News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by ashray on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @08:18AM (#6437409)
6 years is way too much for a non violent crime. There are rapists and murders and drug dealers who get by with less at times. It's amazing what the right kind of lobbying can do in this world.

On the other hand, I personally see this as part of a policy of appeasement and am now waiting for some huge 'donations/low interest loans' to come out to Spain from the USA/MPAA/RIAA/etc.

I'm not Spanish but I have seen the culture of copying and sharing and using pirated software that exists in Spain. A penalty like this may shut down a file locker or two, or may even take down a few torrent sites, but it will do nothing to deter file sharing in general - what's more ridiculous is that the proposal clearly states that it's in line with the people's culture to generally share software/music/movies/games/etc.

Given that it's such a half assed effort it could only be a response to pressure from the US, a response tuned to not raise too many eyebrows in Spain but at the same time unlock some bonuses/favors from the US govt.

Ultimately I think this has come as subsequent pressure and a fallout from the whole Rojadirecta debacle a few years ago.[1] (those guys basically sued the US government for seizing their domain... AND WON[2]!)

1 - http://torrentfreak.com/tag/rojadirecta/

2 - http://torrentfreak.com/u-s-returns-seized-domains-to-stream...

Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by outworlder on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @09:55AM (#6437850)
Any jail time AT ALL is too much for non-violent crime. If a citizen is no threat to others, it is not necessary to take away his freedom (and along it, his job, and contact with his family). This is a monetary crime at best (usually, without profit for the pirate) and a monetary compensation is in order, nothing more. A hefty fine can hurt a lot and is a deterrent, but not taking away the ability to support oneself.
Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by a2kadet on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @10:00AM (#6437890)
You think Bernie Madoff should have walked?
Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by rayiner on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @11:10AM (#6438367)
I do. You can't have a broad policy of "non-violent crimes = no jail time" if you do a case-by-case of "who we like" and "who we don't like." Because that's why Weev and other hackers are getting jail time.
Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by MysticFear on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @11:38AM (#6438550)
So the worst penalty for a financial crime is to lose all your money? Low odds of being caught, very high reward, and assuming you didn't have money to begin with a zero penalty for being caught. Seems like a financial criminal's dream.
Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by ashray on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:02PM (#6438717)
Well, if you really didn't commit the financial crime for monetary gain then what was it for ? Just trolling the copyright industry ? There needs to be a deeper look at the situation in this case because the law being discussed right now is really about pirates making money off being pirates.

How is losing all your booty not a big enough deterrent ?

Edit: Also, I'd like to make a distinction here between copyright infringement and financial fraud. I don't think it's been proven yet that people are losing jobs and companies are becoming bankrupt because of large scale copyright infringement. That isn't the same as financial fraud. Personally, I'd like my tax dollars to go first to a jail that houses someone that poses immediate physical danger to me or someone else. Then a list of other things. And finally to those 'dangerous' young'uns from the pirate bay. They're pretty far down the list of evil doers.

Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by pessimizer on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:46PM (#6439006)
>How is losing all your booty not a big enough deterrent?

If that's all you lose, it's not a deterrent at all. If the punishment for stealing is simply that I have to give back all that I got caught stealing, I would never not be stealing because there would be absolutely no risk that I would end up worse off than my present state.

Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by ashray on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @01:22PM (#6439302)
Yes, you're right. But the idea is to take everything away + impose fines/penalties (but not like those $1 million per download kinds of fines). I just think that jail time seems overboard for this kind of thing. Even a fine that may take a few years to pay off is a pretty harsh punishment. But maybe it'll push our already talented pirates to do something more worthwhile and work to pay them back ?
Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by rayiner on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @01:51PM (#6439515)
If you have no money to begin with, you're probably in no position to commit a real financial crime. "Poor people financial crimes" are still crimes involving some level of physical violence (breaking into a house, picking someone's pocket, etc).

If you do have money to begin with, taking it all away and imposing fines/wage garnishment as penalties are a major deterrent.

Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by ledge on Wednesday September 25, 2013 @12:51AM (#6442711)
"Rich people financial crimes" involve an aspect of violence too, or at least can have the same impact as violence. When Bernie Madoff screws someone out of their savings, and that person then can't pay their insurance/medical bills, I would say that fits under a broad definition of violence.

For someone with Madoff's connections, it wouldn't be hard to acquire a false identity and resume some kind of low-level fraud. Putting him in prison is the best way to protect the public IMO.

I personally think that prison sentences are just as valid for non-violent crime as violent crime anyway. It's a disincentive, it's aptly punitive in cases such as Madoff's, and it makes it harder for the offender to re-offend.

Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by MysticFear on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @04:45PM (#6440638)
You should watch CNBC's American Greed. Highlights numerous white collar financial crimes from pyramid schemas to embezzlement. Most people I found came from low wage jobs into multi-millionaires.
Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by belorn on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @10:59AM (#6438290)
His work was indeed without profit. As the former non-executive Chairman of the NASDAQ stock market, and the admitted operator of a Ponzi scheme, how could he possible earn any profit from doing that.

Lets also eliminate the difference between infringement, and fraud. Next time apple sues someone that infringe on their swipe to unlock patent, they should add a fraud case to it. How dare those phones deceive users with Apple's gesture!

Re:Spain's new piracy penalty: Six years in jail by joelle on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @12:54PM (#6439062)
I totally agree that 6 years is way too much. It's absolutely absurd. Punishment definitely doesn't fit the crime.