News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by kamaal on Monday September 23, 2013 @06:21AM (#6429896)
Your post has a lot of gems, but you also misunderstand a lot about what is going on in Indian society. I am not surprised, not a least bit.

>>I am sorry to say this, but parents come with an “old generation” mindset ... Because they think that if he gets a job he has settled in life ... Unfortunately, what they don’t realize is that there is no such thing as “settling” in IT jobs.

They come with a very correct mindset. For many people here. Including my own family, getting to a IT job was a long drawn battle against very tough financial conditions, social pressures and all other kinds of problems. There are people, including few of friends where they were the first people to enter a Engineering college. Imagine having to drive a taxi, or an auto rickshaw, or pushing a vegetable cart, or a small time farm worker practically working 18 hrs/day and then sacrificing every small desire of yours to save every single paise and doing this for decades you can so that your child can study. And imagine the kid, having to wear only two shirts and two pants a year. Traveling in near-to-explode crowded buses in a city starving all afternoon, and practicing math problems on a newspaper just to get a decent degree and a job.

From their perspective, they are really reaching a milestone, when they get a full time job. At least that is how I felt I when I got my full time job at a Call center here in Bangalore. You might think that's a disaster for an engineer. But from my perspective, the analogy is similar to a person dying out of thirst in a desert getting a glass of cold water, and you criticizing him for not aiming for Apple juice.

Its extremely difficult to understand this, unless you have suffered the same fate. Even if you think you do, you don't. You really need to suffer from it, to understand what it is.

Remainder of your post has some nice insights. But I believe our society suffers from a crisis of honesty. Throughout my entire childhood, teens and now in a job I see rampant corruption. I don't mean bribery. But unfair play of all kinds. Question papers in exams getting leaked, seats in colleges being secured through 'high influences' & capitation fees, Seats denied to general category students due to reservations.

And now in the corporate job, I don't see things as any different here. In fact this is the worst I'm seeing in my life. Even if you are the best programmer out there, you will be slaughtered in the resulting office politics. I've seen some super idiots being promoted, sent to onsite locations, and given amazing hikes just because his manager happens to be speaking the same language as him, or belongs to same state from some part of India, or is because of some religion. At the same time, the entire industry is full jumping jacks, attrition in nearly every company is record high. Because every one wants to be a manager, thanks to the IT services companies and the mess they created in 90's. Now every one joining this industry thinks programmers are losers, and climbing the corporate ladder is all that is sole measure of one's success, or how many time one has visited the US.

Meritocracy is dead in the water, when it comes to the programming scene in India. If you want progress, you need to be some managers's pet and "suck up" to him. Playing political games, and being in manager's power structure is all that counts. Else find your self a manager who is of your state or speaks your language.

This has nothing to do with engineering education. Its about being honest and playing fair. Besides I chuckle every time a guy gives 'engineering education' as a reason to not do something. A 20+ year old with Google at his disposal, has 0 reasons to complain when it education and knowledge these days.

Start up's and bootstrapping are our only hope at this point of time.

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by unlimit on Monday September 23, 2013 @03:22PM (#6433535)
I work at one of these IT service companies. This year I complete my 10 years. I love coding, solving problems and learning new things. But unfortunately, with extreme reluctance I will have to become one of these managers. I just do not have any other way, no body cares about writing code here and writing good code will not get you nowhere.

I am too old for the product companies and I am not from a top tier college. So its game over for me, however the only hope I have is that someday I will manage to build something on my own that will free me. This is what I have been dreaming of ever since I passed out of college. You may ask me why I did not do it then, but for a guy from a lower middle class background, it was not an option. I needed to survive.

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by thewarrior on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @01:58AM (#6436274)
Any advice for someone who has completed just 1 year ?
Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by unlimit on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @02:10AM (#6436301)
First question - do you like programming? If not get out. If you like programming, get better. Learn algos, lookup open source projects, dig through the code. That is how I learnt. Build something - it could be a website, an app. Try showcasing it, it may open opportunities.
Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by thewarrior on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @02:19AM (#6436320)
Yes I like coding. I'll try and do what you suggested. But how did you find the time ? It gets very hectic at time doesn't it ?
Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by pramalin on Monday September 23, 2013 @08:47AM (#6430419)
//Seats denied to general category students due to reservations// I mostly agree with the rest of your post, but bundling the reservation system among corruptions is naive and mischievous. Reservations for the low caste were gained after a long struggle for their social justice.
Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by enry_straker on Monday September 23, 2013 @09:55AM (#6430867)
No it's not.

'naive' and 'mischievous' don't mean what you think they mean, and the author of the parent post did not claim anything of that sort. It's just that your opinions differ and you want to throw some idiotic words at the author's post.

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by pramalin on Monday September 23, 2013 @10:58AM (#6431381)
I quoted what the poster said.

It is _naive_ for a person born into low caste, to believe that the reservation system is corrupt.

On the other hand it is _mischievous_ for the elitist to claim that it is corrupt. Indian popular media and the justice system which are disproportionately occupied by the elitists, have been successful in their propaganda to make the younger generation think that it is wrong to utilize the reservations.

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by kamaal on Monday September 23, 2013 @01:09PM (#6432394)
Justice is equality, not reservations.

There are two people, Person A works very hard, Person B doesn't. In a exam, because of the registration number system both are anonymous. Now if Person A scores above Person B. I don't see why B must get a seat above A? For what?

Social justice is to give people what they deserve corresponding to their efforts.

>>Indian popular media and the justice system which are disproportionately occupied by the elitists

By elitist you mean people who work hard and make it big in their lives?

And 60+ years of reservation system hasn't changed anything which says volumes about the problems with uplifting weaker sections of our society. If you give some one an option to get something for free, they take that rather than working for it.

Net Result? You get people who only look progressive but are actually not.

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by enry_straker on Monday September 23, 2013 @11:36AM (#6431643)
No he didn't. Don't just make shit up.

And, by the way, the constitution of india enjoins every indian to be treated equally. If you don't understand that concept, and only view life through casteist eyes, then you are in for a sad, bigoted future.

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by rahul_rai on Monday September 23, 2013 @07:29AM (#6430107)
A 20+ year old with Google at his disposal, has 0 reasons to complain when it education and knowledge these days

WRONG

Totally

Where would a 20 year old learn about a driver code written 15 years back , with no documents? This job would feed him And it is hard.

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by kamaal on Monday September 23, 2013 @07:35AM (#6430131)
Nobody gets Google search results, For "segfault in driver.c written by rahul rai in 1985"

But, they get good enough help on writing device drivers and troubleshooting them. That is all you need, and you have to take it from there.

There is nothing like copy-paste if your are solving a new problem. You have to incrementally work your way to a solution.

If you think that is not possible for a person, they must rethink and chose a different profession instead.

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by enry_straker on Monday September 23, 2013 @09:58AM (#6430897)
No.

It also indicates that companies hire people and then throw problems at them without training them or mentoring them or providing adequate tools for them.

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by enry_straker on Monday September 23, 2013 @09:57AM (#6430888)
I call BS on that attitude.

First, the author was making a generic point. Your contribution is to point out some silly exception.

However, if a 20 year old had the driver's code, he can learn to look at the code of similar driver's or failing that learn to read the code, and run them through a kernel-level debugger. If he doesn't know how to do that, there are resources available on the internet to show him how.

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by rahul_rai on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @02:49AM (#6436406)
Where do you find a similar iscsi driver code written for windows NT
Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by enry_straker on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @09:18AM (#6437647)
Similar to what?

Here's a link to the open source linux version: http://linux-iscsi.sourceforge.net/

Also check out this site for more info: http://www.open-iscsi.org/

The Windows DDK is a good source of sample driver code. If you are a MSDN subscriber, you would be able to find it as part of your collection ( or available for download online )

Beyond that, i suggest contacting MS tech support.

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by rahul_rai on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @11:28AM (#6438503)
I know all of this

my point is how do you deal with the pain of supporting code written by someone else years ago?

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by enry_straker on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @02:22PM (#6439735)
If you knew all this why ask a specific question?

I am really trying hard to take you seriously and not treat you like a troll.

As far as supporting code written by someone else years ago, that's just the nature of programming. If you find it too painful, get out of this industry, find something you truly enjoy and do your best in that area.

Life is too short to be struck doing something you really don't enjoy.

Re:The Story of Engineering Education in India by okpatil on Monday September 23, 2013 @08:07AM (#6430254)
He means to say that an engineering student should have an aptitude of solving problems. All he needs is a hint of solution. Google is happy to give that..