News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by eschnou on Friday September 27, 2013 @01:49AM (#6455437)
"Unlike other countries, Americans are taxed not only as residents of the US but also as citizens, wherever they live."

Huh?? Just because you are a US citizen, you have to pay taxes to the US wherever you live? Is any other country in the world having such policies?

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by ronilan on Friday September 27, 2013 @02:19AM (#6455517)
According to Wikipedia Eritrea also has a citizenship based tax system. They do however use the metric system over there.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_taxation

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by ekianjo on Friday September 27, 2013 @02:14AM (#6455502)
France was also trying to do that recently, since the government there spends way more than they can hope to "steal" from their citizens. They thought it was a good idea to try to tax citizens living abroad (on top of the taxes paid abroad).

If they ever did that, I can tell you a number of French citizens living abroad would just drop their French passport without hesitation.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by gamblor956 on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:16AM (#6455699)
A number of French citizens, including nearly a dozen billionaires, actually did renounce their French citizenship over the proposed tax scheme. Gerarad Depardieu is the most famous of them, but not the wealthiest.

One of the Facebook founders similarly renounced his U.S. citizenship prior to its IPO.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by pekk on Friday September 27, 2013 @02:37AM (#6455564)
Taxation is not theft, it is lawful. The developed world is founded on taxes.
Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by Frozenlock on Friday September 27, 2013 @02:45AM (#6455589)
And war isn't murdering people?

Just because something has the backing of a government doesn't change the definition of words.

You can argue who is the owner of the money being taxed, but you can't say something is or isn't because it's lawful.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by wmt on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:04AM (#6455657)
My ISP insists that I must allow them to steal my money on monthly basis or they would cut my Internet!

Taxes are not theft, but a membership fee. Its perks are roads, fire department, schools, laws and law enforcement, protection from foreign armies and basically keeping the society together.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by Afforess on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:16AM (#6455701)
Except your argument makes no sense if you DONT LIVE IN AMERICA. If you pay US Taxes but live elsewhere, you are in fact getting robbed. Your local and government services are not provided by America, you get almost no representation from America, and yet you pay full taxes.

Complete highway robbery.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by nnnnnande on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:19AM (#6455710)
If you felt that your ISP didn't give you the proclaimed service, you could always cancel your subscription and sign with another ISP.

I do agree that the idea of taxation is not theft, but at what point does it become so? If you look at all those aspects that you point out, would you say that the taxes are well spent? The other issue here is that the people in question don't even live in the US, and thus don't make use of those services (and probably don't want their money to be used on foreign wars, as well. Just an educated guess).

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by ahomescu1 on Friday September 27, 2013 @05:45PM (#6459773)
If you don't like what the ISP charges you, you can cancel your Internet subscription. You're not allowed to say "well I don't drive, so I don't want to pay for roads".

In addition, about 50% of the federal budget these days is Social Security+Medicare+Medicaid. Most of the things you listed are paid from local/state taxes, which are much smaller. Two thirds of the federal budget goes to pensions, welfare and military expenses. Roads, laws and law enforcement aren't where the bulk of taxes goes.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by cabalamat on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:25AM (#6455737)
> Just because something has the backing of a government doesn't change the definition of words.

For some words, the government defines what they mean. This includes legal terms, such as murder or rape or theft -- all or which mean what the laws (written by the government) say what they mean.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by paulhauggis on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:02AM (#6455646)
How much is considered lawful? 30%? 50%? 90%?

It would be lawful if I agreed to all of it. I do agree we need taxes, but in many cases, it's excessive and against my will (you can go to jail if you don't pay it).

The other problem is that there is no accountability.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by seanmcdirmid on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:09AM (#6455676)
If you are living in the USA, you are probably paying far fewer taxes (income and consumption) than people living anywhere else in the developed world, as well as much of the developing world.

I'm assuming you live in China though, since you said there is no accountability, and you can't vote out public officials whose tax policies you don't like.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by Afforess on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:21AM (#6455720)
So because other countries take an arm and a leg in taxes, but the USA only takes an arm, we should shut up and be happy?

/FlawedLogic.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by seanmcdirmid on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:42AM (#6455800)
Give me a good example of a developed country with generally happy citizens who pay less taxes than we do, then we can use that country as an example of how a low tax society could work without failing spectacularly. Barring that, it might be possible that the libercrazian no/low-tax country might still work; we just have no evidence and/or experience that it does.

Whenever I hear Americans complain about taxes, I play a sad song on a very tiny (invisible) violin in my hand.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by slygent on Saturday September 28, 2013 @12:20PM (#6462185)
Surely complexity of the tax code is important too? Anyway, Hong Kong is a very developed and modern place, and taxes are much lower here.
Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by nohuck13 on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:18AM (#6455704)
In practice, the US has lots of bilateral income tax treaties [1] that prevent expats' getting doubly taxed. For example, I'm an American living in London but I don't pay US taxes for work done here because the tax rate is higher here and by treaty, the UK gets first crack at me. I know a few Americans in (low-tax) Singapore who have to pay Singapore taxes, then pay the on top of that to the US government up to the level they would have been taxed if living in the US.

I get extra pain when I go on business trips to the states, which the US doesn't count as being foreign work. So every year I have to fill in a spreadsheet of all the days I worked in each country, and subtract the US days from my tax treaty credits. I have to do the same thing in reverse for the HMRC in the UK. My least favorite part of being an expat :)

[1] http://www.rumbaklaw.com/resources-and-tools/us-federal-tax-...

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by dutchbrit on Friday September 27, 2013 @02:14AM (#6455500)
Yes, being a US citizen requires you to pay the US tax, even though you live in a different country, work in that country and already pay tax in that country.

It's been like that for a long time already, pretty rediculous of you ask me!

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by seanmcdirmid on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:07AM (#6455669)
Note that you often don't get double taxed. They just want the difference between what you would pay in the USA vs. what you actually pay in country B, after $97k that is. If you are in a country with higher taxes than the states, which is most of the world actually, you won't be paying anything more (just watch out for HK, Singapore, and Switzerland).
Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by capisce on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:21AM (#6455716)
Having to go through the form hell of filing US taxes seems like a tax in itself.
Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by seanmcdirmid on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:48AM (#6455825)
Every year I spend a couple of hours on it, and I do my taxes by hand at that. The hardest part is figuring out where to find a post office to mail the forms out. They seem to change each year (I could also drop it off at the embassy I guess, but that would require 15 or 20 more minutes to get in the front door).
Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by sipior on Friday September 27, 2013 @02:17AM (#6455509)
Yes, although there is a high deductible (~$80k, as I recall). It's never been something I needed to worry about, but FATCA most definitely will be. I don't know the answer to your last question, but I've never personally heard of another nation with similar policies.
Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by bsullivan01 on Friday September 27, 2013 @02:42AM (#6455576)
Do you still have to file US taxes though? Say you make $60K in Germany, well under the deductible, and do not file US taxes for 10 years.

Is there a penalty just for not filing? penalties can cripple you.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by sipior on Friday September 27, 2013 @11:44AM (#6457558)
Yes, I believe you are still obligated to file. Not sure how rigidly that's policed, though.
Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by brudgers on Friday September 27, 2013 @02:29AM (#6455543)
US citizens living abroad are able to avail themselves of services through embassies and consulates for ordinary problems and call upon the USMC etc. for assistance with extraordinary ones.
Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by Lewisham on Friday September 27, 2013 @02:45AM (#6455592)
Are you trying to say that US citizens abroad are paying for the services of their embassy? That's crazy. Every expat citizen from any country is offered help from their home country's embassy, and they do it without citizen-based taxation.

I could walk into the British consulate in San Francisco tomorrow and expect help, and I haven't paid taxes in the UK for 5 years now.

Re:Why are Americans giving up their citizenship? by yardie on Friday September 27, 2013 @03:15AM (#6455696)
If that is what the embassies and consulates are for than I wouldn't have a problem with that. At the moment I have to call a number to make an appointment and get shaked down by consulate security to get in to file an announcement of birth. I also have to pay a fee for that same announcement.

I think you are under the impression US embassies are a country club that expats just go to and have a cocktail from time to time.