News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is... by rayiner on Monday September 23, 2013 @10:49PM (#6435605)
His whole analogy only works because the librarian is a human, and if a human with some apparent authority lets you do something, you can reasonably infer that you have permission to do it. But you can't anthropomorphize a server like that. It's not a gatekeeper, capable of granting permission, just a dumb lock which may be flawed. Only humans can consent.

To repurpose his analogy, if you sneak into the staff room and the librarian doesn't notice and doesn't stop you, you can't use that to say it must have been okay.

Re:This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is... by biot on Monday September 23, 2013 @11:21PM (#6435737)
Both are gatekeepers. One has been configured with an employee handbook. The other is configured using .htaccess or similar. When making requests of either, how do you know whether you have permission to make the request you're about to make?

If a server cannot consent, does issuing "GET /" to a web server mean you snuck into the homepage and are not authorized to view what the web server was configured to provide to you?

Re:This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is... by angersock on Monday September 23, 2013 @10:57PM (#6435639)
People boil down to dumb locks--if presented with the correct context and input, if they are rational they should by definition grant access.

This library analogy was the best way I've seen the issue put, and one that is actually accurate.

Re:This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is... by rayiner on Monday September 23, 2013 @11:01PM (#6435654)
I totally didn't understand where you were going with that.
Re:This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is... by rubythurs on Monday September 23, 2013 @11:52PM (#6435862)
I agree with library analogy
Re:This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is... by rcsorensen on Monday September 23, 2013 @11:37PM (#6435799)
The problem is that the people who wrote the code are human. The people who deployed the code are human. The people who paid for the internet connection that lets you connect to their service are human.

There are any number of explicit steps that are taken to put code on an HTTP service on the internet.

Re:This hacker might seem shady, but throwing him in jail is... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @02:31AM (#6436349)
If you're going to repurpose the analogy, do it right. The librarian is supposed to let you into x room. Someone somewhere expected you to look at one record before leaving, but you check out some other records. But at no point did you wholesale sneak past the librarian.