News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by sbarre on Saturday September 28, 2013 @01:52PM (#6462515)
Anyone else feel that Keith Alexander will be synonymous with Joseph McCarthy 50 years from now?
Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by slashdotaccount on Saturday September 28, 2013 @02:07PM (#6462555)
What people don't understand is that those public individuals (the front-end, if you want) just doesn't matter. If Alexander didn't exist, it would be just another name here and everything would be the same. People who decide things, they are behind the curtains, mastering their puppets. Those two parties that you think you vote for one of them is theatre of democracy, they are two hands of the one evil. You would say this is another conspiracy theory? You would've said it about Snowden's revelations one year ago. Open you eyes. Those who have power, those several families, banks and the corporations, they will do everything and anything to preserve their power and control over the people.
Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by DerpDerpDerp on Saturday September 28, 2013 @02:30PM (#6462644)
I've known about or guessed at the Snowden revelations for years now, and I think you're personifying a complex system by saying "Surely some person must be in charge!"

The truth is that it actually seems to just be a clusterfuck of many people interacting, each pursuing their own (usually ambivalent to good) intentions, and that no one really is running the show.

Which in many ways, is more terrifying: if someone is in charge, then all we have to do is change who is in charge to fix the problem; but if the problem is that even with good intentions, there are problems with scale and complexity that mangle them in to monstrosities like this... what can we do about it?

You can always behead a bad king, but what do you do about human nature and the problems of scale?

Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by droopyEyelids on Saturday September 28, 2013 @04:06PM (#6462987)
I'm glad to see other people thinking this way, because I believe this is the problem we're actually dealing with. Combine that with the fact that this cat can not be stuffed back in its bag, and all I can think of doing is hoping the surveillance is complete enough and disseminated widely enough that no one asshole or cabal of assholes can seize control.
Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by DerpDerpDerp on Saturday September 28, 2013 @05:27PM (#6463212)
I mean, I would argue that any solutions have to be found in restructuring things to be much more localized and decentralized.

A return to city-states, for instance, would deal with the problem of global super powers that can spy on huge swathes of the population, because it would require many independent groups who all have their own self-interests to collaborate in a way that lessens their individual power.

To some degree, the kind of spying we see now is only possible because the balance between the federal government and the states swung in favor of the federal government - something the citizens can influence directly (if they opt to do so).

Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by flavor8 on Saturday September 28, 2013 @08:43PM (#6463646)
I think that's exactly right. I came to the same conclusions after reading 1/2 a dozen books about the events leading up to the 2008 market crash. There were no evil masterminds, just a lot of shortsighted greedy individuals whose actions had consequences larger than they'd imagined.

We're not a very rational species yet.

Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by rhizome on Monday September 30, 2013 @12:15PM (#6470380)
Inadvertent? Jamie Dimon? Hank Paulson? I guess hindsight always has a "whoopsy daisy!" loophole though.
Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by prirun on Sunday September 29, 2013 @01:30PM (#6465829)
Solution: starve the beast to reduce the scale. Ex:

1) Banks: a. don't use any of the banks that are primary dealers b. use cash whenever possible c. save then spend rather than taking out loans d. don't buy shit you don't need e. don't put more than $250K in any one bank

2) Food & groceries: a. buy stuff on sale b. alternate between big stores to promote competition c. shop at less popular stores for lower prices d. don't buy more than you need and throw it away e. save leftovers f. be flexible on brands g. don't buy shit you don't need at all h. if they jack up the price on something, substitute i. watch for quantity vs price tricks j. buy from the value menu k. shop at several stores, buy what is cheap at each

3. Gadgets and gimmicks a. don't buy shit you don't need b. cancel your cable; watch HDTV over the air c. cancel your land line d. use cheap phones instead of smart phones e. use cheap prepaid phones from the dollar store: $15/mo f. don't buy Internet "higher speed" packages g. get on someone's cell family plan h. buy the cheapest plan, not the "best"

4. Big stuff a. don't buy a new car just because rates are low b. or a house c. verify your home tax assessment every time d. protest every assessment that isn't justified e. payoff your loan as soon as possible f. don't keep a (big) loan just to keep the exemption g. buy only what you need h. buy only what you can afford i. use rubbers j. is college still worth it, really? learn a trade

5. Eating out a. it's a treat, not a lifestyle b. order water to drink c. order lunch portions d. order less food: most Americans overeat e. save leftovers f. find cheap restaurants with good food g. split large orders h. tip 20%+ with your savings: you'll feel better

6. Don't recycle: reuse a. first, don't buy shit you don't need b. sell old stuff on eBay or craigslist, even if $5 c. force yourself to sell old stuff = buy less new junk d. donate anything reusable rather than tossing it e. take care of your shit so you don't have to buy more

IMO, we will never "fix" our governments. They are screwed up at the local, state, and federal level, because they are not spending their own money: they are spending ours. The only thing we can do is starve them until they can't afford to do all the crazy shit they are doing today.

Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by dwaltrip on Saturday September 28, 2013 @07:15PM (#6463458)
There isn't a grand evil master. There are large numbers of misguided individuals inadvertently assisting the development of certain unfortunate emergent phenomena.
Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by r0h1n on Saturday September 28, 2013 @02:07PM (#6462556)
That of course presumes that all of this - indiscriminate spying, secret courts, gag orders, war on whistle blowers, redefinition of concepts like privacy & freedom - would have come to pass and the world will be much freer than it is today (which is how we look back at the McCarthy era today, right?).

But what if it doesn't end that way, and things are much worse 50 years from now?

Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by javajosh on Saturday September 28, 2013 @03:10PM (#6462774)
Patience! I keep saying this but it's worth repeating: the US has had a lot of evil policies, even eviler than this one, IMHO, in the past, but they haven't lasted. Indian genocide and slavery were the worst, but there were also Prohibition, MacCarthyism, Jim Crow laws, etc. After doing tremendous damage to people, we eventually moved on. We are moving on from sexual/familial freedom and drug freedoms, and we will certainly move on from this.

Think of 9/11 like a severe blow to the head. It just so happens that some of us (Feinstein, Alexander) have taken longer to come out of the security-daze. And they may never. But they will eventually be out of office, let us hope sooner rather than later.

Personally, I don't believe that any policy is irreversible, unchangeable. Life is change. People change.

Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by droopyEyelids on Saturday September 28, 2013 @04:01PM (#6462958)
That attitude assumes that the quantitative change in abilities that computerized surveillance brings about never turns into a qualitative change.

I believe that is totally possible though. Surveillance used to be limited by manpower, and look how well it worked. Before today, the amount of information the NSA's computers were sifting was only conceivable as the omniscience of God.

Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by weland on Saturday September 28, 2013 @02:25PM (#6462613)
Only if we avoid the future that people like him shape.
Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by waterlesscloud on Saturday September 28, 2013 @06:58PM (#6463424)
The President is still the man in charge. He can stop these things.

If he wanted to.

Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by dutchbrit on Sunday September 29, 2013 @01:44PM (#6465898)
He's mainly just a puppet, he can't stop this. Trust me.
Re:N.S.A. Examines Social Networks of U.S. Citizens by mcantelon on Saturday September 28, 2013 @07:04PM (#6463436)
Yup. Alexander's developing the model that this empire, and future empires, will employ to maintain hegemony.