News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by georgemcbay on Friday September 20, 2013 @04:28PM (#6420305)
The suggestion was that the relationship is mutually beneficial, not that it was bi-directional in terms of components traded.

Apple is like the USA to Samsung's China in this specific relationship in that the product (components in this case) pretty much goes one way, but both still rely on the relationship.

Samsung makes some of the components Apple needs, Apple buys those components. Apple needs Samsung for inexpensive chip fab, Samsung needs Apple for the revenue provided in return.

Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by Miyamoto on Friday September 20, 2013 @05:30PM (#6420628)
Samsung does not need Apple. Apple probably doesn't need Samsung either, but they've chosen to need them for this processor.
Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by mathattack on Friday September 20, 2013 @06:16PM (#6420864)
It's not a matter of needing each other. As long as there's a positive NPV on working together, they'll do it. They each might say, "We benefit X, but there's a risk that costs Y." As long as X is greater than Y, they'll work together. They don't have to, but as long as they're the best partners for a given transaction, why not?
Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by georgemcbay on Friday September 20, 2013 @06:39PM (#6420964)
Oh, I agree.

"need" may not have been the be the best word to use there. I didn't mean to imply that either needs the other by the strictest sense of the word. I meant it more in the sense of "I need my morning coffee". I don't really need it, but I'd, you know, really, really like to have it.

Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by revelation on Friday September 20, 2013 @05:07PM (#6420508)
I think you are overestimating how much Samsung needs Apple as a customer. Gigantic companies as Samsung are simultaneously active in any number of large markets. They do not need single customers, they do not even need whole markets. They are essentially investment holdings that will move out and into markets as they mature or are commoditized.
Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by Jtsummers on Friday September 20, 2013 @05:29PM (#6420622)
And if Samsung unilaterally ends their relationship with Apple it sets a dangerous precedent. If you knew that your trading partner would end their sale of products to you because you had a (valid or invalid) suit against one division of their business or had a product suite that competed with one of their division's product suites, would you want to do business with them or would you find someone that can actually play well with others?
Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by Kequc on Friday September 20, 2013 @05:56PM (#6420766)
How would you determine whether or not that was true about the next company? What about business that is ended between companies due to overlapping interests? That happens all the time.
Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by Jtsummers on Saturday September 21, 2013 @12:19AM (#6421973)
Those were outside the hypothetical that was proposed (namely that Samsung could give up Apple as a customer and not notice it - presumably meaning longterm). Sure companies end relationships when they have overlapping interests, but sometimes they prop each other up as a result of that as well - see Microsoft's support of Apple in 1997, monetarily and with product support. It was apparently to their benefit to support a (failing) competitor, in this case I'm guessing it was to do with the anti-trust charges. But they were competitors at the same time.

In this particular case though (Samsung/Apple) the overlapping interest is part of Apple's core, and just one of many Samsung divisions. It would not be (or at least it's not obvious that it would be) in Samsung's interest to poison the well of their component division just because it happens that their phone division competes with Apple. Ditching Apple may not, on its own, be an issue after a couple years, but it would put other component customers on edge. See the concern some Android phone manufacturers had when Google bought Motorola's mobile division for a similar issue but from the software side.

Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by CountSessine on Saturday September 21, 2013 @03:50AM (#6422297)
The two businesses that Samsung is in that are making almost all of their money right now are semiconductors (and only flash and SOCs) and mobile handsets. Take those two businesses away and Samsung starts to look more like the ponderous, government-sheltered behemoth that it is.

And someone is going to take away the handset business - everyone in asia is basically waiting for Huawei and ZTE to eat Samsung's lunch. Samsung can't compete with either of them on cost, and eventually they won't be able to pump more pixels into 400+ppi screens to keep customers from buying cheaper smartphones. And without unique software to offer consumers (like Apple), Samsung is extremely vulnerable in the handset market.

And in the meantime, Samsung is amortizing a fortune's worth of chips fabs that were mostly built to supply components for iDevices.

Yes, Samsung needs Apple's business.

Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by Volpe on Saturday September 21, 2013 @07:07AM (#6422615)
I think it's a bit more nuanced than you are making out.

Samsung do have their own Software (Tizen, and Bada(?), and a third 'unknown' base). They are pushing for an Android compatible linux, with strong hardware integration. Huawei and ZTE won't be able to compete with that. They could fail completely on that strategy, but they are doing more than just increasing PPI.

Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by CountSessine on Saturday September 21, 2013 @03:55PM (#6424225)
Neither Tizen nor Bada are realistic competitors for Android outside of Korea. Certainly not anymore than Meego was an Android competitor - and Nokia actually had a lot of really great software engineers working for them. That's something that's hard to say about Samsung considering Touchwiz. And neither Bada nor Tizen has any significant ecosystem of apps.

This isn't a competitive edge against Huawei and ZTE because no one buys Samsung phones for their software.

Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by Volpe on Saturday September 21, 2013 @07:06PM (#6424980)
Tizen can run android apps. So they have the largest ecosystem. Samsung has a huge brand, they could easily make Tizen a competitor by deploying it on Galaxy Phone in the future. Consumers wouldn't know (or care).

Not sure how you can judge a whole companies software engineers, based on one project (Touchwiz).

Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by CountSessine on Sunday September 22, 2013 @09:40PM (#6428799)
Tizen can run android apps. So they have the largest ecosystem.

No they don't. Android has the largest ecosystem. They're riding on Android's train - they don't have their own train. And they're on the Android train with Huawei. And if they're dumb enough to jump off the train, then they're in the bushes.

Samsung has a huge brand, they could easily make Tizen a competitor by deploying it on Galaxy Phone in the future. Consumers wouldn't know (or care)

No they couldn't. Brand doesn't count for anything if you're selling the same stuff your competitor is. Substitutability. The top phones from Apple, Samsung, and HTC offer more for more money than what Huawei can offer right now because there's room for mobile hardware innovation, and that's what they do best. Once they hit a ceiling - no more pixels to add to the screen, no more transistors on the CPU without exceeding a reasonable thermal envelope - then its all Huawei's game. The only one of those three that stands a chance is Apple because they have their own ecosystem.

Samsung has more brand recognition than Huawei. And it doesn't matter a whit. They'll still get steam-rolled once the ppi wars are over and we're buying based on price. This is the grim reality that Samsung shareholders have been realizing.

Not sure how you can judge a whole companies software engineers, based on one project (Touchwiz).

I've owned many Samsung products and have had no good experiences with their software or drivers. I'm willing to be convinced otherwise, but so far they seem to fit the stereotype of the hardware-company-that-doesn't-get-and-can't do-software.

Re:Apple's A7 is Made By Samsung by megablast on Friday September 20, 2013 @08:14PM (#6421333)
They would lose billions, maybe 10 to 20 billions a year from Apple.

Nobody would seriously end this relationship from Samsungs end, at least if they had any brain cells.