News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by nawitus on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:32PM (#6386761)
>How were you supposed to know?

It's safe to assume all animal products are unethical.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by venomsnake on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:40PM (#6386999)
Also eating plants is unethical. For them to be developed we needed to destroy habitats, displace species and cause suffering too.

We are invasive species. What we should aim is low impact farming. To extract the most food with the least possible amount of suffering caused and resources expended.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by refurb on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:22PM (#6387112)
I never understood the "humans are an invasive species". If a beaver builds a dam and floods a habitat forcing out the native species thats "natural".

Humans do the same thing and it's "invasive".

I take the view that humans are as natural as any other animal on the planet. We obviously have a goal to sustain the ecosystems we value, but we're just as much a part of the ecosystem as any other animal.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by bmelton on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:33PM (#6387147)
It isn't that we're 'invasive' in relation to nature, it's that we're 'invasive' by our own definitions of the word.

For what it's worth, the beaver that forces out native species by flooding a habitat is both natural and invasive. Beavers are considered, by humans, to be a fairly invasive species, especially when introduced to areas they are not native to.

It isn't a double-standard that we're applying, it's just a little uncomfortable when the same standard is applied to us.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by refurb on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:53PM (#6387204)
There isn't an animal out there that doesn't have some impact on it's environment. Humans are no different.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by bmelton on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:57PM (#6387215)
I don't disagree, but there are species that invariably have more impact on their environment than others, and those species with inordinate amounts of impact on their environments, or nominal impacts in their native environment with non-nominal impacts in non-native environments are defined as 'invasive'.

We fit our definition for the term. Like I said before though, I don't see anything unnatural about it myself.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by dasil003 on Saturday September 14, 2013 @08:49PM (#6387745)
I don't have a problem being invasive per se, but if we eventually change the environment such that we have a very difficult time surviving (which seems a realistic possibility the long term) then I'd say we're a pretty poor species.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by iooi on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:22PM (#6387475)
No, eating plants is not unethical. This might interest you:

http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1mdqbr/if_the_wo...

The short story is that it takes up more land to feed and house livestock than it does to farm plants. "More than two-thirds of all agricultural land is devoted to growing feed for livestock, while only 8 percent is used to grow food for direct human consumption."

Not to mention the amount of water livestock and its feed consumes.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by makomk on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:27PM (#6387490)
From what I recall there's some debate over whether meat production does necessarly have to consume more land than farming an equivalent amount of plants, eg: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2010/sep/06/meat-pr...
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by nawitus on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:51PM (#6387029)
Technically speaking my point was "it's more unethical to consume animal products than it is to consume plant-based products".
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by venomsnake on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:34PM (#6387150)
That is interesting question. Is it more unethical to torture a species and ensure its survival because it is tasty, or to push a species to extinction to farm on its former habitat? And why?

This is one of those questions that drink a lot of beer and lead to violence among friends late in the evenings. With no good answer.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by tedks on Saturday September 14, 2013 @09:59PM (#6387875)
Do you think a species as a unit has preferences?

It seems like your friends are conflating genetics and utilitarian ethics. There's a way of explaining genetics in terms of preferences, but genes don't really have preferences. Species, by extension, don't have preferences. Cows as a species want nothing. Individual cows do.

So personally, as a vegan, I wouldn't see the death of the last cow on earth as a huge loss, as long as the cow was safe, happy, and comfortable.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by dinkumthinkum on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:26PM (#6388023)
Or we should just stop hating our species ... Just a thought. Sorry, I just have uncontrollable disdain for this attitude. :)
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by blahedo on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:22PM (#6386940)
> It's statistically reasonable to assume any particular animal product, that was bought in a store, in the US, and doesn't advertise any particular affiliation with ethical-treatment or other specialty causes, is unethical.

I think this is roughly what you meant, right? There are lots of exceptions to the totally blanket assertion, although I think the underlying sentiment (as carefully caveatted above) is basically correct.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by tedks on Saturday September 14, 2013 @09:56PM (#6387868)
...so it's safe to assume all animal products are unethical.

According to that statement, the ethical value of any animal product is a function of some huge number of variables, and the upper bound on that value is the minimum of that set.

So, it's safe to assume that all animal products you encounter as a human are unethical. Regardless of where you buy them, or what their advertising is, you should assume they are unethical and be very, very difficult to persuade. Anything else is just unsafe.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by blahedo on Monday September 16, 2013 @06:02PM (#6396206)
I agree, and I understood the careful phrasing ("safe", "assume") in the original remark---but given the number of people who apparently didn't understand, I wanted to give a clarified version.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by tedks on Wednesday September 18, 2013 @05:42PM (#6408352)
I think the problem with your phrasing is that most humans will interpret it to mean "oh, I can just find something that looks good on any one of these metrics, and then it'll be ethical."

This is why animal welfare-ists exist, and why people think that there is such a thing as "happy meat."

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by nawitus on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:53PM (#6387035)
I don't think there's lots of exceptions. In fact, the exceptions are exceedingly rare.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by asciimo on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:31PM (#6387139)
One exception that comes to mind: A cow approaches you and graciously hands you a gallon of milk it excreted from its own udder, expressly as a gift to you.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by 4hthth4 on Saturday September 14, 2013 @06:58PM (#6387391)
That's just silly, they don't even have opposable thumbs. It would have to squirt the milk into your mouth.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by enraged_camel on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:36PM (#6386779)
What is so unethical about eggs or cow's milk?

edit: The point I am trying to make is that not all of our food comes from unethical industrial factory farms. There are a lot of farmers who use ethical and sustainable methods. It is not too difficult to do research and find out how your food is produced.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by dribnet on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:44PM (#6386816)
Is there anything wrong with force feeding a cow corn which makes them sick, injecting them with antibiotics so that doesn't kill them, impregnating them so that they produce milk, separating them from their calf at birth (who most likely will be used for veal) causing them distress, and making them livid a horrid life wading in cow shit their whole life until their hoofs are painfully literally rotting?

Yes, what is happening to the civets is appalling. But it's really no worse than what is standard CAFO treatment. It's not entirely your fault that you don't know this because the food industry tries very hard to keep this from you, including pushing for laws that make exposing these facts acts of terrorism.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by enraged_camel on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:55PM (#6386858)
I know all of it. What you don't seem to be aware of is that there are a lot of farmers who don't follow these practices. I make an effort to do research about the food I buy and to make sure it comes only from sustainable, non-industrial farming methods.

What I was trying to get at in my question is that there is nothing "safe" about the assumption that ALL animal products are unethical. It's just a blanket generalization that discourages learning more about the subject.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by integraton on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:41PM (#6387168)
Although most US farms are small farms, they are in decline and also far less productive, so the vast majority (85%) of output comes from large-scale farms.

Furthermore, because the agricultural system and all of the regulations support large-scale farming, small-scale family farms have to work within the system. (eg, http://www.businessweek.com/stories/2009-02-05/more-on-the-s...).

The trend is toward more factory farming, not less, since small scale farms are less profitable, often not covering costs. The difficulty of making small farms sustainable is generally attributed to the regulations, infrastructure, and economic realities increasingly favoring large scale factory farming.

If you doubt any of what I've said here, the USDA and others have plenty of reports available: http://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/err-economic-research-r...

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by dribnet on Saturday September 14, 2013 @10:29PM (#6387921)
I'm glad you are familiar with industrial farming as many people are not aware of how food gets to our supermarkets. However, even in the kindest of farm environments (which, incidentally I have visited first hand) I personally find milk production unethical. Force impregnating a cow and separating - and getting rid of - the calf at birth are not "practices" famers can opt out of, they are the biological and financial reality of producing milk.

I don't know if you can empathize with an animals plight at the discomfort of repeated pregnancies, births, and forced separations from their offspring - or the even grimmer likely outcome of the calf itself, but for me this is not justified by own fleeting enjoyment of a slice of cheese that is completely not necessary for my physical well being.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by deskglass on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:35PM (#6386981)
It's a near perfect generalization depending on where you food shop. Good luck finding eggs from ethical sources at Walmart or Publix.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by rickjames28 on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:56PM (#6388073)
Yeah, the PETA crowd argument, which gleans over the fact that the cow wouldn't exist to begin with if not for those evil farmers and human carnivores.

These anthropomorphic arguments tend to be the result of emotional immaturity, something you find in small children.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by frankzinger on Sunday September 15, 2013 @09:33AM (#6389021)
"These anthropomorphic arguments tend to be the result of emotional immaturity, something you find in small children."

Oh, the irony in this sentence!

It's anthropomorphic to think that dairy cows would choose to bear their immense suffering for the sake of the perpetuation of their species (EDIT: because they're not aware of such a concept; survival instinct is all about the individual being pain-averse in an immediate sense), and it's immature to resort to name-calling in an argument.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by city41 on Sunday September 15, 2013 @12:57AM (#6388160)
Cows would probably rather not ever existed than lead the lives they lead.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by cromulent on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:44PM (#6386815)
Depends on your ethics. 9 chickens per square meter for free-range, it's a bit tight for me personally.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-range_eggs

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by antsar on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:16PM (#6386922)
Huh, wow. It never even crossed my mind that "free-range" and "cage-free" might not mean what it sounds like it means. That was naive of me. 9 hens/meter does not sound very "free" to me either.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by asciimo on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:35PM (#6387153)
Man, do not worry about naivete. It's actually very difficult to learn the truth about the products we consume. That you are openly expressing your enlightenment is remarkable, and worth celebrating.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by Tyr42 on Sunday September 15, 2013 @12:45AM (#6388142)
In addition to these requirements, free-range systems must also provide the following:

One hectare of outdoor range for every 2500 hens (equivalent to 4m^2 per hen; at least 2.5 m^2 per hen must be available at any one time if rotation of the outdoor range is practiced)

From the wikipedia page you linked. That's not too bad, is it?

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by prof_hobart on Sunday September 15, 2013 @07:34AM (#6388770)
Depends where you live. "In the EU each hen must have at least 4 square metres of space."
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by joel_perl_prog on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:14PM (#6387094)
I may have already missed the window where people will read this reply, but let me tell you the basic error in your thinking. Yes it's true that Old MacDonald actually does exist. He may be your neighbor. He's certainly my father's neighbor, out in the country, in Michigan. And you can buy eggs. And a few other people, too.

But guess what. Well into the 90s percent of people don't do that. Probably high 90s percent. And they never could either, because as soon as they tried, you'd see it can't scale up. The only thing that can scale up is the rotten situation we currently have--the one that produces that 90s percentage of the eggs and milk (and meat, which you didn't mention, but it's likewise a parallel here for people who believe in "humane" meat).

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by jkn on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:45PM (#6386817)
I had a discussion with someone who feels strongly about this recently, and he pointed out that even the few chickens and cows that get decent treatment during their lives are brought to the slaughter house when they're not productive anymore (except for a negligible minority of cases). Even if we assume the best slaughtering conditions (wrongly, most likely) it's not hard to see how that can be perceived as unethical.

He did mention that people who take good care of their chickens and cows during their whole life are a different story.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by nawitus on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:55PM (#6387049)
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by rosser on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:42PM (#6386806)
Apparently, you're not very familiar with modern factory farming. One word: "debeaking".
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by 300bps on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:52PM (#6386847)
I eat eggs and my kids drink milk but some people find unethical the environmental impact of using animals to convert relatively efficient vegetable production to relatively inefficient animal production.

Some info: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_meat_pr...

Another thing people find unethical about it are adding literally tons of needless antibiotics to the environment which can have human medical impact.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by smoyer on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:29PM (#6387132)
Do you use a fabric softener? (or a detergent with one in it?) ... sometimes is can be surprising where you find animal products.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by jghrng on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:40PM (#6386798)
It gets unethical pretty quickly as it is produced at industrial scale.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by SeanLuke on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:17PM (#6386929)
Cows only give milk after they give birth. Ask yourself where those calves go.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by huherto on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:02PM (#6387061)
I imagine the female are probably used for Milk. The male calves probably end up being slaughter.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by SeanLuke on Saturday September 14, 2013 @06:37PM (#6387339)
Veal.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by turing on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:10PM (#6387433)
There are a lot of farmers who use ethical and sustainable methods.

Depends on how you define "a lot". The vast majority of eggs and milk produced in the United States are not in any way ethically produced.

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by deskglass on Saturday September 14, 2013 @04:39PM (#6386997)
One such means of reseach is browsing through this site and finding what top rated brands are available where you shop. http://www.cornucopia.org/organic-egg-scorecard/ They also have a less detailed milk scorecard. Note, they only look at organic eggs and they weigh some things other than how the animals are treated based on their political beliefs. Still, they list every category and you can choose which ones you care about.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by notjosh on Saturday September 14, 2013 @03:56PM (#6386862)
The issue of what happens to the males is often overlooked. In dairy cattle, the bulls are relatively useless (low meat yield, etc), so they're killed. Same with roosters - laying breeds are far different from meat breeds, so the males are ground up as chicks.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by dinkumthinkum on Saturday September 14, 2013 @11:32PM (#6388034)
You all are making some bold claims about what is and is not ethical ... Does everyone not realize that ethics and the derivation of ethics is a fairly complex issue?
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by oneeyedpigeon on Sunday September 15, 2013 @09:28AM (#6389008)
Exactly. Most people's arguments are "you say that X is unethical for these reasons, and you therefore avoid X, but Y has similarities with X and you don't avoid Y - that makes you wrong to avoid X" which is plainly ridiculous. This shouldn't be about absolutes.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by bdcravens on Saturday September 14, 2013 @05:30PM (#6387135)
Intrinsically nothing is wrong.

Obviously you appreciate the value of research. It's amazing that people will research the purchase of a new phone more than what they eat?

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by narwally on Sunday September 15, 2013 @09:39AM (#6389045)
That's not exactly an obvious conclusion.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_realism

Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by Pxtl on Saturday September 14, 2013 @06:42PM (#6387356)
What do you think happens to the useless males. The little infant bulls and roosters?
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by peterwwillis on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:06PM (#6387422)
The original way this was marketed was (paraphrasing): "civets roam the forest, eat cherries, poop, and we collect the poop." In other words, not farmed at all. Sounded ethical to me at the time.
Re:Civet coffee: why it's time to cut the crap by theorique on Saturday September 14, 2013 @07:42PM (#6387542)
What about some kind of artisanal steak, locally-curated by genuine Brooklyn hipsters? Or Kobe beef - those cattle get massages!