News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by dctoedt on Sunday September 29, 2013 @04:37PM (#6466423)
> Don't terms like "probable" and "my hypothesis" pretty obviously make this a statement of opinion, and therefore immune to libel claims?

Quite possibly. But who wants to spend the legal fees to test that? Pragmatically, it's better to stay reasonably far away from the edge of that particular cliff, lest one be propelled over the edge by a random gust of wind (or a well-placed push).

Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by alexqgb on Sunday September 29, 2013 @04:57PM (#6466495)
The FUD you're spreading here relies on apples to oranges comparisons, where the apples are public officials working in thee public capacity, and the oranges are private citizens.

Before you go any further, I challenge you to find actual apples to apples examples that can support your remarkably menacing position.

Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by mistercow on Sunday September 29, 2013 @05:28PM (#6466590)
I don't think that's a healthy attitude, especially when we're talking about the possibility of corruption. If we all take that "pragmatic" view, what will actually prevent corruption?
Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by dctoedt on Sunday September 29, 2013 @05:39PM (#6466631)
> If we all take that "pragmatic" view, what will actually prevent corruption?

Journalists. They know that you avoid libel by stating facts supported by evidence. Truth is a defense to a libel charge (at least in the U.S.). And as mentioned above, when the libel plaintiff is a "public figure," a higher standard applies, precisely because of the public interest in ferreting out corruption and the like.

Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by moocowduckquack on Sunday September 29, 2013 @06:51PM (#6466864)
So give some indication of how they would in any way be able to show malice in this case, let alone a defamatory statement.
Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by jlgreco on Sunday September 29, 2013 @07:02PM (#6466904)
Seriously, people voice suspicions about corruption and bribery on the internet thousands of times every day. Rather specific suspicions about specific people, which is a lot more than what the ancestor post did.

How many /r/politics or /r/conspiracy or /r/occupywallstreet posters have been sued for libel? There is no realistic risk that the ancestor post will have to test his theories on libel in court; it just flat out isn't going to play out that way.

Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by moocowduckquack on Sunday September 29, 2013 @07:08PM (#6466930)
Sorry, misread name, made stupid post.
[deleted]
[deleted]
Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by moocowduckquack on Sunday September 29, 2013 @07:15PM (#6466959)
I realised, please excuse me this complete and utter brain-fart, I'm going to stop posting things now and go to sleep. Is for the best. :)
Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by moocowduckquack on Sunday September 29, 2013 @06:40PM (#6466836)
You sound like a rubbish lawyer if that is really your attitude towards it.
Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by tptacek on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @09:24AM (#6482208)
Practice a lot of law, do you?
Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by moocowduckquack on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @09:52AM (#6482353)
Look, he is warning people to watch their mouths over language that clearly isn't actionable and then when challenged is saying that even if it isn't actionable it is best to stay quiet just in case. I don't need to practice law to say that this seems like really bad advice. "Don't publicly theorise about public figures" may be good general advice if you are actively being pursued by a court, however it is appallingly restrictive advice for general life.
Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by tptacek on Wednesday October 02, 2013 @10:42AM (#6482661)
It clearly isn't actionable? I can rely on your legal expertise for that assessment? Had you heard of per se libel before he brought it up?

And, is that what he's saying? "Don't theorize about public figures"? That's not what I read.

Re:Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to ... by ksrm on Monday September 30, 2013 @05:29AM (#6468566)
Wow.