The nice thing about using WEP is that if someone does end up using my network for something nefarious and I end up holding the bag for it, I (or an expert witness) can point out that WEP is known to be vulnerable in court giving me an out.
- Until they argue that the default encryption level on routers now is WPA/WPA2, so by enabling WEP you were actively lowering the security level.
- Until they argue that your technical background means that you should have known better that WEP is crackable.
Following your reasoning, my background means that I should know that I shouldn't have a wireless network at all. There are vulnerabilities for just about any method I would use to secure a wireless network.
My important stuff is firewalled within the network. I use WEP because it's the easiest way to give network access to folks I've authorized to use my network while still letting unauthorized users know they're not welcome.
It would be argued that you should have taken 'reasonable' measures to prevent unauthorized access. It could then be argued that using WEP is not reasonable, especially it you know it is easily crackable.
We should use the default standard method of locking our doors. And our Wi-Fi access points.
A better door analogy is replacing the deadbolt with a slightly crappier one that unlocks whenever you're in bluetooth range (for "convenience"). Just because the system is "easily broken into" doesn't mean that you're not "breaking and entering" when you break the security and enter the house.
However, I try to treat even my home WIFI as if it were a coffee shop. The password is there to keep leechers out, but I still vpn into a more secure location for some tasks, use SSL when connecting to sensitive services, and keep my ports locked down.
WPA2 is in fact quite secure if you're careful about your passkey and who you give it to.
Heck, in many countries, wifi routers actually use WPA2 with a pregenerated shared key, which is a good 24 chars long and fully random. Incredibly easy to guess or crack! (its very, very hard to crack.)
While it certainly could be the crowd I hang out with (not all of which are techies, mind you), but I've never met anyone who uses WPS.
- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wi-Fi_Protected_Setup#Security
Mind you, I think with open source firmware like TomatoUSB and good password you should be good.
The problem is with the PSK variety, mainly that it's susceptible to offline dictionary attack: about 5% of actual WPA2-PSKs can be easily guessed [1].
There is stuff in the works to fix this though. My favorite is EAP-PWD [2]. It's resistant to offline dictionary attacks, it has perfect forward secrecy and it's already supported by Android. Basically, it's what WPA2-PSK should have been.
In the mean time, if you're security conscious just set a long random PSK or configure e.g. EAP-TLS. Both will give you strong security against pretty much any attacker.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extensible_Authentication_Proto...
EDIT: Sorry for having repeated some of the stuff bjornsing already said. Should read through more carefully before rushing to comment, I guess.
Most of the problem is that passwords are either easy for computers to crack or hard for humans to remember. The middle ground has disappeared as computational power has increased.
Obligatory xkcd comic: https://xkcd.com/936/
Although mathematically the password given in the comic has a higher entropy and would take more time to crack under normal circumstances, the problem is that it follows a very simple and easily describable pattern: smash (four) dictionary words together into a combination.
Crackers will simply start using wordlist rules to generate large lists of meshed together dictionary words and use them if they have good reason to believe you're using this pattern (pretty sure it's simple with tools like Crunch). Whether they'll guess the proper order is unknown, but as with any other case people will use certain permutations and combinations more than others.
$ wc -l /usr/share/dict/words
119095
$ python -c 'print(119095 ** 4)'
201175048646341950625
$ python -c 'print(85 ** 10)'
19687440434072265625
So, even if your target is known to be using this scheme in pure form, this has more entropy than a completely random 10-digit password (assuming ~85 characters) -- and who would actually be using such a thing, except someone using a password management program - who could just as easily be using a 20-character random password?So even if it becomes known, it's an improvement on what users are doing now.
$ perl -E 'open(my $fh, "<", "/usr/share/dict/words"); my @words = map {chomp; $_} <$fh>; close $fh; say join " ", map {$words[int rand @words]} 1..4'
menu chemists administrative seeps
Might have to run it a couple of times before you get something that you can memorize. shuf -n 4 /usr/share/dict/words | tr -dc 'A-Za-z0-9'Obviously a random 64 character string would beat either of them, but if you're expecting a human to memorize a password, correct horse battery staple is clearly preferable.
There are more possible permutations of four words than permutations of 10 upper/lowercase letters, digits, and common symbols. The four random word approach is harder to crack.
is a really good password that people can remember easily.
Create a near-random 63 char password, put it in a text file on a USB key and possibly print it out as a QR code and you’ll never have to worry about either entering it by hand or it getting cracked by that strange kid across the street.
(You can copy and paste it, though.)
There are a few problems with all PSK schemes that make internal attacks problematic. Anyone who sniffs your initial handshake and knows the master PSK can read your traffic. There's a lack of mutual authentication. Having a scheme where each device registers its own password with the AP would probably be better.
Other than that, it's generally a good solution, why do you feel it needs replacing?
Search for it there is a list of routers that are better than others. With WPA+WPS we are mostly back to WEP days where any kid with a laptop and some googling skills can get access to many wireless networks.
The only thing WiFi passwords are good for is to prevent your neighbors from using your network and using up all of your bandwidth (which would slow down your network access) and preventing drive-by spammers/hackers from doing things which you might then get blamed for.