Re:Conan Doyle estate seeks US copyright of Sherlock Holmes'...
by beagle3 on Friday September 20, 2013 @05:10AM
(#6416708)
> Just need to administer this scheme, which would be a logistical impossibility. Yay.
Actually, ridiculously easy to administer: The enforcement you get depends on your reporting (and tax paid). If you claim to have made $x in a given year, you cannot sue any one individual for more than $x loss in that year.
So, if Disney properly reports - it is administered.
If Disney under reports - they let infringers off the (full) hook. If they do a Hollywood Accounting and claim loss every year - well, then, they can't sue any infringer for it.
The only thing giving them any standing is copyright law. Just tie it to taxation, and all will be well.
Actually, ridiculously easy to administer: The enforcement you get depends on your reporting (and tax paid). If you claim to have made $x in a given year, you cannot sue any one individual for more than $x loss in that year.
So, if Disney properly reports - it is administered.
If Disney under reports - they let infringers off the (full) hook. If they do a Hollywood Accounting and claim loss every year - well, then, they can't sue any infringer for it.
The only thing giving them any standing is copyright law. Just tie it to taxation, and all will be well.