Re:Nintendo visionary Hiroshi Yamauchi dies aged 85
by fwonkas on Thursday September 19, 2013 @10:15AM
(#6411743)
Actually, both Pac-Man and E.T. were developed and published by Atari itself. That's not to say that third-party garbage wasn't a major (and probably the primary) problem.
Re:Nintendo visionary Hiroshi Yamauchi dies aged 85
by irishcoffee on Thursday September 19, 2013 @12:13PM
(#6412536)
I actually owned and played both those games on the 2600 when I was a kid. As it turns out, they were very buggy (and for me to recognize this as a child says something). Not refuting your point, just an anecdotal comment.
Re:Nintendo visionary Hiroshi Yamauchi dies aged 85
by DanielleMolloy on Thursday September 19, 2013 @05:35PM
(#6414478)
@fwonkas: OK, thanks for clarifying this!
Re:Nintendo visionary Hiroshi Yamauchi dies aged 85
by ANTSANTS on Thursday September 19, 2013 @08:38PM
(#6415283)
The GP wasn't saying that exercising quality control as a platform holder is a bad idea, just that Nintendo engaged in some ethically dubious practices at the time. The most obvious evidence: Nintendo did excellently in Japan while exerting significantly less pressure than they did on companies that wished to produce games for the American market. The Famicom had no lockout chip. Nintendo did not impose a strict 3 game per-year limit in the Japanese market like they did in America. Third parties were allowed to manufacture their own game cartridges; there is direct physical evidence of this fact in the varying shapes and vibrant colors of the cartridges themselves[1], and the existence of customs ICs and discrete mapper designs common in Famicom cartriges. In addition to slimming margins for third party developers, this also made supply and demand problems very difficult to deal with, as tinco mentioned. Remember how Nintendo infamously forbade third party devs from publishing games for competing platforms in America? Didn't happen in Japan, and so a fair amount of early Famicom games received ports to the MSX and other Japanese computers.
The Famicom did have some amount of Atari 2600-goldrush-esque crappy games (some licensed, some not), but it didn't stop the console from being a huge success. This suggests to me that Nintendo's reasoning was only part "Americans will flood the market with shitty games again if we don't do something about it," with pure monopolistic greed being the other part.
With all due respect to Hiroshi Yamauchi, I don't think their business practices during this era should be considered at all admirable, and I don't think it's right to credit their monopolistic practices for "saving the medium."
Atari is relevant here for a different reason, since their Atari 2600 partly failed because they did not have good quality control schemes, and because low-quality buggy third-party titles flooded the market (famous examples: PacMan, E.T. - The Extraterrestrial). Consumers simply lost interest in spending money for titles that didn't work (something I would like to see in the PC market today). A couple of years later, the Nintendo Entertainment System won the customers back partly because they controlled their market.
R.I.P. Hiroshi Yamauchi.