One way to compensate for the suffering caused by economic dislocation is to reduce the hardship of not having a job. More unemployment and welfare aid, with less degrading means testing would help. Better would be a basic income, with income earned from working always a bonus on top.
I.e. I've interviewed a number of people in the past year or so. I only recommended hiring one of them.
Can you tell me what sort of position was this for (developer, scientist, "unicorn"*, etc)?
Were the parameters for this candidate search "find us someone regardless of price" or was there some notion of "market rate" attached to it?
This sentiment comes from the idea that businesses facing a "shortage" can always hire good candidates by just raising their salaries. That is true, but it does not disprove a shortage--it just proves that good employees can be recruited from competitors if the wage is high enough. But if there actually is a shortage, all that does is move the shortage around.
There's also the issue of what is a sustainable salary expense in a given industry. Sure Inova could staff up with top-notch nurses if it paid them all $300k per year. But then how much would they have to charge patients to stay in business?
In the end, this a fun and easy argument to make because it requires no actual data about a given industry--just a preconception that businesses are cheap and manipulative. (Which they sometimes are--but again, that doesn't mean there's not a shortage.)
why does Dynamic Systems 101 goes out of the window when it comes to proponents of supply/demand economics? Positive feedback in a system - like rising prices increase supply - is not necessarily leads the system to equilibrium, in many cases it is a recipe for the system to swing even more widely out of equilibrium. What do they teach these days in colleges?!
The answer is that it is very difficult for people to change industries. It would be like if you needed gold for a product you're manufacturing, but only iron was available. No matter how much you're willing to pay for it, iron won't do what gold does. Only mining, or transmutation, can give you what you need.
We're mining new developers and nurses by educating youth. The question is, can we transmute factory workers?
[1] Just using these industries as examples.
We think that things would be better for everyone if we could train more people to be effective programmers.
The shortage should then be eliminated organically by more people being attracted to the higher wages. Therefore I tend to agree with the GP, if you are hearing about a shortage, it is probably just that employers are looking to avoid raising wages, so they are trying to make the market correct more quickly.
Yes, eventually, but how long does that take? A temporary shortage is still a shortage while it persists.
And it takes more than just being attracted to high wages; job applicants need to have the skills and experience to satisfy the demands of the position. How do they get those? If they're a laid-off 40-something parent of 2 with a high school education? That's the big question.
Like most of the U.S. economhy, it works because it is a free exchange in which both parties gain something. I could easily keep my data away from Facebook. But then I would not benefit from their services.
I think the real issue is hidden in the article--opportunity today is incredibly rich for those who have the right education...which not everyone has.
There are two issues here, actually. The first is whether our public education system is preparing youth to seize future opportunities. On the whole, I think the answer is at best mixed--but it seems solvable. We can improve our schools and make the students next year smarter than the year before. At least we have the concept of free public education as a platform.
The second is what happens to adults who lost their industries? Can a 40-something factory worker or lumberjack learn how to create Android apps that generate revenue? The answer here seems a lot worse. Not only does it seem harder for middle aged folks to radically change their professions, there are no free, and few low-cost institutions helping them do it. Online schools like Khan Academy seem exciting, but are very far from being proven answers to this problem.
There do seem to be openings in the middle--providing services to the educated people who can build moneymaking technologies. For example, I believe there continues to be a shortage in nurses nationwide. It's not easy to become a nurse or PA, but at least there are a lot of good community college programs for it.