News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by mistercow on Sunday September 15, 2013 @07:56PM (#6390835)
This sounds pretty neat; a handful of modest little adjustments that could prevent a lot of headaches. Being able to instantly take Colemak with me to any computer would be amazing (although carrying a keyboard around everywhere I use a computer sounds iffy).

Now I've said some positive things, so I'm going to nitpick. This is HN, after all.

The first thing that stands out to me is that it doesn't seem like a lot of attention has been paid to ergonomic details. The lowest hanging fruit here, which I've never seen in any keyboard, is to put feet on the side toward the user. In almost all cases, the way I've seen people's desks set up is such that there is no way for them to have a neutral wrist position (wrists not bending up). Worse yet, keyboards invariably have those little feet on the back, and people assume they should use them, which causes them to bend their wrists up even more. Ideally, a keyboard would let you fine tune its slope so that you can set it up exactly to your needs, although I have no idea how you would build that conveniently.

The second nitpick is with something Atwood says on the linked page:

> Nothing lets you get your thoughts out of your brain and into words faster and more efficiently than a well made keyboard.

Technically that is true, in the sense that a stenotype is technically a keyboard. But the reason I'm picking this nit is that as someone who has made it a side quest to find something better than a standard computer keyboard, this is a bit of a sore spot for me. The minimum you have to be able manage on a stenotype to be a court reporter is 225 wpm for live testimony. That's a $50k/year job where a requirement is typing faster than the all time world record for a typewriter-style keyboard.

That's a phonetic system, and it's not immediately obvious how to untangle all of the issues with making it work with programming. On the other hand, there's Veyboard, which is non-phonetic and more flexible, and seems like it could be used for programming in its current state. It's slower than stenotype, but far faster than a traditional keyboard.

My point is that it irks me that we have so many people typing so much and getting injured, and not much focus seems to be going into adopting a better, radically different approach. We have a handful of very expensive hardware options intended for specialized markets, and we have Plover[1] (nothing similar exists that I know of for emulating a Veyboard), and that's about it. And on the mass market side, we have less expensive, specially designed ergonomic traditional keyboards based mostly on shakily researched principles.

Would it necessarily help with RSI just to increase typing speed? That needs to be tested. But it seems likely that if you reduce the amount of time spent typing, you'll reduce the amount of damage.

[1]http://plover.stenoknight.com/

Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by jseliger on Sunday September 15, 2013 @08:11PM (#6390882)
Regarding ergonomics, I've been using a Kinesis Advantage for the last couple years (http://jseliger.wordpress.com/2009/07/20/kinesis-advantage/), and I would find it hard to return to a standard keyboard all the time.

The Advantage is absurdly expensive relative to other keyboards but for someone who spends a lot of time—too much, probably—typing, it's worth it.

Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by jonhohle on Sunday September 15, 2013 @08:42PM (#6390956)
I've been considering building an Ergodox[0], which has a Kinesis inspired key layout, but does not have the concave key well. In your experience with the Kinesis, would having a flat layout be a significant impediment to the comfort of another matrix key layout?

[0] http://ergodox.org

Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by eikenberry on Sunday September 15, 2013 @11:27PM (#6391447)
I'm also a kinesis fan having used one nearly exclusively for the last 4-5 years. For me the concave layout is nice, it makes it easier to reach the keys, but it is not the key ingredient. The thing about the kinesis which would make it very hard to change back to a standard layout keyboard is the thumb based meta keys.

I've looked a the Ergodox myself as well as this one [1] which I'm not sure has a name yet. I read about it originally here on HN [2].

[1] http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=44940.810 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6297356

Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by jseliger on Sunday September 15, 2013 @10:34PM (#6391303)
In your experience with the Kinesis, would having a flat layout be a significant impediment to the comfort of another matrix key layout?

It's probably not optimal but probably is an improvement. Having the space and backspace keys (which are probably the two I use most) under my thumbs is a HUGE advantage.

That being said, if you can get the cash together the Kinesis is worth it. I didn't think so at first, but, as I say in the post, I went back to a regular keyboard after sending the review unit back. Then I found the money.

Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by w1ntermute on Sunday September 15, 2013 @08:15PM (#6390894)
I might have asked you this before (in a prior thread), but do you have the pedals that go with the Kinesis and, if so, how (useful) are they?
Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by jseliger on Sunday September 15, 2013 @10:39PM (#6391325)
Nope. My guess is "reasonably," but I don't see a use case where I'd use them often enough to bother.
Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by fsck--off on Sunday September 15, 2013 @10:51PM (#6391354)
Foot pedals can eliminate the need for full sized function keys. You can also use foot pedal wiring to add new physical buttons onto the keyboard.

http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=26579.0

Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by w1ntermute on Sunday September 15, 2013 @10:55PM (#6391362)
You mentioned the difficulty of typing {}[] using the Kinesis Advantage. Perhaps Ctrl, Alt, Shift could be moved to the foot pedals, and then the keys for Ctrl, Alt, Shift could be remapped to {}[].
Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by fsck--off on Monday September 16, 2013 @02:21AM (#6391915)
If you're going to use an unusual keyboard remap it's easier just to adopt a completely different layout, e.g. Programmer Dvorak or something like that. You can use software to remap the symbol keys to be unshifted and on the number row. My remap puts the parentheses keys on the number row in the columns above my left and right index fingers.

The number row can be rearranged so that the odd numbers are under one hand, and the even numbers are under the other (which makes it much easier to learn to touch type numbers because the layout can be "derived" if you forget it.)

You can even set up a dead key to act like Alt-Gr so that you can use both Alts as "Meta" keys in Emacs.

A unique remapping might sound like overkill, but if you learn the new layout while adjusting to a Kinesis it doesn't seem strange at all. It also does not really require any technical knowledge.

Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by jseliger on Monday September 16, 2013 @10:10PM (#6397189)
That's a great point—I hadn't thought about it, though in retrospect it's obvious.
Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by yapcguy on Sunday September 15, 2013 @08:58PM (#6390991)
Have you used the Kinesis Freestyle 2 or the just released Microsoft Sculpt Ergonomic keyboard? If so, what are your thoughts?
Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by jseliger on Sunday September 15, 2013 @10:38PM (#6391317)
No. They both look like net improvements, however. The Sculpt also uses scissor keys like the ones on MacBooks or, at least at one point, Thinkpads, which is an interesting choice. I prefer keys with more travel, but that's pure preference.

Pretty much no one likes the standard rubber-dome keys.

Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by howardbeware on Sunday September 15, 2013 @09:46PM (#6391155)
Regarding stenotype hardware options and Plover, check out the Stenosaurus (http://www.stenosaurus.com). It's not out yet, but it looks promising.
Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by mistercow on Sunday September 15, 2013 @09:55PM (#6391182)
That looks pretty neat. Do they have a page with any more information on it?
Re:Typing stealth: a review of the CODE Keyboard by howardbeware on Sunday September 15, 2013 @11:08PM (#6391400)