When people focus their disappointment on companies that are forced to comply you get civil war while the real aggressor is just laughing at you. Let's instead focus on how government got so much brutal power, how can we possibly reduce it and prevent from increasing again in the future. That's the real issue here.
If a company publishes a "Transparency Report" that is woefully incomplete, they shouldn't call it a "Transparency Report", should they now? They effectively fudge the numbers to make things look better than they are.
Im sorry, but that won't happen to you in a lot of other countries. Even with data retention in the european union there's still no such thing as NSL in most european countries.
> This report doesn't include national security requests. We want to report the exact number of national security requests we receive, if any. Unfortunately, the government allows services to disclose only the aggregate number of all law enforcement and national security requests received (and even then the disclosure must be in large bands). A report in that form decreases transparency, especially for companies that receive zero or very few national security requests.
They can't report on how many national security requests because they have to lump them in with regular law enforcement requests in bands of 1000. Since there were less than 1000, it would be 1-1000, and that's it. They're working on being able to release the exact number, so they had to file a brief with FISA.
Had Dropbox received just one national-security request [... the report would] look like this:
Jan-Dec 2012 United States 1-1000
Reporting in this way decreases transparency. [...] It would also obfuscate the number of [...] requests [...] which were not sealed and are in the public record.
so they are arguing that you either get the numbers shown or 1-1000 and nothing else (which seems odd to me, as google seem to manage to show both - see my link below).
cut + paste from pdf not working so may be typos above. https://dt8kf6553cww8.cloudfront.net/static/docs/DropboxFISC...
[Update - 9/23/2013] – Today we filed a legal brief asking the court to confirm that we have the right to report the number of national security requests we receive, if any. You can check out our brief here: Dropbox FISC Brief. We'll keep you updated about any developments.
They've phrased their document to suggest they have 1-1000 requests without actually saying it. For all we know they could have served thousands of requests last year but are using this as an excuse not to show that.
It would be as if a city fighting crime releases statistics on muggings but not homicides.
"Today we filed a legal brief asking the court to confirm that we have the right to report the number of national security requests we receive, if any. You can check out our brief here: Dropbox FISC Brief. We'll keep you updated about any developments."
Maybe you don't find that information important, but I do.
huhtenberg's point is simply that he doesn't agree with the classification of the page. That is contains too much information, and cannot include other information.
Fact is, that's not a Transparency Report, it's PR Report, to make you feel better and not run away screaming. I've decided that Dropbox/Google Sync shouldn't be trusted for anything of any importance.
Considering how self-congratulatory HN readers are about this community's intelligence, you'd think more of them would be able to read between the lines.
Not to mention these two claims are contradictory:
"This report doesn't include national security requests."
"Unfortunately, the government allows services to disclose only the aggregate number of all law enforcement and national security requests received "
Does it include the NSA request, or not in the aggregate? First sentence says no, second implies yes.
> * This report doesn't include national security requests.
What good is this "Transparency Report" if it excludes an unspecified number arbitrary wide secret information access requests? The one kind that actually ignited the fire under Dropbox ass.
How can they seriously think this could calm and reassure anyone who cares about privacy of their data held with Dropbox?