging and the nature of on-again off-again bloggers who make up a large percentage.
This includes myself. I've had several blogs, and currently I don't blog. None of my blogs was a "failure". At each new juncture I had found a new voice in my writing and my previous work was no longer of interest to me to have out there. This is not the experience of all bloggers, it's just my experience.
I expect to blog again soon. But with new social networking mediums, such as Facebook, MySpace, Twitter, each with quite a different flavor and audience, I find that some things that previously would have made a blog entry make more sense as a twitter, or are more appropriate on Facebook, and so on. The article almost, but not completely, misses this complexity to social networking.
It is also my completely non-scientific impression that the New York Times more frequently contains a negative take on blogging in general. It would be interesting to analyze that and see if it's actually true or not, it just seems to be the case as far as I can tell.
You know, it could be both.
Note also, since the discussion tends to slide to blog-vs-newspaper: This reader is not pleased that following the link to the NYT article takes me through a jeweler's ad page. "All the news that's fit..." ...and a lot of UNfit attempts to sustain profitability.