Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by ekidd on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:53PM
(#6375677)
I've sat in front of enormous piles of resumes, desperately hoping that one candidate in 10 might be able to code fizzbuzz or reverse a linked list. Yes, the candidate pool is awful on average, but this is a survivor effect—the good candidates tend to get hired, and a handful of unqualified candidates keep spamming their resumes.
But as an economist once told me, the market clears. If you're realistic about the market price, you can absolutely hire qualified people. That's practically the definition of "market price." Price signals work; when programmer salaries get ridiculous, plenty of competent people take an interest in programming.
You can save money by offering other benefits, hiring outside Silicon Valley, being better at evaluating candidates than your competitors, not discriminating based on age/gender, or by figuring out how to work with talented remote experts. But you have to make an interesting offer if you want talented people.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by anovikov on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:05PM
(#6375354)
Easy explanation is that there are a ton of people holding a STEM-related diploma but absolutely inept in this profession not even trying to compete. I know that from every class of software engineers in Russia, couple guys make a successful career, couple more become mediocre coders, couple more try for a while give up, rest not even bother...
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by SomeCallMeTim on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:11PM
(#6375386)
Exactly. I've interviewed recent UC Berkeley EECS [1] graduates and found they couldn't write a line of code, and Berkeley is a top 10 engineering and top 10 computer science school (or at least was a the time; haven't checked rankings recently).
[1] Electrical Engineering and Computer Science; their B.S. degree in computer science. I think they have a B.A. as well.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by SomeCallMeTim on Friday September 13, 2013 @01:49PM
(#6381953)
Probably given very controlled circumstances of a language they were really familiar with, they could have written something.
But they took my programming test and got a big fat ZERO on it. Some of the questions were very open-ended ("What do you NOT like about your favorite programming language?"), and I didn't even know they HAD a wrong answer until these two recent grads took the test, but they were very creative. ("I can't think of anything.")
The only code I actually asked them to write was in a very simplified language that was completely defined ON the test. They only needed to know IN GENERAL how programming languages worked. And I'm not talking about picky syntax problems, but a lack of even an attempt to write the code.
FWIW, the people I hired tended to completely ace the test. The one time that I ignored the results of the test because the guy talked well and seemed otherwise like a good fit, it turned out he couldn't do anything we'd asked him. There didn't seem to be many in the middle: Either they really got it and could ace the test, or they really didn't and they'd bomb badly.
This isn't news; haven't you heard of the Fizz/Bang problem? [1]
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by anovikov on Sunday September 15, 2013 @04:21AM
(#6388468)
Really curious, may i have a look at the test? I was hiring people for almost all of my career (on my first job, my first boos quickly realized i was too good to just let me type code) and i know things are really bad, but not as bad as you put it... Maybe your test is too hard?
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by SomeCallMeTim on Sunday September 15, 2013 @04:50PM
(#6390284)
My test is obsolete, AND is likely designed to get a different kind (class?) of programmer than you need (statistically speaking; I have no idea what you do).
At the time I was doing video game development. I still am, but WHAT you need to know as a game developer is different now than it was then. For instance, I still wanted people to know SOME assembly language concepts (and Berkeley EECS grads were required to take an assembly language course, so that wasn't unreasonable).
Game development is still harder than most kinds of software development ("most" defined in terms of number of people who practice each kind), but the specific knowledge required has changed a lot. There are probably awesome developers today who have never tried to code a line of assembly language.
This fact makes me sad, actually, because I feel that my grounding in assembly language gives me a perspective on WHAT the computer is actually doing that developers who have never seen a language lower-level than C can't really have. And I feel it's a healthy perspective to have. But I'm not filtering out applicants based on whether they know assembly language. At least not any more.
Seriously, though, one of the questions was "What do you not like about your favorite programming language?" At the time the question may have been "What do you not like about C/C++?"; I can't remember when I changed it. This is a question that is designed to gauge what programming concepts the developer in question is challenged by, or what corners of the language they have trouble with.
If they answer "Pointers give me trouble!", then they're too green, but if they answer "overloaded template and normal function selection priorities in C++ are too hard to remember," then I know they've been doing relatively complex things with the language. So it's a question designed to give me a glimpse of their current skill and expertise; none of the answers I imagined people would say are "wrong," even though some might make me not want to hire them.
But to answer "I can't think of anything wrong" showed such an amazing lack of imagination (or fear of revealing the above) that it was the only time that I felt they'd managed to give a "wrong" answer to the question. If you can't come up with anything wrong with a programming language that you are saying you're skilled in, then you're not sufficiently analytically minded to work in games. Or at least not in a small indie studio where everyone needs to be awesome at something.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by epoxyhockey on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:29PM
(#6375966)
I know a Ph.D. in economics who can't balance his own checkbook.
None of these anecdotes mean anything. Humans have strengths & weaknesses, experience & inexperience, interests & disinterests. Match the person with the job or train them if they aren't a 100% match.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by SomeCallMeTim on Friday September 13, 2013 @02:23PM
(#6382161)
>Match the person with the job
Absolutely.
>or train them if they aren't a 100% match.
If they're close, sure. If they're not, then odds are unfortunately good that they aren't trainable, at least with respect to certain categories of advanced programming.
I could probably train anyone with decent technical aptitude to do web page work, or simple CRUD backend server work. There are probably still people who couldn't learn it; I think there needs to be an aptitude regardless.
But core game programming (engine work, graphics work, but not simple scripting) and certain kinds of embedded development (especially if video is involved) are realms that I'm familiar with that have a higher barrier to entry, and where "training" is probably going to fail more times than not. As in fail 90% of the time or more.
I think the cutoff is when you go beyond the point where a topic can be completely "taught" at all, and instead the task itself requires the developer to have exceptional learning and analytical skills. If a developer is good enough at figuring things out to actually get the work done, then any training would be unnecessary, because you would be able to learn what you need to know to get started on the job. Then what a new developer needs isn't "training" but just "orientation" to the tools and methods used in the domain in question.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by robbles on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:05PM
(#6375766)
One issue I keep seeing in these kind of studies is the use of the "STEM" acronym itself.
I'm sorry, but with the current job market, this kind of grouping makes NO sense. The jobs and opportunities are mostly in the middle two letters - technology and engineering.
Science and mathematics are still tied to academia enough that only the real go-getters with the ability to self-educate and work out how to transfer their skills to other fields will easily find careers. Despite the flaws in most of the institutions offering engineering degrees, an education in engineering/technology is still the most straightforward path to a career, with the most applicable job skills being taught.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by drewying on Thursday September 12, 2013 @04:55PM
(#6376896)
I have a good friend who is a mathematician, masters degree. She works for an insurance company doing statistics as an actuary.
This is just based her anecdotes, but from her stories it sounds like the world of professional mathematicians/staticians is suffering from a talent shortage that completely dwarfs what we experience in the technology sector. A good mathematician is rare gold in the finance/insurance worlds right now.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by robbles on Friday September 13, 2013 @08:25PM
(#6384090)
That's a great example - Your friend sounds exactly like the people I mentioned who "work out how to transfer their skills to other fields". I think that these kind of people are outliers who underestimate the difficulty involved in doing this for others, probably because they're very talented people. What most people want to get out of their degree is a straightforward path to a job, not a stepping stone that they can use creatively to build their own career.
I suspect that the issue with that particular talent shortage might be similar to the software engineering one - it hinges on the definition of "good mathematician". If I graduated with good grades from a top university with a degree in mathematics, will I automatically have a good chance of being hired by a financial institution? Or do I need to somehow acquire domain-specific knowledge first and have the right personal network?
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by Balgair on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:10PM
(#6375812)
A couple of friends of mine decided to 'walk a mile in their shoes' and became hiring managers. Craigslist is a wonderful thing, especially since it is very cheap to post a job listing. My buddies put out a very generic job posting for the types of jobs they were looking for. It was a way to gauge the heat of the job market, to see the competition, and mostly to see what it was like. Their hypothesis was at least 100 resumes. And being good scientists, they posted in a lot of big metro areas.
14 total resumes came in, 7 from India. In 10 major US metro areas, and this posting lasting a cumulative 3 months among the areas they got 14 resumes in. 5 Cover letters. 3 of the guys were ok, and hirable.
It was a shock. They thought they were in a really hot market and the competition was fierce. That must be the reason they get no calls back. Nope, not at all. At least in the Craigslist sphere, there were no job hunters to speak of. Personally, I don't know what to make of the data either. Lots of jobs were posted, but no-one was there and answering. The only thing that came to mind was that MOST of the craigslist postings were fradulent, just like my friend's.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by Balgair on Monday September 16, 2013 @01:36PM
(#6394504)
Myself as well. Also, just driving over and handing them a resume has worked really well for me. I did this to 12 companies and got 3 interviews. Best ROI yet.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by hackula1 on Friday September 13, 2013 @09:11AM
(#6380194)
I would just expect a person posting a job on Craigslist to be out to scam me or have no idea of how expensive software is. No one wants to waste their time filtering through the postings asking them to rebuild facebook for $100.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by Balgair on Monday September 16, 2013 @01:38PM
(#6394512)
See, now I am not in software. I'm a hardware guy. I like the less desk bound jobs and have been lucky to get to do them for a bit. That said, I still have no idea where the job postings actually are.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by gopher1 on Thursday September 12, 2013 @12:55PM
(#6375306)
This guy linked to the IEEE Spectrum article, but I don't think he read it, because they address the issue about defining STEM workers, and despite his anecdotal evidence, they came to the conclusion that, yes, the STEM shortage is a myth.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by bowlofpetunias on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:25PM
(#6375477)
No, they don't address the issue in that article, they carefully circumvent it. Like all shortage-denial articles, they focus on education rather than actual practical competence.
There is no shortage of STEM graduates. There is a shortage of people actually capable of doing the jobs which, amongst other things, require a STEM background. And for most software development jobs, the latter isn't even the most important qualification.
The STEM shortage is a myth created by people who want to deny that there is a shortage of qualified knowledge workers by equating "qualified" to having a STEM degree.
Nobody actually in the business ever complained about a STEM shortage. We complain about a shortage of competent people.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by hackula1 on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:43PM
(#6375603)
> We complain about a shortage of competent people.
As an aside, software development is one of the most internally brutal and self-critical industries out there. We tend to consider anyone outside the top 20% to be entirely, unredeemably incompetent. It creates a huge drive in our industry to keep getting better, but I do wonder if the d* measuring contest might be holding us back at the same time. The ridiculously competitive nature of our field has already been attributed to unintended consequences like blocking out women and older people. I personally was drawn to the field due to its competitiveness, but I do wonder if sometimes we let "perfect" be the enemy of "good".
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by noonespecial on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:53PM
(#6375676)
>We tend to consider anyone outside the top 20% to be entirely, unredeemably incompetent.
The trouble is, in software, single individuals in that top 20% are capable of doing things in a short time that individuals from the bottom 80% couldn't do in 1000 man years. Software is funny like that, some people can think different kinds of thoughts.
So in a way, for certain values of incompetent, this is actually true.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by eli_gottlieb on Thursday September 12, 2013 @06:52PM
(#6377522)
In which case, merely adding more software developers won't help the problem. You need to add more people of the quality of the current top 20%, thus expanding that to "top 30%", "top 40%", and eventually the actual majority, hopefully.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by noonespecial on Friday September 13, 2013 @01:03AM
(#6378761)
I'm not quite sure why I collected the downvotes, but you're spot on. For example, I'm short and relatively uncoordinated. I have a few chronic physical problems in addition to this that make me "unredeemably incompetent" at the sport of basketball. I could work my ass off for the rest of my life and still never come within shouting distance of Michael Jordan. I simply cannot perform at an NBA level no matter what I do.
If there were a shortage of talented basketball players, it wouldn't matter how many copies of myself you were able to get into basketball training programs, you'd never get an MJ. We need a better system to find MJ's of STEM and allow their talent to work for us.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by geebee on Thursday September 12, 2013 @04:52PM
(#6376878)
"Nobody actually in the business ever complained about a STEM shortage."
Yes, they have, to the point where legislation is being considered to award green cards specifically to recipients of MS or PhD degrees in STEM fields.
I completely agree with you that STEM should be a red herring. But it's hard to say that a focus on STEM is circumventing the issue when the notion of a shortage of STEM degrees is specifically built into the proposed legislation.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by daurnimator on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:36PM
(#6375549)
This sounds to me like the issue is more university programs: people completing a STEM degree SHOULD come out of it able to take on a STEM job.
From the hiring side, I agree with the dearth of quality candidates, and on the job training is often the current solution.
From my own university experience: the wrong things were being taught, and depth was pretty much out of the question. I can only imagine its worse elsewhere.
Only due to my personal side projects did I end up getting the knowledge needed for a job.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by epoxyhockey on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:22PM
(#6375906)
This sounds to me like the issue is more university programs: people completing a STEM degree SHOULD come out of it able to take on a STEM job.
To be fair, college is not trade school, nor is it supposed to be trade school.
on the job training is often the current solution
10-15 years ago, this was standard operating procedure for college grads, as were decent training budgets to keep all employees up to date on skills. Only more recently have employers demanded a turn-key candidate while training budgets have been cut back or zero'd out.
It's pretty worrisome for the future. Many individuals in this thread complaining about lack of qualified candidates may find themselves unqualified to a future employer if they don't value training.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by trekky1700 on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:29PM
(#6375502)
It's a concerning trend. Lot's of people go into the fields looking for high salaries and job opportunities, and then have no interest and thus talent in the field. There's so many totally inept people with even graduate degrees in computer science.
At the same time, look into some of the top University's CS exams and they're writing code on paper. They're not training effective and talented programmers, they're training effective exam writers.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by dnautics on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:42PM
(#6375592)
This problem exists in the "hard sciences" too. There happens to be an intern in our lab, who is very motivated to do science, and actually fairly competent, but there are just some really critical things that are missing she just can't do basic mental arithmetic - it takes her minutes to figure out what volume to add to do a 1:20 dilution. Then she writes it down so that she doesn't have to do that calculation again in the future. She's always asking to make sure her procedure is correct, and has never creatively come up with an experiment on her own. This is compounded by self-doubt, there are procedures that need to be done extremely quickly, because there's an air-sensitive compound, and I've told her she needs to be snappy, and if she needs to, practice it 20 or 50 or 100 times to get the whole thing done under a minute or two, still no, and I think it's affecting the results, which of course, increases her self-doubt, so she tries to be more careful, which makes things slower, etc etc (she's not my intern so I can't be too aggressive in giving her criticism). This student has a master's degree and was applying to PhD programs at Harvard. I think Harvard rejected her, and the best grad school she got into had "people worse than her" (which I don't doubt, like I said, she's competent overall), so she's applying again this fall.
I can't take her aside and tell her, "you are not PhD material". I leave it to the reader to figure out why. She would be fine in industry as a lab tech. I presume something similar happens at a lower level where people who are techs, shouldn't even be at that level.
Contrast this with a high school intern in the other lab, who successfully built a giant 6 meter bioreactor that is actually being used to process waste at an industrial facility, and totally took down a professor that asked a dumb question during her "presentation on what she did".... I am terrified that she will leave STEM - she didn't get into as good a college as she should have.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by trekky1700 on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:47PM
(#6375630)
Wow, I didn't realize it was quite so bad everywhere. This really shows how desperately reform in the education sector is needed. Especially the last part, a student brimming with talent turned away and potentially changing fields because of it. That's scary.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by dnautics on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:51PM
(#6375656)
maybe I'm being pessimistic, she got into an good school that I respect, she just - deserves more.
EDIT: I guess I could be more specific.
In the state of california, there is the Cal State system and the UC system, the UC system is considered to be the "top tier" system, and the CS system is widely considered to be "slightly less than". She got into a CS engineering program, that I happen to think creates a substantial number of engineers that are superior to some of the UCs, but that may or may not be the appraisal of people who hire her down the line, especially as we move towards a more credentialed system, or if the system gets flooded with less competent engineers and candidate selection trends toward the superficial.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by dragonwriter on Thursday September 12, 2013 @07:51PM
(#6377735)
> In the state of california, there is the Cal State system and the UC system, the UC system is considered to be the "top tier" system, and the CS system is widely considered to be "slightly less than".
The CSU system is designed to accept the top 1/3 of California high school students, the UC system the top 1/8, so, as a system, UC is by design more "elite". But that doesn't mean that all UC campuses are (or even are intended to be) superior to all CSU campuses in all programs, and certain CSU campuses are very well regarded for certain programs.
(This is particularly true, IIRC, of certain CSU campuses undergraduate engineering programs.)
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by dschuler on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:26PM
(#6375940)
I went to a Cal State for undergrad, and had a great experience. None of my engineering or math classes were 'seminar-style', I always had access to my professors, who generally knew me by name. Most of the students come out being able to put something together on their own. I ended up going to to a private school for my master's, and was surprised to see so many people who wouldn't know which end to hold on a soldering iron. BUT - the student body was generally much more engaged and interesting, and I ended up having a much better time there. I just wasn't blown away by their academic superiority :)
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by dnautics on Thursday September 12, 2013 @04:02PM
(#6376565)
without naming names, there are DEFINITELY programs/whole schools in the UCs that are worse than many Cal States, in my opinion. Nonetheless, my opinion in this world doesn't count for very much.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by vonmoltke on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:48PM
(#6375635)
Well, they are in alignment with the industry then, where the big players seem intent on hiring effective exam writers based on their technical screening process. How do you pass your undergrad courses? Memorize data structures, algorithms, and definitions, and write code on paper. How do you pass a Google interview? Memorize data structures, algorithms, and definitions, and write code on a whiteboard.
I cringe every time someone asks a question about interviews on /r/cscareerquestions and the inevitable reference to Cracking the Code Interview or something similar comes up. I cannot fathom that you can, and should be expected to, study or cram for an interview. It makes the interview the equivalent of an undergrad test, with the same value as a signalling device. I'm not sure which feeds which, and I'm sure there is two-way feedback in this system, but I don't think fixing undergrad education alone will fix the core of the problem, nor will encouraging more students to pursue engineering degrees as programs like MathMovesU attempt to do.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by hackula1 on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:33PM
(#6375527)
IDK, I could see this the other way around too. If you are currently doing the job, then you must be qualified for it, or are soon to be fired. There are probably some small percentage of people who just slide under the radar, but I would think if you were entirely incompetent and unable to do your job you would not last long.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by hackula1 on Friday September 13, 2013 @08:53AM
(#6380104)
In most of the US, you just walk into an employee's office and tell them they are fired. If you tell them a reason that is discriminatory, prepare to be sued, but most of the time you are not required to give them any reason at all.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by walshemj on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:55PM
(#6375693)
For gross incompetence it's not really that hard in either the USA or the UK of course this just means your HR dept has some performance issues it needs to address :-)
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by dnautics on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:01PM
(#6375736)
depends on the state in the US. And let's say the HR dept has performance issues. How do you fire someone in HR? They're the ones that know all the rules and all the laws that could get you in trouble. Where I work slid by, managed to can the HR head, but they were only able to do it because 1) she was super-overpaid and there was a budget crunch - which can be a legal problem for nonprofits (overhead) 2) there was a pretty serious SNAFU involving federal funds that happened under her watch, so she could have been in legal trouble herself.
Also, gross incompetence is not necessarily the problem... Death by a thousand cuts.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by seiji on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:49PM
(#6375649)
Local anecdote: my last N interviews have gone from HR contact to phone interview to phone interview to take home project to (being flown out for) in person interview to ... rejection.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by angdis on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:23PM
(#6375463)
And the real reason that the "candidates are crap" is that too many employers no longer spend the time and resources to train their workers properly. Instead employees are expected to get hired with insanely specific skills and "hit the ground running" working for some clueless line and project managers who don't give a damn about what happens outside of their small-minded metrics.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by bowlofpetunias on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:42PM
(#6375598)
As a hiring manager, it happens very, very rarely that I encounter someone worth training.
When we're talking "crap" candidates, we're talking a complete lack of both talent and passion. It would be a waste of time and effort to try to train these people.
Education is part of the problem. I don't expect higher education to result in immediately applicable job skills, but I do expect it to weed out the fundamentally incompetent.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by hackula1 on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:30PM
(#6375509)
One more reason to work as a consultant/freelancer or for a small business (startups included). In these settings you have a lot of control over the tech stack and can optimize your skills for the changing market. You can also devote whatever reasonable amount of time you need to learning new things as you go. In most of these environments, polyglots are rewarded and encouraged, which means much less career risk, since you can hit the ground running on a wider array of projects.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by bcheung on Thursday September 12, 2013 @03:55PM
(#6376520)
You make it sound like competency is a bad thing. What a sad state when people don't value it and think it is someone else's responsibility to provide it for them.
"clueless line and project managers..." is an ad hominem and doesn't support your argument.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by rfnslyr on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:26PM
(#6375483)
If you're not studying stuff related to what you want to do when you get out of college, on your spare time during studies, you're already losing. It's not enough to come out as a grad. You need to set your sights on a very specific job, and start learning for it. All throughout my undergrad I studied mobile to death and did a ton of work in it. Had no problem landing a 150k+ job right out of undergrad, because I was incredibly skilled.
Not too many companies care about your GPA + the courses you did, the ones that do, will put you into a mediocre role loosely related to your profession since you have no specialty.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by tekalon on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:12PM
(#6375829)
The shortage is in jobs that are willing to take graduates/applicants that know that basics, or even has experience, and then TRAIN them on what they want. Those that can pass STEM are usually smart enough to be trainable. Companies are expecting schools to teach current skills (not just theory) or students to be 100% self motivated in learning those skills on their own.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by bcheung on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:40PM
(#6376061)
I'm the lead developer at a tech startup in Silicon Valley and I interview about 2-3x a week. There is definitely a shortage of competent workers here. We will typically extend an offer to about 1 out of every 5 candidates because they just can't code or don't have the experience in the technologies we use. I've learned that resumes are very puffed up and that having a college degree really doesn't make much difference in terms of a candidate's competency. I disagree with the article about salaries being stagnate. In startups, especially for web developers, competition amongst companies is fierce and has driven up salaries.
Many studies use college degrees vs open positions as their data but I think this is a flawed model because what I have found is that college degrees and education / competency is only a loose correlation at best.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by ifben on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:29PM
(#6375962)
"... how many grads do not have a decent grasp of elementary algorithms and data structures, and are not comfortable with code."
This is more a fault of computer science education than the student. I was taking 16 credits of upper division CS courses at [not renowned but not bad university]. Half-way through the term I had yet to do any programming. I realize that CS is about more than programming (my four classes broadly were proofs, computer hardware, methods of software engineering, and stats for scientists/engineers). But the only way to become good at programming is to do it consistently. One or two big projects towards the end of the term leaves you brushing up on old skills instead of building new ones.
I'll be attending Hack Reactor this fall because I want to become a good programmer, not vaguely familiar with everything CS has to offer.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by rizzom5000 on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:46PM
(#6376102)
CS isn't about programming at all. While CS can help make a programmer a better engineer, it's not intended to teach programming skills; which is much more a vocational skill than a science.
I think the primary reason so many development shops ask for CS grads, is not because they should have learned programming at university - it's because they've already been selected for intelligence by getting into a more selective hard science university program. If programming skills were more important than intelligence, these jobs could be filled with folks who have a 6-month certificate from ITT -- but hiring shops have evidently found out that they get a better product from CS departments.
I kind of feel that CS departments should really emphasize these points to prospective applicants so they can go to HackReactor instead of wasting their time in CS programs - but unfortunately they have little incentive to do so.
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by kbenson on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:39PM
(#6375571)
Is it possible that industry automation reduces the workers needed for some positions, freeing them to look for other positions, thus increasing the pool of candidates? That would go some way towards explaining why projected STEM job candidate numbers are always below reality.
Automation affects many jobs. Just because a job isn't replaced entirely by a robot or program, doesn't mean it hasn't been rendered significantly easier or less time consuming, reducing the personnel required.
CAD is probably one of the oldest examples of this. What's to say that similar changes aren't taking place in many industries now?
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by eli_gottlieb on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:34PM
(#6376009)
There are several different localized shortages, but also a general glut.
If you're trying to hire well-trained software engineers with high-level CS knowledge in the Bay Area, good fucking luck, and make sure to pay plenty because you're getting nothing otherwise.
If you're trying to hire medical device engineers in North Carolina (pulling this out of my ass, but you get the point), there is a glut of unemployed medicine and biology grads to choose from, many with top-flight skills and work experience.
Why do we keep employing these overly large categories that conceal more than they reveal?
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by robotcookies on Thursday September 12, 2013 @01:28PM
(#6375497)
This is a view I've held for a while... that the shortage isn't with people holding square pieces of paper with fancy latin on it proclaiming competence. Rather the shortage is a talent shortage and degrees are a very poor indicator of talent.
There was another article on HN a while ago and it stated that only about half of STEM workers have a STEM degree. Meanwhile, 75% of STEM degree holders didn't have a STEM job. Maybe the problem lies with the process of getting a degree?
Re:Is there a STEM worker shortage?
by vonmoltke on Thursday September 12, 2013 @02:12PM
(#6375826)
I agree the university process is part of the problem, but you need to be conscious of where the numbers come from. As the full Spectrum article mentions, different groups have different definitions of "STEM worker" and "STEM degree" that can vary the numbers significantly, so you may be comparing apples to oranges and not realize it.
But as an economist once told me, the market clears. If you're realistic about the market price, you can absolutely hire qualified people. That's practically the definition of "market price." Price signals work; when programmer salaries get ridiculous, plenty of competent people take an interest in programming.
You can save money by offering other benefits, hiring outside Silicon Valley, being better at evaluating candidates than your competitors, not discriminating based on age/gender, or by figuring out how to work with talented remote experts. But you have to make an interesting offer if you want talented people.
[1] Electrical Engineering and Computer Science; their B.S. degree in computer science. I think they have a B.A. as well.
But they took my programming test and got a big fat ZERO on it. Some of the questions were very open-ended ("What do you NOT like about your favorite programming language?"), and I didn't even know they HAD a wrong answer until these two recent grads took the test, but they were very creative. ("I can't think of anything.")
The only code I actually asked them to write was in a very simplified language that was completely defined ON the test. They only needed to know IN GENERAL how programming languages worked. And I'm not talking about picky syntax problems, but a lack of even an attempt to write the code.
FWIW, the people I hired tended to completely ace the test. The one time that I ignored the results of the test because the guy talked well and seemed otherwise like a good fit, it turned out he couldn't do anything we'd asked him. There didn't seem to be many in the middle: Either they really got it and could ace the test, or they really didn't and they'd bomb badly.
This isn't news; haven't you heard of the Fizz/Bang problem? [1]
[1] http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2007/02/why-cant-programmer...
At the time I was doing video game development. I still am, but WHAT you need to know as a game developer is different now than it was then. For instance, I still wanted people to know SOME assembly language concepts (and Berkeley EECS grads were required to take an assembly language course, so that wasn't unreasonable).
Game development is still harder than most kinds of software development ("most" defined in terms of number of people who practice each kind), but the specific knowledge required has changed a lot. There are probably awesome developers today who have never tried to code a line of assembly language.
This fact makes me sad, actually, because I feel that my grounding in assembly language gives me a perspective on WHAT the computer is actually doing that developers who have never seen a language lower-level than C can't really have. And I feel it's a healthy perspective to have. But I'm not filtering out applicants based on whether they know assembly language. At least not any more.
Seriously, though, one of the questions was "What do you not like about your favorite programming language?" At the time the question may have been "What do you not like about C/C++?"; I can't remember when I changed it. This is a question that is designed to gauge what programming concepts the developer in question is challenged by, or what corners of the language they have trouble with.
If they answer "Pointers give me trouble!", then they're too green, but if they answer "overloaded template and normal function selection priorities in C++ are too hard to remember," then I know they've been doing relatively complex things with the language. So it's a question designed to give me a glimpse of their current skill and expertise; none of the answers I imagined people would say are "wrong," even though some might make me not want to hire them.
But to answer "I can't think of anything wrong" showed such an amazing lack of imagination (or fear of revealing the above) that it was the only time that I felt they'd managed to give a "wrong" answer to the question. If you can't come up with anything wrong with a programming language that you are saying you're skilled in, then you're not sufficiently analytically minded to work in games. Or at least not in a small indie studio where everyone needs to be awesome at something.
None of these anecdotes mean anything. Humans have strengths & weaknesses, experience & inexperience, interests & disinterests. Match the person with the job or train them if they aren't a 100% match.
Absolutely.
>or train them if they aren't a 100% match.
If they're close, sure. If they're not, then odds are unfortunately good that they aren't trainable, at least with respect to certain categories of advanced programming.
I could probably train anyone with decent technical aptitude to do web page work, or simple CRUD backend server work. There are probably still people who couldn't learn it; I think there needs to be an aptitude regardless.
But core game programming (engine work, graphics work, but not simple scripting) and certain kinds of embedded development (especially if video is involved) are realms that I'm familiar with that have a higher barrier to entry, and where "training" is probably going to fail more times than not. As in fail 90% of the time or more.
I think the cutoff is when you go beyond the point where a topic can be completely "taught" at all, and instead the task itself requires the developer to have exceptional learning and analytical skills. If a developer is good enough at figuring things out to actually get the work done, then any training would be unnecessary, because you would be able to learn what you need to know to get started on the job. Then what a new developer needs isn't "training" but just "orientation" to the tools and methods used in the domain in question.
I'm sorry, but with the current job market, this kind of grouping makes NO sense. The jobs and opportunities are mostly in the middle two letters - technology and engineering.
Science and mathematics are still tied to academia enough that only the real go-getters with the ability to self-educate and work out how to transfer their skills to other fields will easily find careers. Despite the flaws in most of the institutions offering engineering degrees, an education in engineering/technology is still the most straightforward path to a career, with the most applicable job skills being taught.
This is just based her anecdotes, but from her stories it sounds like the world of professional mathematicians/staticians is suffering from a talent shortage that completely dwarfs what we experience in the technology sector. A good mathematician is rare gold in the finance/insurance worlds right now.
I suspect that the issue with that particular talent shortage might be similar to the software engineering one - it hinges on the definition of "good mathematician". If I graduated with good grades from a top university with a degree in mathematics, will I automatically have a good chance of being hired by a financial institution? Or do I need to somehow acquire domain-specific knowledge first and have the right personal network?
14 total resumes came in, 7 from India. In 10 major US metro areas, and this posting lasting a cumulative 3 months among the areas they got 14 resumes in. 5 Cover letters. 3 of the guys were ok, and hirable.
It was a shock. They thought they were in a really hot market and the competition was fierce. That must be the reason they get no calls back. Nope, not at all. At least in the Craigslist sphere, there were no job hunters to speak of. Personally, I don't know what to make of the data either. Lots of jobs were posted, but no-one was there and answering. The only thing that came to mind was that MOST of the craigslist postings were fradulent, just like my friend's.
The job market is stranger every-day.
This is the basic assumption, yes. It's why most of us don't job-hunt on Craigslist.
There is no shortage of STEM graduates. There is a shortage of people actually capable of doing the jobs which, amongst other things, require a STEM background. And for most software development jobs, the latter isn't even the most important qualification.
The STEM shortage is a myth created by people who want to deny that there is a shortage of qualified knowledge workers by equating "qualified" to having a STEM degree.
Nobody actually in the business ever complained about a STEM shortage. We complain about a shortage of competent people.
As an aside, software development is one of the most internally brutal and self-critical industries out there. We tend to consider anyone outside the top 20% to be entirely, unredeemably incompetent. It creates a huge drive in our industry to keep getting better, but I do wonder if the d* measuring contest might be holding us back at the same time. The ridiculously competitive nature of our field has already been attributed to unintended consequences like blocking out women and older people. I personally was drawn to the field due to its competitiveness, but I do wonder if sometimes we let "perfect" be the enemy of "good".
The trouble is, in software, single individuals in that top 20% are capable of doing things in a short time that individuals from the bottom 80% couldn't do in 1000 man years. Software is funny like that, some people can think different kinds of thoughts.
So in a way, for certain values of incompetent, this is actually true.
If there were a shortage of talented basketball players, it wouldn't matter how many copies of myself you were able to get into basketball training programs, you'd never get an MJ. We need a better system to find MJ's of STEM and allow their talent to work for us.
Yes, they have, to the point where legislation is being considered to award green cards specifically to recipients of MS or PhD degrees in STEM fields.
http://judiciary.house.gov/issues/issues_STEM%20Jobs%20Act.h...
I completely agree with you that STEM should be a red herring. But it's hard to say that a focus on STEM is circumventing the issue when the notion of a shortage of STEM degrees is specifically built into the proposed legislation.
From the hiring side, I agree with the dearth of quality candidates, and on the job training is often the current solution.
From my own university experience: the wrong things were being taught, and depth was pretty much out of the question. I can only imagine its worse elsewhere.
Only due to my personal side projects did I end up getting the knowledge needed for a job.
To be fair, college is not trade school, nor is it supposed to be trade school.
on the job training is often the current solution
10-15 years ago, this was standard operating procedure for college grads, as were decent training budgets to keep all employees up to date on skills. Only more recently have employers demanded a turn-key candidate while training budgets have been cut back or zero'd out.
It's pretty worrisome for the future. Many individuals in this thread complaining about lack of qualified candidates may find themselves unqualified to a future employer if they don't value training.
At the same time, look into some of the top University's CS exams and they're writing code on paper. They're not training effective and talented programmers, they're training effective exam writers.
I can't take her aside and tell her, "you are not PhD material". I leave it to the reader to figure out why. She would be fine in industry as a lab tech. I presume something similar happens at a lower level where people who are techs, shouldn't even be at that level.
Contrast this with a high school intern in the other lab, who successfully built a giant 6 meter bioreactor that is actually being used to process waste at an industrial facility, and totally took down a professor that asked a dumb question during her "presentation on what she did".... I am terrified that she will leave STEM - she didn't get into as good a college as she should have.
EDIT: I guess I could be more specific.
In the state of california, there is the Cal State system and the UC system, the UC system is considered to be the "top tier" system, and the CS system is widely considered to be "slightly less than". She got into a CS engineering program, that I happen to think creates a substantial number of engineers that are superior to some of the UCs, but that may or may not be the appraisal of people who hire her down the line, especially as we move towards a more credentialed system, or if the system gets flooded with less competent engineers and candidate selection trends toward the superficial.
The CSU system is designed to accept the top 1/3 of California high school students, the UC system the top 1/8, so, as a system, UC is by design more "elite". But that doesn't mean that all UC campuses are (or even are intended to be) superior to all CSU campuses in all programs, and certain CSU campuses are very well regarded for certain programs.
(This is particularly true, IIRC, of certain CSU campuses undergraduate engineering programs.)
I cringe every time someone asks a question about interviews on /r/cscareerquestions and the inevitable reference to Cracking the Code Interview or something similar comes up. I cannot fathom that you can, and should be expected to, study or cram for an interview. It makes the interview the equivalent of an undergrad test, with the same value as a signalling device. I'm not sure which feeds which, and I'm sure there is two-way feedback in this system, but I don't think fixing undergrad education alone will fix the core of the problem, nor will encouraging more students to pursue engineering degrees as programs like MathMovesU attempt to do.
There is also a flaw in the assumption that every STEM jobholder is qualified for a STEM job.
Also, gross incompetence is not necessarily the problem... Death by a thousand cuts.
I'm getting worried I'm actually incompetent now.
When we're talking "crap" candidates, we're talking a complete lack of both talent and passion. It would be a waste of time and effort to try to train these people.
Education is part of the problem. I don't expect higher education to result in immediately applicable job skills, but I do expect it to weed out the fundamentally incompetent.
"clueless line and project managers..." is an ad hominem and doesn't support your argument.
My first day was a hours instruction on the pdp11/03 then I was told to goto the company library get the book they had on FORTRAN and learn it.
Not too many companies care about your GPA + the courses you did, the ones that do, will put you into a mediocre role loosely related to your profession since you have no specialty.
Many studies use college degrees vs open positions as their data but I think this is a flawed model because what I have found is that college degrees and education / competency is only a loose correlation at best.
This is more a fault of computer science education than the student. I was taking 16 credits of upper division CS courses at [not renowned but not bad university]. Half-way through the term I had yet to do any programming. I realize that CS is about more than programming (my four classes broadly were proofs, computer hardware, methods of software engineering, and stats for scientists/engineers). But the only way to become good at programming is to do it consistently. One or two big projects towards the end of the term leaves you brushing up on old skills instead of building new ones.
I'll be attending Hack Reactor this fall because I want to become a good programmer, not vaguely familiar with everything CS has to offer.
I think the primary reason so many development shops ask for CS grads, is not because they should have learned programming at university - it's because they've already been selected for intelligence by getting into a more selective hard science university program. If programming skills were more important than intelligence, these jobs could be filled with folks who have a 6-month certificate from ITT -- but hiring shops have evidently found out that they get a better product from CS departments.
I kind of feel that CS departments should really emphasize these points to prospective applicants so they can go to HackReactor instead of wasting their time in CS programs - but unfortunately they have little incentive to do so.
Automation affects many jobs. Just because a job isn't replaced entirely by a robot or program, doesn't mean it hasn't been rendered significantly easier or less time consuming, reducing the personnel required.
CAD is probably one of the oldest examples of this. What's to say that similar changes aren't taking place in many industries now?
If you're trying to hire well-trained software engineers with high-level CS knowledge in the Bay Area, good fucking luck, and make sure to pay plenty because you're getting nothing otherwise.
If you're trying to hire medical device engineers in North Carolina (pulling this out of my ass, but you get the point), there is a glut of unemployed medicine and biology grads to choose from, many with top-flight skills and work experience.
Why do we keep employing these overly large categories that conceal more than they reveal?
There was another article on HN a while ago and it stated that only about half of STEM workers have a STEM degree. Meanwhile, 75% of STEM degree holders didn't have a STEM job. Maybe the problem lies with the process of getting a degree?
Meaning? (I can think of several possibilities.)