Lots of places get water from private suppliers.
And, you might notice a lot of private security. They don't have extraordinary arrest powers, but ....
> We cannot leave the protection of free speech to companies, or other groups of citizens: they would inevitably suppress certain bits of knowledge from becoming publicly known.
How does a private entity suppress what I want to say? (They may refuse to pay me to say something, refuse to help me say something, or refuse to say something themselves, but that's no suppression.)
Free speech includes the freedom to publish information that has been decided to be 'public information'.
As to financial information, if a company doesn't provide the information that you want, don't do whatever it is that you're considering doing with them. You're free to not deal with a company for any reason that you please, including lack of info, bad info, dice rolls, or even no reason.
Same with people. I have no "free speech" right to information about you but I'm also not obligated to deal with you if I don't like what I hear or don't hear.
If so, then isn't the difference between the two covered by the protection of free speech? The company would like you to shut up, like pressure groups would like you to shut up about certain things, but they can't make you shut up, because Big Brother is protecting you, because it has decided that this is a kind of information that you are allowed to publish. Isn't that protection of free speech?
The question doesn't make any sense.
Free speech is a right of "owners".
I'm free to blather on and on about MY stuff. Companies have no way to intefere in that because they don't have police and stuff. Governments do.
I don't have any free speech rights WRT stuff owned by other people.
Suppose that I worked at Google. It's not a violation of my "free speech" rights for Google to refuse to publish Google's stuff, whether or not I produced said stuff for them.
Furthermore, not everything can be left to companies. Public utilities like the police and water are supplied/regulated by the government for all the usual reasons. Knowledge is also a public utility. We cannot leave the protection of free speech to companies, or other groups of citizens: they would inevitably suppress certain bits of knowledge from becoming publicly known.
Isn't the knowledge of 'where to find what' exactly that kind of knowledge? A near monopoly on search results grants a company great power. In a possible near future, wouldn't it be in Google's best interests to suppress the information of where to find competitors? Not blatantly of course, but when done is subtle ways, will anyone notice? Will anyone believe those who cry wolf? And how devastating it would be to the competition!