Re:The Norwegian prison where inmates are treated like people
by nikatwork on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @09:12AM
(#6405004)
I answered this in my reply to pgcsmd, but additionally: I don't have kids but my taxes supplement education. I don't drive, but my taxes supplement roadworks. Likewise, my taxes also supplement justice.
Now the US prison system has become a corrupt business - and that's a separate and awful issue. But the fundamental ethical basis for punishment stands: you steal money, you pay it back - you deal emotional trauma, you pay it back.
Re:The Norwegian prison where inmates are treated like people
by rycho on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @09:56AM
(#6405219)
Money and emotional trauma are not equivalent. When a thief is forced to give back the money they stole, the victim tangibly benefits. Torturing murderers doesn't tangibly benefit the victim's surviving family members, because emotion isn't transferable capital.
Thus, our goal should be the lowest possible crime rate, and I'm not sure punishment for vengeance's sake is ultimately compatible with that goal.
Re:The Norwegian prison where inmates are treated like people
by nikatwork on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @10:31AM
(#6405457)
> When a thief is forced to give back the money they stole, the victim tangibly benefits [... while] emotion isn't transferable capital
I propose that you would feel differently if someone had emotionally assaulted you or your loved ones via rape or violence. Perhaps this is a difference in personal ethics, but I despise such assaults more than property damage; at the very least I hope we can agree that such crimes deserve to be redressed.
Why should taxpayers have to pay for stone-age, eye-for-an-eye vengeance? Harsh sentencing is expensive.