News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web development in C: Crazy? by pjmlp on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @05:57PM (#6408423)
> > Apache and nginx => C > Tomcat, Jetty => Java > Okay, if you are going to throw in Tomcat & Jetty, you should also throw in the likes of lighttpd, mongrel2, etc., all of which are written in C. Pretty much all the load balancers/reverse proxies are written in C too. Hmm.... is it maybe possible that it isn't always better to use C++ instead of C?

No, they were developed by open source Linux guys that only care about C in what concerns compiled languages.

C++ was always badly received by the Linux community, in contrast with commercial UNIXes.

> IIS => C++/C# > Yup, the one outlier no doubt owes about 0% of its success to its tech stack. In general, if you don't work at Google and want a C++ web server on anything other than Windows, you are looking at a C++ server framework that has an embedded HTTP stack (tntnet, Wt, etc.).

Yes, nothing like contributing to have more insecure servers around.

>> That is my hope, after all we only need a few generations of developers and then the issue is taken care of by itself.

> I think you missed my point. ;-)

I surely got your point, but it is not about Darwin of languages, rather of developers.

Re:Web development in C: Crazy? by cbsmith on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @07:11PM (#6408787)
> No, they were developed by open source Linux guys that only care about C in what concerns compiled languages. > C++ was always badly received by the Linux community, in contrast with commercial UNIXes.

You mean like KDE, Firefox, OpenOffice, OpenCV, VLC, bitcoin... heck even gparted is a C++ app.

The kernel developers obviously have a bias against C++ (and they'd argue that it is a justified bias). User space is a different land.

> Yes, nothing like contributing to have more insecure servers around.

? Not sure your point here...

> I surely got your point, but it is not about Darwin of languages, rather of developers.

> I surely got your point, but it is not about Darwin of languages, rather of developers.

My point was about Darwinian forces applied to language or developers.

I was responding to your point about OS vendors not being left around. It would appear that, for whatever reason, going with something other than C or C++ for your base OS doesn't seem to result in good survival odds.

Re:Web development in C: Crazy? by pjmlp on Thursday September 19, 2013 @02:49AM (#6410229)
>> No, they were developed by open source Linux guys that only care about C in what concerns compiled languages. > C++ was always badly received by the Linux community, in contrast with commercial UNIXes.

>You mean like KDE, Firefox, OpenOffice, OpenCV, VLC, bitcoin... heck even gparted is a C++ app.

>The kernel developers obviously have a bias against C++ (and they'd argue that it is a justified bias). User space is a different land.

I use Linux since 1995, and was for some time a Gtkmm contributor in the early days.

I know how it feels to be a C++ developer in Linux land.

Re:Web development in C: Crazy? by cbsmith on Friday September 20, 2013 @07:04PM (#6421062)
> I use Linux since 1995, and was for some time a Gtkmm contributor in the early days. > I know how it feels to be a C++ developer in Linux land.

The GNOME crowd was self selected to be a bunch of "C not C++" bigots. The KDE community was quite different (even if MOQ is an abomination ;-). The only community I can think of that would be more hostile to C++ is the kernel devs.

I don't think your experiences are accurately reflective of the larger community. Particularly as C++ has improved (really, pre-gcc 3.0 there wasn't a good C++ compiler, and pre-2000 hardly anybody understood RAII, so C++ was kind of a pain), the larger community's attitude has changed. You can see this reflected in the success of the Boost project.

Re:Web development in C: Crazy? by pjmlp on Saturday September 21, 2013 @01:12PM (#6423613)
Coming from Turbo Pascal background I tend to be very critic of unsafe by design nature of C and C++. Specially given my focus in compiler design during the university, which allowed me to have a broad focus and experience in many languages, the average HN crowd might not be aware of.

Having said this, I was already coding in C++ in MS-DOS around 1993 (Turbo C++) and only used plain C when forced to do so.

So I have been part of the C++ community since the early PC compilers were available, and experienced this C vs C++ for quite some years now.

The funny part is remember the performance complaints back then about C and C++, that nowadays people state in HN about languages trying to replace them.

Oh, and I really like Boost.