What? You can't tell just by looking at someone if they have autism. You must have some sort of preconceived notions of what autism looks like. For example, here is two people in my family with autism (they are identical twins)
http://i.imgur.com/9PP5O6T.jpg http://i.imgur.com/aedlKYR.jpg
Rather than saying something incredibly ignorant like "I've never seen it," why don't we use science?
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0140673699...
http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=197365
http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa021134
Those are just some peer reviewed scientific publications disproving any association between autism and vaccines. If you aren't looking at real facts, you are just as bad as the anti-vacciners.
NOW, lets talk about how this got started.
The association was started by one study authored by Andrew Wakefield and published in The Lancet. Andrew Wakfield had serious conflicts of interests and it was later found he was paid money by British trial lawyers to prove the vaccine was dangerous so the lawyers could get rich suing. Hundreds of thousands of pounds we are talking. It was found he had manipulated evidence and broken other ethical codes to publish that paper in The Lancet.
The Lancet paper was partially retracted in 2004 and fully retracted in 2010, and Wakefield was found guilty by the General Medical Council of serious professional misconduct in May 2010 and was struck off the Medical Register, meaning he could no longer practice medicine.
The point to that being that, if vaccines do cause autism, he should have met someone with autism. The fact that he didn't seems to argue against the hypothesis that vaccines do cause autism.
BTW, are you aware what impression people might gain from the the vehemence and narrow focus (missing the broader point) of your response, in a discussion of anything related to the autism spectrum? Maybe you should work on reining in that behaviour instead of indulging it.
My oldest son has an ASD. I'm very familiar with the idea that those with a form of autism are not those who simply "look autistic".
It does no such thing.
There's an outbreak of preventable childhood measles in England at this very moment
This is a map of the Dutch Bible Belt: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bible_Belt_%28Netherlands%29 , and this is a map of the epidemic: http://www.nrc.nl/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/ANP-23877900-56...
And just for clarity: these are areas with a low population density.
My anecdotal experience among anti-vaccination people I've known is that they're only weakly correlated with religion or politics--leaning slightly left but still all over the map.
I have been made aware anecdotally how may times profit is chosen over safety when critical decisions are made... It has lead me to question some decision makers about the actual priorities for their decisions...
[1] I guess they had either neglected to get a booster, were not scheduled to receive the full series of shots, or the vaccine's efficacy isn't what it is claimed to be.
>My anecdotal experience among anti-vaccination people I've known is that they're only weakly correlated with religion or politics
Here is another anec-data point for you. I'm not anti-vaccine, but I am more skeptical / cautious than most (we selectively decline / delay vaccinations). I am also Atheist. My impression is that the skepticism is rooted more in lack of trust in authorities, than religion.
[1] for example, this case that happened in my old town had 3 symptomatic, but 175 or so others needing treatment: http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5341a3.htm
And I totally get the skepticism of authorities thing. I only developed what trust in medical authorities I have after doing prepress work on a lot of medical textbooks and getting more familiar with the literature. Frankly most of us don't have a chance of keeping up with the state of the field when even professionals can barely keep up.
Interested to hear your justification for declining / delaying vaccine's, but not considering yourself anti-vaccine.
I'm interested to hear why a five minute old infant is at risk of contracting Hep-B. Our kids will get Hep-B before they start school. Even if one of our kids did contract Hep-B, it is pretty unlikely that they will be able to give it to your children.
Rota-virus vaccine was suspended by the FDA temporarily,[1] We opted to decline this one even after the suspension was lifted considering seriousness of intussusception[2][3] compared the very low incidence of death or serious injury by rota-virus infection in the US. Even though the suspension wasn't related to the earlier intussusception problem, I considered the incident sign of poor QC and/or a lack of respect for the FDA by the manufacturer. We would probably reconsider if we had plans for international travel with the children, even though our oldest has probably been exposed/infected. (a fun story!) (It sure would be nice if antibody testing were cheap and widely available).
Seasonal Influenza - Declined based on personal negative experience and systematic reviews of vaccine efficacy[4][5]. Every single seasonal influenza vaccine I have taken has resulted in a miserable two-week flu-like state. I have never had a case of the flu as that was as unpleasant as my reaction to the vaccine. I understand most people are not affected so negatively by the vaccine. After reading the Cochrane reviews on the subject, I am inclined to believe that the seasonal Influenza vaccine is an unnecessary and rarely useful product.
Not that I need to worry about it yet, but Cervarix and especially Gardasil seem to have low efficacy WRT to the (possible) risks of the vaccine, especially considering the prognosis for those that contract cervical cancer (women rarely die of cervical cancer). I also find Merck's relationship over the matter with my state's idiot Governor particularly aggravating.
So, basically, if the risk of contracting and or having the illness is low, and if it doesn't needlessly endanger others (like MMR refusal for school-aged children) then I am going to take a good hard look at whether we really need the vaccine.
>not considering yourself anti-vaccine.
Anti-vaccine means you don't allow yourself or your children to be vaccinated. Our children do receive most vaccines at the scheduled time. We have opted to delay or forgo a few vaccines. Lumping people into two opposing factions has had a very negative effect on the debate, as it tends to do in a debate on any subject.
[1] http://www.fda.gov/BiologicsBloodVaccines/Vaccines/ApprovedP...
[2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22293889
[3] http://www.fda.gov/BiologicsBloodVaccines/Vaccines/Questions...
[4] 'Flu vaccine doesn't help elderly' http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20166072
[5] Please read the author's conclusions for this one. 'Vaccines for preventing influenza in healthy adults.' http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20614424
Because a baby whose mother is infected with Hep-B can be infected at birth, it's estimated that only 50% of the pregnant women who have Hep-B are identified, and babies can get Hep-B from other family members and caregivers.
See http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/PDF/rr/rr5416.pdf for the full details, but here are two relevant passages:
> Even with improvements in the management of pregnant women, only approximately 50% of expected births to HBsAg-positive women are identified (on the basis of application of racial/ ethnic-specific HBsAg prevalence estimates to U.S. natality data) for case management, which maximizes timely delivery of postexposure immunoprophylaxis (11; CDC, unpublished data, 2004). The need for proper management of women without prenatal care, including HBsAg testing at the time of admission for delivery and administration of the first dose of vaccine to infants <12 hours of birth, is underscored by the higher prevalence of HBsAg seropositivity among these women than among women who are screened prenatally (12). Even when maternal HBsAg testing does occur, certain infants of HBsAg-positive mothers do not receive postexposure immunoprophylaxis because of testing errors and lapses in reporting of test results (13), and infants of women with unknown HBsAg status at the time of delivery often do not receive a birth dose of vaccine (14).
> Children who are not infected at birth remain at risk from long-term interpersonal contact with their infected mothers. In one study, 38% of infants who were born to HBsAg-positive mothers and who were not infected perinatally became infected by age 4 years (64). In addition, children living with any chronically infected persons are at risk for becoming infected through percutaneous or mucosal exposures to blood or infectious body fluids (e.g., sharing a toothbrush, contact with exudates from dermatologic lesions, contact with HBsAg-contaminated surfaces). HBV transmission rates to susceptible household contacts of chronically infected persons have varied (range: 14%–60%) (65,66). High rates of infection also have been reported among unvaccinated long-term residents of institutions for the mentally handicapped (67,68), and, in rare instances, person-to-person transmission has been reported in child care settings (69,70).
Also, the vaccine is made from virus capsid protein expressed in Baker's yeast. There's no infectious material at all, making it a very safe vaccine. (Unlike the earlier Hep-B vaccine which had a danger of including viral DNA should something go wrong during purification.)
Well, we didn't elect to deliver in the back room of a whorehouse, or under a tree on the prairie. We went to one of the best hospitals in the country, where blood tests are done in advance of delivery, where these things are discussed and planned as part of the pre-natal pregnancy care.
Wife and I are both vaccinated, and apparently Hep-B negative. I have to make sure my kids aren't raped by Hep-B positive child-rapists, which is sadly too common.
> There's no infectious material at all, making it a very safe vaccine.
You keep missing something from my posts. I don't doubt the science behind vaccines. You don't need to convince me that vaccines are practically a modern miracle. I lack confidence in manufacturers, and in fairness of the NVIC.
You seem to think that Hep-B is only spread through sex and drug use, and from the mother through childbirth. This is incorrect. For example, one of the citations in the above report was to http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2626287 . It seems some 30% of Hep-B infections come from unknown sources.
> We investigated two situations involving hepatitis B virus exposure among children in day care. In the first a 4-year-old boy who attended a day care center developed acute hepatitis B; another child at the center, who had a history of aggressive behavior (biting/scratching), was subsequently found to be a hepatitis B carrier. No other source of infection among family and other contacts was identified and no other persons at the center became infected.
Before the vaccine, some 24,000 children got Hep-C each year. That's down about 90%.
As to the "very safe vaccine", nothing in that last line was meant to imply that you needed any sort of religious faith in vaccines nor that you doubted the science. It was meant to explain why failures by the manufacturer are less likely to lead to severe adverse effects than with the older vaccine. This is an engineering consideration and not a science one.
The previous vaccine was only "safe", and not "very safe." The older vaccine started with blood serum from people who had Hep-B, and purified it so only Hep-B proteins remained. This has a risk of infection should something go wrong in the purification process so that the full virus - or other viruses - somehow get through. This sort of failure would be very risky for newborns.
But the current vaccine, which is based on a genetically modified form of Baker's yeast, does not come from human sources. Since human viruses aren't in the source material, they can't enter the vaccine. There can still be other failure modes, but the most fatal - introduction of virulent particles directly into a newborn baby - can't happen through a process failure during vaccine manufacturing.
Think also of the oral polio virus. This uses an attenuated virus, that is, a mutant form of the polio virus which infects the child, but doesn't cause the symptoms. The child's immune system produces the same antibodies at it would the wild-type virus, which provides immunity. The problem is, the attenuated virus mutates in the body, and it can mutate towards a form which is deadly. This happens about once every 750,000 cases.
Again, this is not the type in the modern Hep-B vaccine - there is no infectious material at all - making it safer than oral polio virus. That's why I said Hep-B is "very safe."
>But the current vaccine, which is based on a genetically modified form of Baker's yeast, does not come from human sources. Since human viruses aren't in the source material, they can't enter the vaccine. There can still be other failure modes, but the most fatal - introduction of virulent particles directly into a newborn baby - can't happen through a process failure during vaccine manufacturing.
That is interesting and reassuring to learn. Thanks, I will also pass it on to Mrs. Fnord.
> So, basically, if the risk of contracting and or having the illness is low, and if it doesn't needlessly endanger others (like MMR refusal for school-aged children) then I am going to take a good hard look at whether we really need the vaccine.
But there-in lies why I would label you anti-vaccine. If the risk of disease is relatively low, you decline vaccine's - regardless of whether or not they are safe (e.g. " Gardasil seem to have low efficacy WRT to the (possible) risks of the vaccine").
> Anti-vaccine means you don't allow yourself or your children to be vaccinated.
To me, and most medical professionals, Anti-vaccine means you default to declining a vaccine, which you seem to do, despite no evidence of harm from the vaccine, and good evidence for safety.
That is the whole things with vaccines - the herd immunity is as important in protection as the vaccine itself. It is virtuous positive feedback loop.
A vaccine doesn't have to get anywhere near 100% protection to be effective - it just has to drop the viral coefficient below 1.
Vaccines aren't to keep individuals from getting sick; they're to prevent outbreaks and pandemics.
That they prevent most people who receive them from getting sick is an added benefit.
You'll have a lot better luck selling vaccines to people if they provide a direct benefit.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-23168519
National newspapers are very much involved. Journalists like to present two sides of the story as equal rivals for "balance", even when one side is science and the other is paranoid quackery. When it comes to public health, this is a disaster.
It was just sheer luck this happened when school was out, the school system here doesn't require kids to be vaccinated as most places in Canada require.
It's so easy for a stupid thing to escalate into a world-wide event all because of a few anti-vaccination idiots.
Not sure where you live.
There are two kids with autism on my block. Both young boys. Autism is a common disease where I live in the midwest. We have 3 large organizations that only work with Autistic kids.
My wife and I have 3 kids and vaccinate them selectively on our own schedule. We vaccinate our kids for the same things that we received as children, nothing more and nothing less.
> The stuff we vaccinate against is not harmless.
Our medical system wants to vaccinate for everything now, chicken pox etc.
Vaccinating on your own schedule is dumb. Do you have a MD? Did you develop the vaccine? Trust the experts.
Skipping vaccines is dumb. Science and medicine make progress. To put this in HN terms: this is like saying I'm going to build my startup's website using DOS and XTs, because that's what existed when I was a kid. It's a dumb idea.
If there's a vaccine available: get it. There is no scientific reason not to. Skipping vaccinations means your an irresponsible parent and member of society.
When I talked to my doctor about all of this, her hypothesis was that there was probably some other virus which weakened our immune systems to the point where the dormant chicken pox virus could get out and travel up the nerve endings and break out. Her thinking was that as a result of kids getting vaccinated, we're actually not exposed to the virus a lot any more. She felt that as a result shingles was becoming more prevalent in adults because you're not generating as many antibodies.
Through all of this, my daughter who was three at the time, also broke out in slight bumps on her legs. She had been vaccinated against the chicken pox, so the bumps went away and never developed into anything like a full blown case. I remember when I was a kid and got the chicken pox it was pretty horrible.
My point is really that there are side effects to everything. I haven't seen a study of whether shingles is on the rise, so I don't know if my boss and I were just unlucky. My preference is to still vaccinate, but really I'd love to see that particular virus wiped off of the planet.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varicella_vaccine
I'm surprised at the number of comments on a tech site showing fear of technology.
It is nearly impossible to find authorities on the subject who can calmly and rationally explain the risks and benefits, and help you evaluate the risk properly. It is also nearly impossible to find objective impartial information from any source. The "debate" on the subject is very polarized. Skepticism is often treated as heresy or idiocy.
We still vaccinate our children, but not for everything[2], and not always on schedule.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Childhood_Vaccine_Inj...
[2] We delayed the HEP-B at birth and opted not to take the rotavirus vaccine.
Right, we determined the risk of contracting Hep-B was very low for infants. The other risk factors are blood transfusions, medical malpractice. They will get it before they start school. There is also very low chance for an infected infant/toddler to spread Hep-B so, no ethical worries there, unlike MMR.
On the other hand, there is a direct link between not being vaccinated and getting sick. Probably why they want to vaccinate against everything. Even chicken pox can cause more severe disease like shingles [1].
You wouldn't want your kids riding in a car with only the safety features that existed when you were a child. Why would you do the same for their health?
Honestly, there are many possible adverse reactions, and honestly, I want to see lots of good data. I know it may be costly, I don't care. I want to see the little bumps and dips in the plots of efficacy and safety for various vaccines. I want continuous quality control. I want it published publicly where the incidences of vaccine related injury were investigated, a cause found, and a problem corrected. I don't question the science or the public benefit of vaccination. I question whether the safety of vaccines as they are manufactured, transported, and stored is as advertised.
This is from the product insert for DTaP, note it cannot be considered conclusive, because the data collection methodology is crap. Would the manufacturer or FDA allow autism to be in the following list if either could conclusively exclude it? Honestly, I hope these guys have it right[1]. I think it would be fantastic if the solution were so simple.
"Adverse events reported during post-approval use of Tripedia vaccine include idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura, SIDS, anaphylactic reaction, cellulitis, autism, convulsion/grand mal convulsion, encephalopathy, hypotonia, neuropathy, somnolence and apnea. Events were included in this list because of the seriousness or frequency of reporting. Because these events are reported voluntarily from a population of uncertain size, it is not always possible to reliably estimate their frequencies or to establish a causal relationship to components of Tripedia vaccine."
source: http://www.fda.gov/downloads/BiologicsBloodVaccines/Vaccines...
[1] http://www.bmj.com/rapid-response/2011/10/30/iodine-deficien...
This is all part of the cost/benefit analysis. How much do we need to spend in order to say that the data is good enough to use?
"I want it published publicly where the incidences of vaccine related injury were investigated, a cause found, and a problem corrected."
It is published publicly. Download the entire data set yourself. It's available at http://vaers.hhs.gov/data/index in CSV format and through the CDC WONDER on-line tool at http://wonder.cdc.gov/vaers.html .
Make sure to read the big warning messages. It's not possible to establish a cause from this data.
> More than 10 million vaccines per year are given to children less than 1 year old, usually between 2 and 6 months of age. At this age, infants are at greatest risk for certain medical adverse events, including high fevers, seizures, and sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). Some infants will experience these medical events shortly after a vaccination by coincidence.
> These coincidences make it difficult to know whether a particular adverse event resulted from a medical condition or from a vaccination. Therefore, vaccine providers are encouraged to report all adverse events following vaccination, whether or not they believe the vaccination was the cause.
How much money and time should we spend to determine a causal relationship? More importantly, what do we do when we don't have those resources?
This is all part of the cost/benefit analysis.
"it cannot be considered conclusive, because the data collection methodology is crap. Would the manufacturer or FDA allow autism to be in the following list if either could conclusively exclude it?"
You have misunderstood the list. It's a complete list of serious and uncommonly high occurrences. They are not allowed to exclude autism. More importantly, if they excluded something only to find that it shouldn't have been excluded, then they can be sued.
I don't know why there is an increase of autism in your area, or even if there really is an increase. But vaccines are a red herring.
http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-504763_162-20125260-10391704/hum...
As well as plans/experiments for vaccines against smoking, alcohol consumption... I don't think vaccines are what I thought they were any more. Viruses are not the main target for some of these...
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22895958
http://science.slashdot.org/story/13/02/15/184232/alcoholism...
So yes, we are being conditioned to be vaccinated against everything. Unfortunately, this is a profitable business for some, creating a feedback loop with questionable motives...
Of course in the 80s in Eastern Europe some things were just considered being a kid that I suppose will give you today some diagnosis.
Was chicken pox or mumps the one that boils your testicles if you get is as an adult?
I have also never seen a case of autism.
In a few years we will have outbreak of something preventable. I just feel poor for all the kids that had real reasons not to get the shots.
A friend of mine after very bad Hodgkin was with compromised immune system for 10 years. He was constantly sick and popping antibiotics like tic-tacs. If the herd immunity was not so strong he would have been dead.
The stuff we vaccinate against is not harmless.
I would also recommend Ben Goldacre's "bad science" where he makes one of the best analysis of the MMR scare insanity and its origins and development. It is mostly the media's fault.