Self-education invariably triumphs educational process. The key of successful educational institutions is access to the teachers, mentors and environment that students need to advance their own educational goals. From reading a few bios, these students are self-starters and will be constrained by an MBA-style program.
Completely agree. Made my first $1M before 30 and am a college drop-out.
However, 6 months of working in what is quite frankly a sheltered environment is not exactly "self-education".
His MBA program seems, to me, like so much of this marketing hype that is going around today... It is constant promotion and talking, and producing very little product of actual value or interest. Some of the projects seemed interesting. None seemed any more significant (and a few less significant) that what we've seen come from some motivated folks who have neither a real, or a Godin, MBA.
So in general we each set our own falsifiable goals, and we're responsible for helping each other succeed. So in the sense that there's a performance standard to be met, your punishment for not meeting that standard is not accomplishing your goals.
There is much value in class-room learning on subjects like Finance, Accounting, Publishing (books, etc.). You can learn these things yourself, but when the material is well defined and relatively unchanged over time, a classroom environment can present the data in a structured and efficient format.
More data points = more accuracy.
Neat experiment, but most people would not consider this troupe on-par with any MBA program after hanging out for 6 months.
Maybe if this was an 18 month program, or maybe if Godin could better articulate how this is more "MBA" than "self-study" the "students" might have some merits.