News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our approach to gender diversity by rayiner on Friday September 13, 2013 @07:06AM (#6379690)
I think this sort of affirmative approach is going to become more common as tech is dragged kicking and screaming into the 21st century.

When I was an engineer, I never worked under a woman in a technical role. Since I've been a lawyer, I've had a majority of female bosses and mentors. 50 years ago, this would have been unthinkable.

Doctors, accountants, and many other professionals can tell the same story. Today nobody thinks twice about the head of internal medicine at a hospital being a woman. Medical schools don't go out of their way to find qualified female candidates. Because of measures taken decades ago, these professions have achieved a level of normalcy that has totally eluded engineering as a profession.

Re:Our approach to gender diversity by JPKab on Friday September 13, 2013 @09:29AM (#6380281)
I am 31 years old. When I went to college in 1999, jobs which were considered to be high-status and high-pay: medical doctor, lawyer, engineer (I almost hesitate to include it because American society doesn't bludgeon you with the "engineers are all rich" meme like it does with doctors and lawyers.

Computer programmer is not one of them. In fact, we were constantly being told by the media that the future for programmers was bleak due to outsourcing.

The point I am making is that medical school and law school are viewed societally as risk-free, guaranteed paths to wealth. This is of course turning out to be a myth for law school. They are huge magnets for smart people who are following the standard path of university to job.

The "not enough women in tech" concept never took off until tech became consistently viewed as a high-status job. The vast majority of construction workers and mechanics are men, but you don't see a huge societal uproar about it. This is because these positions are low status in our society.

I can't find a male teacher in my son's elementary school, and yet a highly talented male teacher I know was turned down for a position at his school which was given to a young woman. While this issue (including the self-reinforcing feedback loop that deters men from becoming elementary teachers) has been well documented and discussed in niche circles, its not something that graces the cover of newspapers and magazines like the women in tech issue does.

Now that tech is a high status job, instead of just a high pay job, this will correct itself just like it did for law firms and medical practices.

I can tell you this: anyone who thinks that artificially shrinking the pool of experts which you can pick to speak at a conference won't affect the quality of the presentations is deluding themselves.

Re:Our approach to gender diversity by mtoddh on Friday September 13, 2013 @10:01AM (#6380471)
I can tell you this: anyone who thinks that artificially shrinking the pool of experts which you can pick to speak at a conference won't affect the quality of the presentations is deluding themselves.

Whether this is true or not, the parent commenter is right - quotas seem to be the direction that Westernized societies are heading for in the 21st century. I remember last year reading that the European Commission put forth a proposal requiring that publicly traded companies must have 40% of their non-executive board posts filled by women by 2020 [1]. Whether that ends up getting approved or not, it seems like a bellwether for how these issues are going to be framed.

[1] http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/european-commissi...

Re:Our approach to gender diversity by gametheoretic on Friday September 13, 2013 @10:25AM (#6380660)
>quotas seem to be the direction that Westernized societies are heading for in the 21st century.

Explicit quotas are a big no-no in the U.S. (where most things are concerned - you can find exceptions here and there). See, for example in university admissions: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regents_of_the_University_of_Ca...

IMO, legal risk surrounding hiring is THE reason consulting is growing so huge, so fast (in the U.S. at least). Even if the government were to foist quotas on everyone, hiring consultants instead of employees provides a way around it.

Re:Our approach to gender diversity by spindritf on Friday September 13, 2013 @07:42AM (#6379794)
Nobody may be thinking twice about the head of internal medicine being a woman. But they do about just regular physicians.

> We find that the median female (but not male) primary-care physician would have been financially better off becoming a physician assistant. This result is partially due to a gender-wage gap in medicine. However, it is mostly driven by the fact that the median female physician simply doesn’t work enough hours to amortize her upfront investment in medical school.[1]

Anyway, I think ibanking is in line before tech.

[1] http://www.anderson.ucla.edu/faculty/keith.chen/papers/Gende...

Re:Our approach to gender diversity by rayiner on Friday September 13, 2013 @08:13AM (#6379921)
Banking is more overtly sexist but banks have policies to hire women so you have more women in "front-line" roles. 14% of partners at Goldman Sachs are women. In which tech company are 14% of executives in technical roles (not HR or marketing) women?
Re:Our approach to gender diversity by RobAley on Friday September 13, 2013 @09:42AM (#6380357)
I currently work in the UK Medical Careers Research Group at Oxford University. [edit: this post isn't an official communication from our group!]

To give a UK perspective, what our research has found is that, in general, female doctors are only disadvantaged in their career (in terms of career progression and so on) when they have periods out for maternity leave and work part-time for childcare reasons. And then, they are only disadvantaged to a similar level as male doctors who took time out or work part-time for the same or different reasons.

In medicine, in the UK at least, there is a lot greater gender parity than there is in the Tech industry (which being a programmer I also am part of).

This conference looks really interesting, aside from the gender issues, and it's happening right here in Oxford. Its a shame I don't have funding to attend conferences, academia can be very fickle like that!

Re:Our approach to gender diversity by masklinn on Friday September 13, 2013 @07:54AM (#6379840)
That's a very different meaning of "thinking twice" than the one rayiner used.
Re:Our approach to gender diversity by RyanMcGreal on Friday September 13, 2013 @09:27AM (#6380273)
We might ask why it is still broadly assumed and expected that women will scale back their career hours so much more than men within a given profession. To suggest instead that women doctors should have become medical assistants is astonishingly blinkered.
Re:Our approach to gender diversity by yummyfajitas on Friday September 13, 2013 @10:55AM (#6380839)
You clearly didn't read the study at all.

The study doesn't assume that women will scale back their hours. They use data which shows it. Suggesting that female doctors should have been medical assistants is merely the result of the fact that they would have made more money (i.e., income - cost of education) if they did.

Re:Our approach to gender diversity by RyanMcGreal on Friday September 13, 2013 @10:59AM (#6380871)
I did read the study. My question is: why do women still take a lot more time off their careers for childcare than men? Presumably most of the children that a woman doctor is missing work to look after also have fathers: why are fathers not taking more responsibility to raise their children?
Re:Our approach to gender diversity by yummyfajitas on Friday September 13, 2013 @11:15AM (#6381009)
Most of the time the fathers are taking responsibility. They typically provide income while the mother takes care of the children. Or perhaps you are asking why individual couples choose this particular breakdown of responsibility?
Re:Our approach to gender diversity by RyanMcGreal on Friday September 13, 2013 @11:28AM (#6381094)
I'm asking why the prevailing pattern in North American couples is for the mother to give up years of career advancement to provide direct child care while the father continues to work, earning more money and a higher income.
Re:Our approach to gender diversity by yummyfajitas on Friday September 13, 2013 @11:54AM (#6381268)
Most likely more than 50% of women have a comparative advantage (relative to their husband) in caring for children.
Re:Our approach to gender diversity by RyanMcGreal on Friday September 13, 2013 @12:25PM (#6381455)
You're still begging the question. Shall I jump on the regress treadmill with you and ask why women have a "comparative advantage" with respect to caring for their children? I suspect you'd like us eventually to land on some innate, hard-coded difference between men and women that makes women's relative absence in tech and under-representation in pay and seniority in other industries okay, but that's bullshit.

Men are every bit as capable of looking after children as women, and it is a convenient insult to men to suggest otherwise: convenient because it just happens to uphold the gender imbalance that leaves men in much more powerful positions, relatively speaking, than women.

Re:Our approach to gender diversity by yummyfajitas on Friday September 13, 2013 @12:48PM (#6381602)
I don't know why, I haven't looked at the topic in detail. I just suggest comparative advantage because it is generally a good answer as to why two parties mutually agree to some particular economic arrangement.

I don't actually subscribe to collectivist moral theories that declare it somehow wrong when members of different groups are statistically more likely to make different choices. In fact, I believe most of the collectivist theories that do ascribe morality to statistics of this nature are not even well formed.

Re:Our approach to gender diversity by rayiner on Friday September 13, 2013 @01:16PM (#6381760)
There are enormous social pressures involved. Families and child rearing are deeply tied up in culture and history. Pretending that it's just parties mutually agreeing to a particular arrangement based on comparative advantage ignores the evidence plainly in front of your face in order to preserve some idealistic theory.

Between my wife and I, there is no comparative advantage when it comes to child rearing. We're attorneys, we both work at big firms, we make similar incomes (hence have similar opportunity costs), neither of us is any better with the kid than the other (thanks to the magic of modern technology, like infant formula). Yet from the moment she got pregnant, the pressure was on my wife to be the primary caregiver. People talked about what a shame it was that she was a busy professional and the baby had to spend all day in daycare (nobody ever said anything similar about my job). People will say things like "she needs her mom" when the baby cries (no: she's either hungry or bored or needs to be changed). When we stroll around in winter with the baby without putting a hat on her, busybodies never tell me to put a hat on the baby, always my wife.

If you're a woman and you have a baby, the deck is totally stacked against you from the minute you get pregnant.

Re:Our approach to gender diversity by Pxtl on Friday September 13, 2013 @02:53PM (#6382377)
Yup.

My wife took only 5 months mat leave. I took the other 7. People were generally envious and supportive of me, at least publicly.

My wife, on the other hand, got to hear all the negativity. People treating her as heartless for going back to work and "leaving" a 5-month-old, and being deeply suspicious of "trusting her husband with the kids", which kinda turns my stomache.

Honestly, most folks are pretty positive about it, but it only takes a few throwbacks to make you feel disgusting.

Re:Our approach to gender diversity by RyanMcGreal on Friday September 13, 2013 @03:48PM (#6382673)
When my children were quite young, I used to bristle when people who knew me would see me out with my baby or toddler and ask, "Oh, are you babysitting?"

I'd answer, "No, I'm parenting."

Re:Our approach to gender diversity by RyanMcGreal on Friday September 13, 2013 @01:21PM (#6381789)
A family is not merely or even principally an "economic arrangement". This reductionism of a complex biological, social and cultural arrangement to abstract economic principles is pretty much guaranteed to lead you to clean, rational conclusions that entirely miss the point of what you're trying to reason about. You end up talking about people and their experiences as if they are instances in a multi-agent system.