News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by swombat on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @12:52PM (#638112)
I'm not entirely convinced that a public body would be better at determining what should be visible than a private company. Both have their pros and cons. Private companies will tend to look at what's best for their users in order to maximise profits. Public bodies will tend to look at what's appropriate politically.

Considering how corrupt most political bodies are (see all the various lobbying efforts and other expenses scandals) and considering the importance of search, I'm not sure that a public body can be entrusted with it. It's too important to screw it up in the way that governments tend to.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by calambrac on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @05:01PM (#638629)
This is Cory Doctorow, I doubt very much that he means 'government' when he says 'public'.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by Confusion on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @03:14PM (#638427)
Private companies try to maximize profits, but that doesn't necessarily mean they do what's best for their users. Fast-food stores encouraging people to eat there often are a good example. Apple refusing certain apps is another one: it's not in my advantage, nor in that of most of my peers, that they limit my choice.

Furthermore, not everything can be left to companies. Public utilities like the police and water are supplied/regulated by the government for all the usual reasons. Knowledge is also a public utility. We cannot leave the protection of free speech to companies, or other groups of citizens: they would inevitably suppress certain bits of knowledge from becoming publicly known.

Isn't the knowledge of 'where to find what' exactly that kind of knowledge? A near monopoly on search results grants a company great power. In a possible near future, wouldn't it be in Google's best interests to suppress the information of where to find competitors? Not blatantly of course, but when done is subtle ways, will anyone notice? Will anyone believe those who cry wolf? And how devastating it would be to the competition!

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by anamax on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @07:22PM (#638869)
> Public utilities like the police and water

Lots of places get water from private suppliers.

And, you might notice a lot of private security. They don't have extraordinary arrest powers, but ....

> We cannot leave the protection of free speech to companies, or other groups of citizens: they would inevitably suppress certain bits of knowledge from becoming publicly known.

How does a private entity suppress what I want to say? (They may refuse to pay me to say something, refuse to help me say something, or refuse to say something themselves, but that's no suppression.)

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by Confusion on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @04:19AM (#639424)
Governments must force companies to publish all kinds of information about their practices, such as a yearly financial report. Without that obligation, that information would never be made public, because the company would force individuals that wanted to publish the data to keep their mouth shut (that follows from the fact that many companies do their best to get an exemption from publishing all kinds of data).

Free speech includes the freedom to publish information that has been decided to be 'public information'.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by anamax on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @09:04AM (#639678)
Actually, no, that's not free speech. (BTW - That's not the employee's data, so it isn't their call.)

As to financial information, if a company doesn't provide the information that you want, don't do whatever it is that you're considering doing with them. You're free to not deal with a company for any reason that you please, including lack of info, bad info, dice rolls, or even no reason.

Same with people. I have no "free speech" right to information about you but I'm also not obligated to deal with you if I don't like what I hear or don't hear.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by Confusion on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @11:59AM (#639929)
Do you agree that there is a difference between what the government stipulates you are free to say and what a company would like you to be free to say, if they had their way?

If so, then isn't the difference between the two covered by the protection of free speech? The company would like you to shut up, like pressure groups would like you to shut up about certain things, but they can't make you shut up, because Big Brother is protecting you, because it has decided that this is a kind of information that you are allowed to publish. Isn't that protection of free speech?

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by anamax on Wednesday June 03, 2009 @02:13PM (#640133)
> Do you agree that there is a difference between what the government stipulates you are free to say and what a company would like you to be free to say, if they had their way?

The question doesn't make any sense.

Free speech is a right of "owners".

I'm free to blather on and on about MY stuff. Companies have no way to intefere in that because they don't have police and stuff. Governments do.

I don't have any free speech rights WRT stuff owned by other people.

Suppose that I worked at Google. It's not a violation of my "free speech" rights for Google to refuse to publish Google's stuff, whether or not I produced said stuff for them.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by madair on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @02:31PM (#638341)
Wow, wow, and wow. So you're saying better to trust a private interest than a public one, due to scandal & corruption?

Okay, I'm trying to do justice to this with a response, but it's just going to fall into a trap, probably a libertarian one, but I'm not really sure, perhaps just a childish one. I do need to leave a comment though, even one not very information filled, at least to cover the gap and give people pause and think about what you just said and all hopefully they will think of all its implications, until someone with more time fills in the gap or this article just fades away and the comment with it.

I hope, swombat, that you just haven't thought about all the implications of what you're saying, so at least you're just uneducated, and not evil.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by swombat on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @02:41PM (#638366)
Typing a 3-paragraph comment to finish with an empty ad-hominem is very lame.

I'm saying that I'm not convinced that putting a public body in charge of search would be any better than the current situation. I don't trust either of them.

I know what Google wants - they want us to continue using them and they want us to click on adverts. And I think they're smart enough to realise that if they mess too much with search results in an unethical way, people will get pissed off and go elsewhere.

A government body could have any number of varied and colourful motivations. They might want to pander to the latest anti-whatever craze and ban all related results. They might abuse their power for political purposes (far worse than commercial abuse imho).

Importantly, they might mandate that everything has to go through them. With search engines being private, I at least have the choice to go elsewhere. If you make this a public, government affair, they might pass laws requiring you to use their search engine, or other equally asinine things. Google at least is under no illusion that the only way it can convince people to use it is to provide the best results.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by madair on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @04:06PM (#638510)
It's more profitable for Google to self-censor in China. So they do.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by spot on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @04:43PM (#638595)
self-censorship is "Self-censorship is the act of censoring ... without an authority directly pressuring one to do so" (quoting the wikipedia).

needless to say, this is not the case of google in china.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by madair on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @04:56PM (#638619)
Self-censor, or be blocked. They self-censored.
Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by swombat on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @06:59PM (#638828)
I don't think that the fact that Google bowed to the chinese government's demands of self-censorship (or whatever you may call it) can be used as evidence that private companies are untrustworthy.

If anything, it's more evidence that governments shouldn't meddle with what should or should not be allowed in search.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by spot on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @05:59PM (#638734)
does "or be blocked" sound like direct pressure to you?
Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by madair on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @06:36PM (#638800)
Okay, so you're going to quibble over a questionable definition. Fine.

Google censors themselves.

[ADDED]

And since the brigade on this seems determined to dull the impact of the statement that in order to achieve higher profits, Google has chosen to censor itself, and thus is an excellent example of problems of self-regulation, here are some references:

"Google enters China, but censors itself" -- http://www.economist.com/agenda/displayStory.cfm?story_id=54...

"Google's decision to set up a self-censored version of its search engine in China this year aroused a storm of criticism in America." http://www.economist.com/world/displaystory.cfm?story_id=685...

"Google censors itself for China" -- http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/4645596.stm

"Google has agreed to censor its search engine in China. In return for blocking politically sensitive terms, Google gains access to the world's No. 2 Internet market." -- http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/cyberspace/jan-june06/google_...

Wow, can't believe this. Neither can I believe the claims also here that it's somehow debatable that too little regulation had nothing to do with the economic crisis we're in. Sigh.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by madair on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @03:09PM (#638421)
A typical set of fears of regulation. At least you clarify that you really meant what you said.

The people who think the market will self-regulate remain convinced even in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary, for instance the current banking and mortgage crisis.

Re:Cory Doctorow: Search is too important to leave to one co... by ryanwaggoner on Tuesday June 02, 2009 @03:53PM (#638488)
Actually, the case has been made that the current economic crisis is a good example of the consequences of too much government involvement. I'm not sure I agree, but the fact is that both sides are using this crisis as an example to backup their ideological viewpoints, and there's evidence on both sides. The truth is complex. To characterize one side as just sticking their head in the sand reveals your own bias.