News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can I Make a Living Off Bitcoin Mining? Probably Not by nwh on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @04:56AM (#6443387)
Not casually.

I've a little ASIC device sitting in the corner, but it's more a mild curiosity than any actual income. I've made a lot more money reselling the devices than I have mining with then.

Re:Can I Make a Living Off Bitcoin Mining? Probably Not by gaius on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @07:13AM (#6443786)
In any gold rush, sell shovels.
Re:Can I Make a Living Off Bitcoin Mining? Probably Not by junto on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @08:14AM (#6444024)
This is a great analogy!
Re:Can I Make a Living Off Bitcoin Mining? Probably Not by Lewton on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @08:41AM (#6444157)
which is why it gets repeated everytime bitcoin articles get posted on HN ;)
Re:Can I Make a Living Off Bitcoin Mining? Probably Not by PeterisP on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @06:04AM (#6443591)
Bitcoin mining is not a "job" (requiring effort) but an investment - requiring capital. So in the long run, it shouldn't be possible to get a return on bitcoin mining much above normal market interest rates, since if the return would be higher (as it was just recently) then an investor can buy/build large amounts of ASICs and drive bitcoin price down.
Re:Can I Make a Living Off Bitcoin Mining? Probably Not by nwh on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @06:12AM (#6443610)
There's certainly people who have lucked out and made a considerable amount of money that would, for all intents, be a replacement job for them. Some of the early Avalon machines would have been making hundreds of dollars a day when they were received. Even earlier miners on CPUs would be rolling in hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Re:Can I Make a Living Off Bitcoin Mining? Probably Not by PeterisP on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @07:04AM (#6443757)
They may have made a great investment with a large, quick return - but it's not a job because:

(a) the income from the Avalon machine likely is much less now than initially, and is likely to shrink rapidly - so it's not a sustainable future income;

(b) keeping the income at the same level can't be done by spending your time, but by investing lots more money again and again;

(c) you (and anybody else) can increase that income hundredfold by buying hundred times more machines - i.e., it is limited by capital, not by time/effort.

It sure is income, but with very different characteristics. It's even very different from classic 'passive income' investments like dividend stocks or rental real estate - such 'passive income' investments are with rather sure long-term returns; but bitcoin mining gear produces very volatile short-term returns, and is likely useless in the long run as the device you buy now will after a couple years likely earn less than the electricity cost.

Re:Can I Make a Living Off Bitcoin Mining? Probably Not by nwh on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @06:31PM (#6447755)
That's in a literal sense. I meant mining as a replacement for having a job, not so much that the mining itself was a job. You're right in every way though.