Re:Children are suffering a severe deficit of play
by bsullivan01 on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @03:28PM
(#6407470)
I agree 100% with you. Not to go off-topic too much, and I am no doctor but I wonder if this is a reason for a stunning increase in autism cases. Maybe sitting alone, in front of the TV, game console does a trick on you when very young?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Children are suffering a severe deficit of play
by LaGrange on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @03:41PM
(#6407556)
The reason? Like, higher diagnosis rate? Also, autism can be diagnosed by the age of 2, and practically a significant portion of cases gets identified by the age of 5-7. So, um, no, it's not video games.
Re:Children are suffering a severe deficit of play
by roc on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @04:11PM
(#6407767)
Maybe it's regional, but it's been more than a decade since I've been around a 2-7 year old that wasn't spending a significant portion of their time with dvds and games.
I wouldn't be so quick to rule out such social factors.
Re:Children are suffering a severe deficit of play
by cantankerous on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @04:22PM
(#6407849)
Autistic behavior can sometimes be identified before a baby is a year old. Signs like the avoidance of eye-contact can be big indicators. I suppose babies "play", but not in the same sense that a 5-7 year old would "play".
I'm skeptical of pointing the finger at television and video games for the spike in autism rates. Video games and television have been around quite a bit longer than the increase in diagnoses of autism-spectrum disorders.
Re:Children are suffering a severe deficit of play
by jbooth on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @05:07PM
(#6408156)
If someone's identifiable as autism SPECTRUM based on their eye movements at 1, maybe they'd still be better served to hang out with other kids and be the 'weird kid', learn how to work with other kids while maybe being picked on a little, than to not hang out with anyone and be complaining on an internet forum that they're "aspie" and can't form relationships 20 years later.
Re:Children are suffering a severe deficit of play
by Locke1689 on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @07:13PM
(#6408796)
This seems to quite obviously the case of someone completely uninformed and ill-qualified attempting to proffer their "wisdom" as fact. I would encourage HNers to ignore this random internet content if you ever have to make such a decision and instead consult an expert familiar with their child's problems.
Re:Children are suffering a severe deficit of play
by jbooth on Thursday September 19, 2013 @01:57PM
(#6413160)
You're right actually, my fault. I was overreacting to other comments on the thread that were all butthurt about being picked on as a kid.
Re:Children are suffering a severe deficit of play
by roc on Thursday September 19, 2013 @10:34AM
(#6411859)
"let's not rule out a possible contributing factor" is a long way off "pointing the finger".
Re:Children are suffering a severe deficit of play
by tekalon on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @03:55PM
(#6407656)
Higher diagnosis rate, the definition of 'autism' is always expanding, parents being older when they have kids (late 20's-30's, compared to late teens/20's), possible links to pollution and environmental influence. Same can be said with ADD/ADHD (My husband has autism, and I have ADD. Neither of us did lots of tv/gaming until we were older. If anything, we gravitated to tv/games/reading/being alone/studying to avoid being around other people)