News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Brief History of Lisp Machines by greenyoda on Sunday September 22, 2013 @06:39PM (#6428373)
"Why Lisp Machines? The standard platform for Lisp before Lisp machines was a timeshared PDP-10, but it was well known that one Lisp program could turn a timeshared KL-10 into unusable sludge for everyone else. It became technically feasible to build cheaper hardware that would run lisp better than on timeshared computers. The technological push was definitely from the top down; to run big, resource hungry lisp programs more cheaply. Lisp machines were not 'personal' out of some desire make life pleasant for programmers, but simply because lisp would use 100% of whatever resources it had available."

This explanation doesn't seem to make sense.

If you wanted to prevent a Lisp program from using up 100% of CPU on a timeshared machine, all you would have needed to do is impose CPU quotas on the users.

And a lot of the engineering on Lisp Machines did go toward making life pleasant for programmers. The windowed GUI environment on a Lisp Machine was a whole lot nicer than logging into a PDP-10 on a VT-100 terminal. If running Lisp more cheaply was really the goal, they wouldn't have given these machines high resolution bitmapped displays, which were very expensive at the time.

Re:A Brief History of Lisp Machines by lispm on Monday September 23, 2013 @07:33AM (#6430127)
> This explanation doesn't seem to make sense... impose CPU quotas on the users

CPU quotas don't help.

Take for example a VAX 11/780. 1 MIPS, 32bit architecture and only a few MB RAM (2MB -8MB). Additionally used virtual memory.

A single Macsyma running on top of Maclisp on such a computer could use all the memory and more. A garbage collection would touch all memory and swap everything else out. This swapping would make the machine completely crawl. The resources CPU and main memory would all be used by a single process. Limiting the CPU for the Lisp process does not help. The Lisp process would be slow, the machine I/O would be slow. Most programs would wait for I/O.

The minicomputers (PDPs and later) were too expensive and optimized for timesharing - not for running Lisp images which were larger than main memory.

> If running Lisp more cheaply was really the goal, they wouldn't have given these machines high resolution bitmapped displays, which were very expensive at the time.

That's even more expensive. Now you have an expensive bitmap display hooked up to an extremely expensive minicomputer. Btw., that was experimented with before the Lisp Machines appeared - Interlisp was running in such a combination.