News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by rayiner on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @09:51AM (#6437817)
There is nothing new under the sun. Your grand kids will be writing similar screeds in whatever forum is popular with them about more or less the same subject, just as the hippie generation did in the 1960's.

Society vacillates between rejecting institutions and embracing them, for a basic reason: you really don't want to go too far in any direction.

On one hand, you obviously don't want to become slaves to the status quo. Injustice exists, and it must be fought. On one hand, there is intrinsic value in having issues be settled. At a point, a final disposition is better than the "right" disposition. It is difficult for society to function productively without broadly shared values, purposes, and coordinating institutions.

The idea of a "hyper-individualistic" "post-communitarian" world is absolutely at odds with the direction of social change to date. Our societies become ever more interdependent, a phenomenon that has accelerated greatly since the industrial revolution and the resulting trend towards specialization and division of labor. Which is really the more "hyper-individualistic" world? The world circa 1750 where everyone was a farmer and grew their own food and sewed their own clothes and generally did 95% of the activities necessary to sustain their lives, or the world circa 2013 where everyone does a hyper-specialized job and depends on the labor of thousands of other people doing hyper-specialized jobs to maintain their lifestyle? Shared values, shared purpose, and common institutions are far more important today than they were a couple of hundred years ago.

Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by jbooth on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @10:16AM (#6438003)
Actually, two things are new:

1) The ability to store/process data on the scale to monitor an entire population.

2) The US government's assertion that it has the right to do this. It's not new under the sun, but it's new in the US.

Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by protomyth on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:58PM (#6439099)
Sadly, point 2 is really not new in the US. The amount of data might be but some pretty ugly examples can be found in every decade of the 1900s (maybe not so much in the first two but the 30's were fun).
Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by jbooth on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @01:14PM (#6439233)
Sure, we've got the j. edgar hoover era and everything going along with that, but that's a case of individualized, nominally illegal wiretapping. Now we're talking about broad-based wiretapping with entire buildings dedicated to it, operating practically in the open compared to the cloak-and-dagger stuff of yore.
Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by protomyth on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @07:02PM (#6447888)
I would say the 1930's under FDR were worse than what Hoover did. Even with the limited technology they did a pretty good job of oppression.
Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by spangled on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @11:51AM (#6438635)
The US government's assertion that it has the right to do this.

What are you referring to, exactly? I thought the scandal was the dubious distinctions being made to specifically avoid "monitoring an entire population", and the lack of oversight to prove it.

Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by rubinelli on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @10:24AM (#6438053)
Yea, we are smaller parts of a larger whole, but the nature of our interaction is completely different. We have replaced relationships with contracts, traditions with EULAs. And while individuals used to be relatively self-reliant in normal conditions, they had the backing of the community. There's no modern equivalent of barn-raising. This is the real problem: modern institutions don't give individuals any stability, but still demand compliance, if not loyalty.
Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by Apocryphon on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:27PM (#6438873)
Watergate was probably the turning point though, that destroyed trust in the establishment. Or was it World War I?
Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by protomyth on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:59PM (#6439109)
To be fair, the revolution was anti-establishment. It didn't really start as a quest for independence either.
Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @01:55PM (#6439537)
As a Gen Y kid, you nailed it.

We're not anarchists. Well, ok, most of us will claim to be anarchists of some sort. But what's really going on is that we almost all, to a man, feel hugely betrayed by society's institutions.

That doesn't mean we hate institutions and all want to move to the desert and become survivalist maniacs. It means we want institutions that actually do their job of making society run well.

Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by rayiner on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @05:35PM (#6440922)
The next generation will replace the institutions of the generation that came before, just as the baby boomers replaced the institutions of the World War II generation.

Whether it will be better is an open question. I don't think the baby boomers did a great job with their renovation.

Re:The Banality of Systemic Evil by wissler on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @11:24AM (#6438473)
Nothing new? What about the Internet, which enables radical new ways of communicating?