News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Startups That Received Investment from In-Q-Tel by tptacek on Monday September 16, 2013 @03:51PM (#6395471)
Time for another thrilling round of everyone's famous game, Guilt By Association yaaaaay!

The truth is usually 83.46% more boring than conjecture, but in this case I bet it's 100%. I have no affiliation with In-Q-Tel, nor have I ever worked for an In-Q-Tel-funded company, but I have friends on the management teams of more than one and my bet is: In-Q-Tel just gives money to things they thing DoD will find useful, and that's that.

Re:Startups That Received Investment from In-Q-Tel by andrewcooke on Monday September 16, 2013 @06:03PM (#6396211)
i'm sorry, but i think this is mistaken. it's both mis-applying the term and misunderstanding why this list could be useful.

guilt by association is when, say, two companies happen to share the same building. if one is known to work for the intelligence community then guilt by association blackens both. but this isn't (accidental) association. this is a direct, paid relationship.

and association isn't useful anyway. what's interesting is understanding why.

you don't give money for nothing. you use it to buy (or invest in) something. maybe it's a useful service. palantir's products seem like exactly the kind of thing you'd buy if you were an intelligence agency. or hardware and software for processing a large volume of data.

but what about other companies here? can they all be explained that simply?

if not, what else could the money be buying? access? information?

that seems like a smart question to ask. particular when you no longer trust the person paying.

i don't think this is being paranoid, but i am curious. i'm not painting everyone black through simple "association", but i am asking myself what is being sold.

and that seems like a reasonable question.

[indeed, given how reasonable that seems, your knee-jerk dismissal is odd. do you really not see the questions raised?]

Re:Startups That Received Investment from In-Q-Tel by nemothekid on Monday September 16, 2013 @07:11PM (#6396515)
If you look at their portfolio you would see most of these investments are centered around products, namely those that processes or make sense of either large amounts or complex data, nothing that includes covert surveillance a la facebook.

NSA bad actors withheld, I have a tough time seeing why anyone would consider In-Q-Tel a bad thing. A lot of our current technology (lets not forget the Internet) were born out of government funded projects.

Re:Startups That Received Investment from In-Q-Tel by fixxer on Monday September 16, 2013 @10:10PM (#6397188)
> I have a tough time seeing why anyone would consider In-Q-Tel a bad thing.

Wholeheartedly agree.

I take their investment as a stronger sign of success because they are closer to the customer (rather than just being one of those firms that bets on the greater fool theory).

Case in point, consider their 10gen play. CIA has been a major player in database design since the beginning:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oracle_Corporation#Overall_time...

Re:Startups That Received Investment from In-Q-Tel by martinlandau on Monday September 16, 2013 @06:59PM (#6396455)
Yah I agree, this list doesn't build all the bridges that are really there, like Joe Lonsdale (of Palantir) now funding OculusVR. We need a list that connects all the relevant people and boards with everyone else, then we will have a more accurate picture. Can anyone provide it?
Re:Startups That Received Investment from In-Q-Tel by timr on Monday September 16, 2013 @04:17PM (#6395616)
Yeah, but that's just what you would say if you were in on the conspiracy. Obviously.

(Aside: I can't help but notice that 10gen is in that list. MongoDB is clearly a tool for the Man. That means that people will start using real databases again, right?)

Re:Startups That Received Investment from In-Q-Tel by wglb on Monday September 16, 2013 @05:08PM (#6395917)
Help me out with this... So what would, exactly, he say if he were not in the conspiracy?
Re:Startups That Received Investment from In-Q-Tel by aristidb on Monday September 16, 2013 @05:13PM (#6395952)
That's the point. It's somewhat like this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catch_22
Re:Startups That Received Investment from In-Q-Tel by martinlandau on Monday September 16, 2013 @06:51PM (#6396406)
Palmer Luckey of Oculus fame was funded by Joe Lonsdale, of Palantir. He told me Lonsdale hasn't been involved with Palantir in over 4 years though, so any associations with "spooks" or "nsa" type stuff is silly. Yah right, OK Palmer Luckey, like the NSA, CIA wouldn't love to control hardware and software related to future VR worlds. Like Lonsdale has been able to cut all ties, I thought the old saying was once you get in, you never get out, at least not willingly! LOL! I think Palmer Luckey is a sith lord.