News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Conan Doyle estate seeks US copyright of Sherlock Holmes'... by derefr on Friday September 20, 2013 @03:24AM (#6416395)
At this point, I wish we could just pass a stupid special-case law granting Disney and Apple Music whatever copyrights they currently hold in perpetuity, so that the rest of the copyright system could get back to being useful/healthy.
Re:Conan Doyle estate seeks US copyright of Sherlock Holmes'... by quink on Friday September 20, 2013 @04:14AM (#6416539)
Force them to, after let's say 28 years of copyright, to pay an ever increasing percentage of the revenue they earn from the characters as a tax to keep them out of the public domain.

35-50 years of extra copyright = 30% of revenue. 50-70 years of extra copyright = 65% of revenue. 70-100 years of extra copyright = 90% of revenue. 100+ years of extra copyright = 200% of revenue.

And so on. Just need to administer this scheme, which would be a logistical impossibility. Yay.

Re:Conan Doyle estate seeks US copyright of Sherlock Holmes'... by beagle3 on Friday September 20, 2013 @05:10AM (#6416708)
> Just need to administer this scheme, which would be a logistical impossibility. Yay.

Actually, ridiculously easy to administer: The enforcement you get depends on your reporting (and tax paid). If you claim to have made $x in a given year, you cannot sue any one individual for more than $x loss in that year.

So, if Disney properly reports - it is administered.

If Disney under reports - they let infringers off the (full) hook. If they do a Hollywood Accounting and claim loss every year - well, then, they can't sue any infringer for it.

The only thing giving them any standing is copyright law. Just tie it to taxation, and all will be well.