News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Local Motors: collaborative car design, construction, and... by vaksel on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @08:00PM (#638923)
Here is the question you need to ask yourself...is your community going to be buying your cars? Seems to me, like the current community is made up of artistic types who'd rather buy a Prius(which probably explains the engine choice). You need to go promote the thing on offroader sites to see the true market conditions, or you'll end up building a car noone wants.

You can experience those same jumps in a lifted Bronco. And if you screw up and roll the thing, you won't be out 50K.

Yes there are people who have 50K invested in their rigs. But that didn't happen overnight, it happened year to year, a few grand at a time. And very few of those high end rigs get taken offroad + when its time to sell, the people get bent over the table, since you won't find many people willing to spend that much money on a weekend toy.

Going to the site now, would be pretty pointless since its just pictures. No guarantee that the thing will even be built. Knowing that it takes close to 2000 hours to assemble a kit car, I don't think we'll be seeing a finished product for a couple of years.

Re:Local Motors: collaborative car design, construction, and... by jrogers on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @09:56PM (#639052)
True that the site is a large proportion of design enthusiasts right now, but since that is who normally designs cars, are we any worse off than a normal car company.<br><br> If you were to jump a Bronco, it would be nothing like the Rally Fighter and we have plenty of Bronco Jumpers in our team to prove it. Short wheel base short travel, Bronco's make for a spine pounding ride over 35miles per hour on a baja desert.<br><br> As for the site having more than pictures, I recommend clicking the build tab. The Rally fighter will be debuted at SEMA (Nov 09). <br><br> Many kit cars take 200 hrs to build...Lone Star (7 days), Factory Five same, etc. You must be good to make this time, but 2000 hours is excessive (though possible for certain people on certain builds). The whole point is that we started Local Motors to addres those scary long build times. Come aboard and give it a little try before you declare so unilaterally that it will never work. Are you so desperate for it to fail? We are pretty good at listening to our faults and appreciate all of your criticism. Hope to see you on the site. (www.local-motors.com)
Re:Local Motors: collaborative car design, construction, and... by vaksel on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @11:57PM (#639194)
Yes design enthusiasts are the ones who design cars...but I doubt at GM/Honda/BMW that they are the ones making the engine choice. Nothing wrong with having a diesel option, but you are forcing your customers to pay a premium, for something they don't need.

I mean if you are going to use a BMW engine, why not use the one from 335i? If you look at BMWs: 335i sedan 300hp for $40K, 335d sedan 265hp for $45K.

So that's a ~$5K premium for the diesel option. I dunno about you, but pretty much every car enthusiast I know, would rather pay $5K less, and get 35 more hp. And lets not forget the fact that the 335i engine has a crapload of aftermarket support, while the 335d has none.

I'm not an offroader, so I dunno about jumping etc. But thats sorta the point, desert racers are almost non-existent, there are so very few of them out there, and only a tiny percentage of those can afford to pay $50K for a toy. You pretty much slashed your possible market to a few hundred rich guys who are into offroading.

The pictures I was talking about the other designs.

I'm not saying the whole idea is a failure, I'm saying that the starting vehicle choice is. Your motto is "Build the car of your dreams", but then you turn around and select a vehicle that only a tiny minority would want.

Re:Local Motors: collaborative car design, construction, and... by jrogers on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @07:52AM (#639585)
Cool, now we are talking. Couple of thoughts.

1 - we are using the 335i engine. And it is one of 3 engine systems we have fitted for the rally fighter. So I agree.

2 - Our entire business is a revolutionary auto business model, so we are structured to do niche production and make that our winning strategy. Each micro-factory serves only a regional area. 2000cars max production. Kinda like IKEA or Cabella's for cars. So call it a minority and you would be right. As for desert racing. It is a big deal in the American Southwest, so we believe it will be successful. The whole point is that since people like you (and me) don't off-road race and don't really know about it, that big companies like Honda, Chevy, and BMW will never make a car that works for this minority since the market isn't big enough to support their massive tooling costs...voila a market opportunity is created for a startup company. Since the Rally Fighter is on and off road legal and seats 2 adults in front and 2 in back (or 3 car seats), it is not my definition of a toy. But I certainly want people to think of it as the most fun car and experience that they have ever bought.

I love your thoughts, and I so wish you were making these critiques on our forum so our community could hear your thoughts. We are about to launch a general forum and perhaps we can entice you to post there.

We will soon be choosing our next LM model to make with the help of our community, and we would love to have you involved in that choice.

Thought you might want to checkout this post last night by Jeff Jarvis on his BuzzMachine Blog. The comment stream there shows the breadth of opinion. http://bit.ly/9CRkv

Re:Local Motors: collaborative car design, construction, and... by vaksel on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @01:51PM (#640097)
1-Didn't know, the site pretty much just states the 335d's engine.

2-Are you sure it'll be road legal? Pretty sure the ride height alone would disqualify it. And if it fails to be road legal, then its pretty much is a weekend toy by definition.

Sure car companies aren't making cars for the market, but how much of that is that they don't know a market exists, and how much of it is that they see that the demand is met by dirt bikes, ATVs, Dune Buggies. Also I think car companies do cater somewhat to this market with specific models/trims.

General blogs is something you shouldn't put too much emphasis on. I mean take that Jeff Jarvis guy...he thinks: "its first model is a muscle car", which obviously its not.

You need to hit up some offroader forums to get some true feedback. Moving to Arizona couldn't hurt either. I mean if you look at it, you have a bunch of guys in Boston, trying to build the perfect desert racer for someone in Arizona(are there many deserts in Massachusetts?), for all you know whomever you are consulting on what people in Arizona want is pulling your chain: "Oh yeah, we'd LOVE a pink hybrid to offroad in, we love the environment and mother earth".

Re:Local Motors: collaborative car design, construction, and... by jrogers on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @08:53PM (#640754)
@vaksel Correction, I was distinguishing the 335 from the X6, we are using the 335d. As for why not the 335i, The carbon footprint is worse than the 335d given that it is 30% less fuel efficient. We are focused on changing the impact of vehicles and this is a good way to start. If we were going to go for a gas system, we are prepared to offer the LS series engines. More hp by 430 vs 300. I hear you on the "Performance, Reliability, Price...choose 2" That has been true in the past, but we do not think that applies when you compare our product+experience to others product. LM is "Design, Performance, Buildability, Price...choose 3 (green is a given)". Our customers want great looking and great performance, and don't want to be keyed in the parking lot for driving something whose mpg is measured in gpm vice mpg. If someone wants to race and get more than the 425lb-ft from the 335d, then they have the room to swap to an LS7 and to crank it up.

As for road legal, you are thinking of passenger car specs, this vehicle would classify as a mixed use vehicle in which case many of the FMVSS specs to which you are referring would not be applicable. Hope that helps.

As for buggies and dirtbikes occupying the market...I guess I am just not going to be able to convince you and should not try. But here goes. ATVs and Bikes are a TOTALLY different experience which require a much more fit rider and mindset. Buggies are not anywhere near as capable as "trucks" made for this landscape (to be precise, we are talking about 25mph max vs 70mph avg.) Then there is the subject of Pre-running. Much of it today is done either in sand-rail/types or in sup'd up F-150/types. Most races (i.e. Reno to Vegas) are pre-run in a column of cars where you are simply eating dust the entire day. So sandrails are miserable, go ask John Marking of Fox Racing. As for sup'd up F-150 types after spending in excess of 150K you will have 10 inches of wheel travel and a 7000lb vehicle that needs a 700+ hp engine to move it, and it becomes a veritable space race of mass and power. The whole point is that no company has ever seen the profit in making cars for this size market, but LM makes cars with a much lower break-even volume allowing us to access a much smaller niche. Even if you are right and the market is not as large as we would want, we will have invested less than $2MM in the build program, so we can afford to scrap it and move on to the next ...compare this to Fisker or Tesla (other startup car co.'s) that have each raised in excess of $200MM and only have 1 model competing in very VERY busy marget segments.

As for MA, you are at Y-Combinator and should understand this. Just because we are starting in MA doesn't mean that we are finishing here. We are in a small startup Ops Center. We have 2 letters of intent on properties in Phoenix and are already working on our MA model. When we started we had no idea that the community would like the performance off-road desert racing segment, so we couldn't predict where would be best to go...so we dove in and got started. Hindsight is 20-20, but I prefer to get going. After all, this is unlike any start-up in any typical venture type market, so some of the nimble ideas do not apply as well. We are building a car company in an intensely difficult time and are taking risks where we feel appropriate and necessary and taking them large. Where we do not need to take risk, we are intensely conservative. I also hope that this helps.

Again, I am so stoked that you care enough to dig and to answer. I really think that our community could use your insight...hope you will join www.local-motors.com

Re:Local Motors: collaborative car design, construction, and... by vaksel on Thursday June 04, 2009 @12:17AM (#640947)
Well the 335i vs 335d is a difference of only 10 mpg...sure it sounds great to say 30% more efficient, but thats something people care about in daily drivers, not the weekend toys. And yes the LSx would be a better choice, I was just giving the example of the 335i just because its another bmw engine.

I just don't believe that there are that many green gearheads to gamble the stake of the company on. Not when you have people running test pipes just to get a few extra horsepower.

Yes people want a good looking car, yes they want to have great performance, as far as the keying thing that pretty much never happens. The only times I heard of cars getting keyed involved a bat shit crazy ex girlfriend.

The thing is, why not offer the LSx as manufacturer installed option. In the build stage it makes pretty much zero difference on what engine to put in. Give the people the choice. Same goes for SEMA, you'll get much friendlier coverage if the demo model has a real engine under the hood. If you do, the coverage will focus on the car company. If you choose to use the 335d engine, the coverage will focus on ridiculing the engine choice. Its just too easy of a target.

I'll take your word about the mixed use thing, since I couldn't really find anything about it. But I don't think its as easy as you are hoping for it to be. I mean, its pretty much impossible to import a car from Japan or Europe and make it road legal.

Well like I said its not really my segment, I like to stick to tarmac. And yeah Tesla and Fisker have invested a ton more money, but lets face it, they are doing a completely different thing since their cars are electric. And require a much larger support system, + they've actually finished their cars. And there is no reason to scrap the thing, something like this(although a little meaner looking) would probably do quiet well in a place like Dubai.

How did you actually pick this thing over some of the other designs? I mean I honestly can't see anyone picking this thing if they had other choices that included super cars. You sure you didn't get spammed by the designer using a bunch of proxies?

And there is nothing wrong with taking risks, it just seems like in this situation, you are taking it for no apparent reason. I mean lets face it, with 2,000 cars, you could build a copy of Pontiac Aztec, and still sell your full inventory over a few years. So why start out in a market with zero mainstream appeal? Why not think long term? Instead of building a car for a tiny market, build something for the mainstream enthusiast. Instead of targeting the few thousand offroaders, target the millions of sports car enthusiasts.

There is plenty of space for a U.S. version of TVR. And the $45K-75K sport coupe market is pretty bare. Plenty of opportunity to enter with an exotic looking limited production super car that doesn't cost an arm and a leg.

Dunno about joining the site, maybe when you add the general message board, where it'll be more of a real discussion and not just a commenting system to a bunch of photoshops.

Re:Local Motors: collaborative car design, construction, and... by AriFerreira on Sunday June 07, 2009 @10:00AM (#645907)
Sorry for the delay, Vaskel! Had a bit of traveling to do these past few days. I went from Chicago to Atlanta for my Father's wedding - what a to-do, great fun. (TMI? :) )

In our eyes 10mpg is a huge savings. Couple that with efficiency gains by utilizing lightweight materials, and boost that with a clean diesel with reduced emissions; for Local Motors, this is the way to move forward. We are not looking for a one-time solution and we will get better as time goes on. With each step, with each vehicle we can only hope to improve with each iteration.

Your views are well heard, and we are aware that many share your views on the type of engine which would be easiest to use and manipulate. If we have made a mistake and the 335d is too difficult, the Rally Fighter is fit for 2 other engine opitons - among those is a plain ol' gasoline engine. Not our favorite option, but we do hear you.

Laughed about the bat shit crazy ex girlfriend. Thank you for that :)

Your words, "Give the people a choice" hits home. The open development process at local-motors.com is exactly that - a forum for participation and choice. While we can digest what you say in this space, the votes of our community members and dedicated participants are the votes and voices we follow. We want your voice to be heard. If you would prefer to wait for a vehicle that is more personal, one that you would use and have a personal vested interest in, I understand. I don't think the desert racing segment is your cup o' tea. But your opinion is so valuable, so consider yourself invited to take part.

RE: "zero mainstream appeal", the segment is certainly limited and the choice is intentional. This is a segment in which we could build a product to have very clear improvements over anything else on the market. A segment that is already building cars, and a segment that is passionate like you wouldn't believe. We will build cars for the tarmac, for Jersey - but we will not, not, not build cars for the masses. Please everyone, and you will eventually please no one. The future of exciting products and cars is niche and supported by a hands-on experience. Again, time will tell as to whether we are "right". I hope you will stay close so we can hash out this conversation again as we grow, and as new niche local markets make their desires known.

I also want to note that I think all of your notes on the US auto industry and market potential are more or less right on. There is space for not only more cars in the segments you mentioned, there is also room for more car companies. I agree with you.

Trust that we have done our "homework", and our business model is viable on a local level w/ limited production for niche markets. The changes you are suggesting we make ("build for mainstream enthusiast", "target millions") would make us un-local motors - and that is not our goal.

This company and community is focused on creating a unique local experience for local enthusiasts. Your suggestions & strategy may be viable, but it is not local.

Thanks again!

Ariel Ferreira

[email protected]