News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Clayton Christensen got wrong by aaronbrethorst on Sunday September 22, 2013 @05:59PM (#6428228)

    In a June 2007 interview, again with Businessweek,
    Christensen reiterated that the iPod was doomed,
    and further predicted that the iPhone would not
    be successful
The iPod was doomed, and it was the iPhone that killed it.

Also, Apple has demonstrated time and again that they're willing to 'disrupt' themselves by introducing hugely popular new products that erode their own margins. See, for instance, the iPod nano, the iPad mini, and, now, the iPhone 5c[1].

I think Christensen got it exactly right. He's just incorrectly applying his own research.

[1] Yes, yes. Apple hasn't released any numbers on the 5c yet. But, just wait. It's going to be huge.

Re:What Clayton Christensen got wrong by abtinf on Sunday September 22, 2013 @06:14PM (#6428288)
You should try reading the whole article.

The OP's point is that Christensen has two theories of disruption, one of which is invalid. The first, new market disruption, to which you are referring with your comment, is not controversial. The OP would likely agree with you.

The second, low-end disruption, holds in business-to-business markets but fails in consumers markets.

Thus, the iPod was not killed by a low-cost and standardized competitor (which is the incorrect prediction of low-cost disruption), but by a vertically integrated highly differentiated competitor (a possibility under new market disruption).

Re:What Clayton Christensen got wrong by whatusername on Sunday September 22, 2013 @08:03PM (#6428601)
That sounds like low-end disruption to me (Possibly I'm misunderstanding the theory). The iPod was killed when the marginal cost of an MP3 Player moved to $0. Same thing is happening to Point and Shoot Camera's. My Phone isn't quite as good a music player as a dedicated MP3 Player. And it's not quite as good as a P&S camera. But their marginal cost to me as a consumer is $0.
Re:What Clayton Christensen got wrong by ThomPete on Sunday September 22, 2013 @10:25PM (#6428898)
An iPhone with a digitalised iPod inside of it. It is exactly a low cost competitor.