Re:Metadata Equals Surveillance
by dredmorbius on Monday September 23, 2013 @06:12PM
(#6434507)
AT&T's metadata about your calls is generated by AT&T's equipment, stored on its servers, and is generally not even accessible to you.
Two strawmen and a falsehood.
AT&T's equipment doesn't randomly go about generating customer metadata (given that much of the information is used for billing purposes, that's fraud). Rather, it is recorded based on the actions of customers AND those contacted by, or contacting, customers. Which is to say, it's a detailed record of activities of third parties (a large number of whom are not even AT&T customers).
In the case of data which merely transits AT&T's equipment, neither party need be an AT&T customer (instead some other telcoms provider is).
And the data collected is available through privacy rights, subpoena, or other processes.
Two strawmen and a falsehood.
AT&T's equipment doesn't randomly go about generating customer metadata (given that much of the information is used for billing purposes, that's fraud). Rather, it is recorded based on the actions of customers AND those contacted by, or contacting, customers. Which is to say, it's a detailed record of activities of third parties (a large number of whom are not even AT&T customers).
In the case of data which merely transits AT&T's equipment, neither party need be an AT&T customer (instead some other telcoms provider is).
And the data collected is available through privacy rights, subpoena, or other processes.