And yet we do, often for years at a stretch.
As for-profit founders want to go to YC to earn a lot of money later, non-profit founders will want to go to YC to earn a sufficient amount of money later. Both will be motivated by creating impact.
But I don't think you should take for granted this and an important step in any non-profit validation is if the non-profit will have enough money to pay its leaders and employees. In regular for-profits it's just assumed that, if you raise enoughs funds or sell enough product, the founders will have their share. With non-profits that can be tricky.
Finally, congratulations, I think this is a great decision. I have being noticing the similarities between startups and non-profit challenges and they are pretty much the same. I applied a lot of "customer development" concepts at my last job on a non-profit, and now I am applying a lot of non-profit concepts on my for-profit startups.
The non-profit startups that are going to fit YC are going to be the ones that aren't in dire need of a market salary, who don't need the potential of a huge cash windfall to keep on grinding.
The sacrifices here will be made in the pursuit of 'success' (however you define that), and the pursuit of watching your organization be large enough to make a difference (these are also primary motivators of for-profit startups in my experience).
I was implicitly assuming founders of non-profits care about salary. I think it's very admirable that there are people willing to forsake salary for a greater social good. It sounds like this might describe the Watsi crowd.
I am only intimately familiar with one non-profit, whose founder spent years launching her non-profit --- with the financial support of her spouse's salary. I have heard anecdotally of other non-profits whose launch was only possible because the founder was financially supported outside of the non-profit.
But it doesn't have to be this way. I don't think it's intrinsic that potential founders must choose between salary and launching a non-profit. For example, founders could make a salary working part-time for for-profit companies and spend the rest of their time running their non-profits.
Maybe YC could help facilitate such work relationships. I think it would grow the pool of people willing to pursue non-profit endeavors.
Also in tech, its almost impossible to sell workers on the idea of a options-based windfall in favor of lower pay -- let alone the vague promise of 'success'.
http://www.coca-colascholarsfoundation.org/quest/relentlessl...
Samasource's founder was sleeping at a friend's couch for a while, while being a SAT tutor.
Note: I'm an ex-Samasource employee
I think a lot of people join startups for the same reason, just with the added benefit that they could end up cashing in.
I would highly recommend reading chapter on "Performance Philantrophy" from the book Richistan: http://www.amazon.com/Richistan-Journey-Through-American-Wea...
My only point is that while there is a __financial__ incentive for for-profit founders to eschew short-term salary, there is no __financial__ incentive for non-profit founders eschew short-term salary.
Despite my financial analysis, I still think this initiative could great for non-profits. I am really excited and optimistic to see what comes out of it.
Even that's not necessarily true; sacrificing short-term salary to stablish an organization where you could have a long-term, modest salary doing something you care about (and therefore can stay with over the long term) is a financial incentive. It may not appeal to the same people that a big cash-out payday from a for-profit startup appeals to, but its still a financial incentive.
I'm quitting my day job in January to launch a non-profit startup. The timeframe is more or less the same as YC, so I'm considering applying.
I've volunteered for a non-profit organisation where even full-timers didn't have a salary, including the founders, though their most direct expenses were taken care of by the organisation. These people didn't want money from the organisation because they didn't need it to stay alive and they knew it would be better spent directly on achieving their goals. It makes sense to me; you don't (and perhaps shouldn't) work full-time for a charity you're not passionate about.
*sensible
Venture capital economics is premised on founders accepting low initial salaries based on the hope for long-term big payoffs. Which makes it OK for seed funding to be very small (on the order of tens of thousands).
However, non-profits have no hope for long-term big pay offs and therefore have no financial incentive to seek small amounts of seed funding.
In other words, it is sensible for a for-profit startup founder to accept zero salary (or close to it). However, it is nonsensical for a non-profit startup founder to accept close-to-zero salary.
I believe the YC non-profit initiative could still be beneficial to non-profits for the sake of mentorship, networking, etc. But I don't think many non-profit founders will drop their day-job salaries to launch YC non-profit startups.
Edit: s/sensical/sensible/g