Re:Urbit: The Internet failed (slides and video)
by urbit on Friday September 27, 2013 @06:03PM
(#6459849)
I can argue with Haskell but I would never argue with teh awesome that is Don Stewart.
Urbit runs on Linux right now - but you're right, it would be very cool to run directly on the hypervisor, and it's totally possible for a self-contained system like this one. Personally I think Haskell never should have tried to be a language for producing Unix system calls - the impedance mismatch between FP and imperative OS is just too great.
Re:Urbit: The Internet failed (slides and video)
by asciilifeform on Sunday September 29, 2013 @02:46PM
(#6466096)
I'd go one step further and argue that: no sane language should be a language for producing Unix system calls.
The impedance mismatch between sanity and imperative OS (and imperative hardware) is too great.
Re:Urbit: The Internet failed (slides and video)
by wmf on Friday September 27, 2013 @10:42PM
(#6460667)
Or you could skip the hypervisor and use containers.
Re:Urbit: The Internet failed (slides and video)
by helloTree on Saturday September 28, 2013 @05:20AM
(#6461396)
You are talking about halvm I think - is it still in use or is it a dead project? The github project page does not seem to have seen commits for a while, but maybe it just ... works.
And can you please point me to the talk?
Re:Urbit: The Internet failed (slides and video)
by platz on Monday September 30, 2013 @03:15AM
(#6468200)
Here's the talk:
http://www.haskellcast.com/episode/002-don-stewart-on-real-w...
He was using Xen to run a GHC process which he describes as a "microkernel environment".
Xen + Language Runtime (ghc) + user functions = the whole stack, and this boots in milliseconds, using only 1 or 2 meg of memory.
What's interesting is that this is a technique that he's using in development today.
I didn't read all the Urbit documentation, but the concepts between Don Stewart's approach and Urbit seem to share some similarities with eliminating OS bloat.
Some folks have claimed Urbit is as much art at practical, but Don is already doing practical things like this; unless I'm mistaken about what Urbit is about (I'm sure it does a lot of other things differently as well).