News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by laureny on Sunday September 22, 2013 @02:14PM (#6427371)
The FSF has never been very relevant so saying it's more relevant than before is not setting the bar very high. Besides, that's probably what you'd expect to hear from someone bragging they've been supporting it for 30 years.

I appreciate the value that free software brings but what differentiates me from the people at the FSF is that I also realize that free software is not a panacea and that closed source, commercial software is a necessary complement to the existence of a healthy ecosystem.

Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by Kim_Bruning on Sunday September 22, 2013 @02:44PM (#6427485)
As I gain experience over time, it begins to appears to me that free software is the only long-term viable option.

I think this is perfectly reasonable, after getting burned for the umpteenth time by proprietary software vendors. (Or vicariously discovering that yes other people have indeed been burned yet again)

Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by Sanddancer on Monday September 23, 2013 @11:04AM (#6431429)
On the flip side, I've been burnt by Open software vendors who have decided that their commercial needs mean discontinuing support and funding for their own projects. The Insight frontend for gdb, for example, was fantastic, but has languished since RedHat bought out Cygnus. I can also point to the support policies of many Open operating systems -- I can still get support, patches, and bugfixes for Windows Vista, which was released in 2007, but can no longer get support, patches, and bugfixes for any Linux distribution released in a similar timeframe. While I can see more and more of the market moving towards Open solutions, I can only see FSF-created solutions dragging us down.
Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by teddyh on Tuesday September 24, 2013 @07:28AM (#6437198)
It is pretty disingenuous of you to claim that you can't get support, patches or bug fixes for any Linux distro from 2007. You can easily get those things. Just not for free. Just pay from the money you saved by not buying Windows Vista, and attribute some of this to the cost of not upgrading your operating system for six years.
Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by quadrangle on Sunday September 22, 2013 @02:17PM (#6427381)
I think the intent was to say that the FSF message is relevant, i.e. the message about software freedom. And that message has been very relevant regardless of how many people are open to it.

That is indeed different than claiming the FSF's relevance, but I think that was the intention.

Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by laureny on Sunday September 22, 2013 @02:18PM (#6427388)
Agreed, so take the message and ignore the organization that promotes it, especially when that organization has such a track record of being led by people who see the world as black and white and who are not open to an ounce of compromise about their views.
Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by spacelizard on Sunday September 22, 2013 @04:27PM (#6427888)
The message of the FSF is not particularly relevant to economics. Free software does not mean "non-commercial," it's free as in freedom. If you want to have control of your own computing then proprietary software is not necessary for any purpose; avoiding it is a must.
Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by laureny on Sunday September 22, 2013 @06:22PM (#6428313)
> Free software does not mean "non-commercial," it's free as in freedom.

Stallman strongly disagrees with you about that.

Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by dllthomas on Sunday September 22, 2013 @06:54PM (#6428403)
No he doesn't.

http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/words-to-avoid.html

“Commercial”

Please don't use “commercial” as a synonym for “nonfree.” That confuses two entirely different issues.

A program is commercial if it is developed as a business activity. A commercial program can be free or nonfree, depending on its manner of distribution. Likewise, a program developed by a school or an individual can be free or nonfree, depending on its manner of distribution. The two questions—what sort of entity developed the program and what freedom its users have—are independent.

In the first decade of the free software movement, free software packages were almost always noncommercial; the components of the GNU/Linux operating system were developed by individuals or by nonprofit organizations such as the FSF and universities. Later, in the 1990s, free commercial software started to appear.

Free commercial software is a contribution to our community, so we should encourage it. But people who think that “commercial” means “nonfree” will tend to think that the “free commercial” combination is self-contradictory, and dismiss the possibility. Let's be careful not to use the word “commercial” in that way.

Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by laureny on Sunday September 22, 2013 @07:16PM (#6428471)
You are quoting the FSF's stand on the issue (which I don't have a problem with) but not Stallman's.

Stallman has always believed that software should not be sold, either directly or indirectly. For example, a quick Google search returned this interview [1]:

    > BYTE: A cynic might wonder how you earn your living.
    > 
    > Stallman: From consulting. When I do consulting, I always reserve the right to give away what I wrote for the consulting job. Also, I could be making my living by mailing copies of the free software that I wrote and some that other people wrote.
Stallman has been consistent for decades in holding this view.

[1] http://www.gnu.org/gnu/byte-interview.html

Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by dllthomas on Sunday September 22, 2013 @07:47PM (#6428564)
What I am quoting was, as is noted at the foot of the page I linked, published in "Free Software, Free Society: The Selected Essays of Richard M. Stallman" and I am pretty confident it was in fact written by him. It strikes me as consistent with his other writings.

The interchange you cite doesn't conflict with this view at all (or if you really think it does, please explain how). First, "selling software" is not the sum total of "commercial software", which is what was being discussed. Second it is not "selling software" that Stallman opposes, first order, but restrictions on freedoms of users to the end of selling software. This should be apparent from the fact that Stallman himself (as is noted in the OP here) sold copies of EMACS back when copying was less trivial. It's certainly the case that triviality of mass copying plus the FSF's "freedom 2" means that it is practically difficult to sell anything but the first copy (because people can simply get a copy elsewhere) but I'd argue that is precisely what Stallman is doing when consulting: selling that first copy.

Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by spacelizard on Sunday September 22, 2013 @07:46PM (#6428561)
>Stallman has always believed that software should not be sold, either directly or indirectly

I'm not sure how you drew that conclusion from that statement. Nothing in there says that.

Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by Kim_Bruning on Sunday September 22, 2013 @10:54PM (#6428974)
Actually, I was at a lecture by RMS where he said "if someone wants to pay Eur 30K for your work, by all means, charge them Eur 30K".

Often it's not practical to charge for the software itself, because people know they can typically download it for free (as in beer) . In that case, you should charge for consulting. (Which is what RMS does)

Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by quadrangle on Monday September 23, 2013 @01:44AM (#6429318)
> Stallman has always believed that software should not be sold

There is very little in this world any more completely and clearly false as that statement. Stallman has himself sold software and advocates that others do so too, in fact selling software is one of the freedoms he advocates that must be protected!

Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by shrikant on Sunday September 22, 2013 @09:32PM (#6428782)
Sorry, you're just misinformed about this: http://www.gnu.org/gnu/thegnuproject.html
Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by dllthomas on Monday September 23, 2013 @02:22AM (#6429416)
Seemingly most relevant bit:

"Since “free” refers to freedom, not to price, there is no contradiction between selling copies and free software. In fact, the freedom to sell copies is crucial: collections of free software sold on CD-ROMs are important for the community, and selling them is an important way to raise funds for free software development. Therefore, a program which people are not free to include on these collections is not free software."

Re:The Free Software Foundation is even more relevant now th... by johnpmayer on Sunday September 22, 2013 @04:05PM (#6427799)
> I also realize that free software is not a panacea and that closed source, commercial software is a necessary complement to the existence of a healthy ecosystem.

Necessary? Is that just because it pays salaries?